Technoblade’s story about Theseus is the most important speech of the entire story but not for the reason you might think
Disclaimer: I am referring to the characters the streamers put on in the story, not their actual personalities. This isn't meant to be an attack or critique of anybody.
Also TL;DR : Technoblade's speech embodies the true theme of the SMP's story perfectly.
With Tommy’s potential exile looking increasingly likely at the time of writing, many people in the fandom have drawn parallels of Tommy’s arc and character to that of Theseus, and they are obviously correct. Tommy, once the hero of L’Manburg, a character who put himself in great danger in order to protect his nation, now looks like he will be exiled and ostracized from that very same nation, just like Theseus. The parallels are obvious. However, I think people tend to overlook one key part of the speech that I personally believe has ramifications on the arcs of every single character, a part which is representative of probably the main theme of the entire story thus far, and something that challenges the very way we look at stories in general. What part of the speech is that?
“Do you want to be a hero Tommy?”
Here’s a question for you to dwell on. Given all the events we’ve seen occur on the server, from the disk war to the election, Wilbur’s corruption arc, Schlatt’s villainy, essentially the entire plot up to this point, what do you think the point was (aside from entertainment obviously)? What were the themes of the story, what was it trying to say. To this you can respond with a handful of things, such as the cost of revolution and what it takes to lead a nation, the way power corrupts and the foleys of government. These are all things that the story pays careful attention to, but I think they all fall under the umbrella of one larger, overarching theme.
The story of the DreamSMP centres around one, fundamental question: What does it mean to be the hero?
Let’s talk about how the story is told for a bit. Almost every member of the SMP streams, mostly on Twitch. This is an important aspect to consider especially given how story-based the server often is, because live streaming works unlike any other story-telling medium out there, because of the way the audience is involved. The lines between the events on screen and the fourth wall are far more blurred. Viewers can leave their thoughts, opinions and input as the events happen, whereas the opinions you may hold about a movie or a book won’t stop the story from going in whatever direction it was planned to go in (like you can’t yell POGCHAMP! In the middle of Endgame and expect the heroes to react). The only other artistic medium that has audience involvement of this kind is video games, however even then there is only such a degree to which the characters in question can be aware of what lies beyond the fourth wall. What boils down to is that the audience has an elevated level of involvement and attachment to the story and its characters, which is in turn reflected back onto the audience from the characters. This is only elevated further with how much of the story of the DreamSMP is improvised, meaning that often the characters react just as the audience would to everything that goes down (think about how everyone reacted to Eret’s betrayal or Schlatt exiling Tommy and Wilbur). Okay, but what does this all have to do with heroes?
Well because of the fact that almost everyone on the SMP streams and thus viewers likely have someone they may prefer, it means that everyone ends up following the journeys of their favourite streamers. We tend to start sympathizing with their causes more. Subconsciously or not, we start seeing them as the protagonists of their own story. We may even start viewing them as the good guys, as the heroes.
And because of how much the audience’s feelings can be mirrored by the streamers, this means that some characters may even start to see themselves as the heroes in their own stories. Characters like Wilbur.
Wilbur’s arc is a perfect example of how this mentality can go absolutely haywire. Wilbur was a hero in the eyes of his viewers, how could he not be? He was a revolutionary, a brave man who was willing to go to the most powerful person on the server and tell him to suck it, before establishing his own free independent nation. At the same time, he imposed himself as the leader of that nation, aimed to have a blatantly undemocratic election with his party as the only candidate, tried to make it as difficult as possible for other parties to contest, lost that election and then decided to essentially start a coup. The heroic image Wilbur had crafted for himself was completely inconsistent with his true actions and motives. This contradiction drove him to insanity, and he decided to get rid of L’Manburg not because he did not want anyone else to have it, but because he did not want his legacy to be tarnished by something that was so dear to him. Wilbur WAS L’Manburg, and he did not want his nation to represent the very thing he fought against.
THIS is the danger wanting to be a hero, of wanting to be the protagonist of every situation, something Tommy is known for. There eventually comes a point where you must accept that you can be and often are the villain in someone else's story. This will end up being Tommy’s downfall, because not every situation demands that HE insert himself as the hero or the good guy, because eventually the only person who will see him as such will be himself.
This is why I believe Techno’s speech about Theseus is so profound, because it perfectly echoes the main and greatest theme of the SMP in my opinion: what it means to be a hero and the consequences that come with it. It is a theme that works so well within the medium through which the story is told and it works on a meta level as well, making us question the very way we consume and analyse narratives, who we see as the good or bad guys in a story. It forces us to ponder on who lives, who dies, and who’s story gets told.
Posted Dec 4, 2020, 4:45 PM UTC · edited
Bro that last line sent chills down my back... probably because it’s reminiscent of “who lives, who dies, who tells your story” which is from hamilton
That was exactly what I had in mind when I wrote it, glad you caught the reference :D
Man I was listing to them sing in my head while reading it.