r/dreamsmp•
Bonables

Technoblade’s story about Theseus is the most important speech of the entire story but not for the reason you might think

Disclaimer: I am referring to the characters the streamers put on in the story, not their actual personalities. This isn't meant to be an attack or critique of anybody.

Also TL;DR : Technoblade's speech embodies the true theme of the SMP's story perfectly.

With Tommy’s potential exile looking increasingly likely at the time of writing, many people in the fandom have drawn parallels of Tommy’s arc and character to that of Theseus, and they are obviously correct. Tommy, once the hero of L’Manburg, a character who put himself in great danger in order to protect his nation, now looks like he will be exiled and ostracized from that very same nation, just like Theseus. The parallels are obvious. However, I think people tend to overlook one key part of the speech that I personally believe has ramifications on the arcs of every single character, a part which is representative of probably the main theme of the entire story thus far, and something that challenges the very way we look at stories in general. What part of the speech is that?

“Do you want to be a hero Tommy?”

Here’s a question for you to dwell on. Given all the events we’ve seen occur on the server, from the disk war to the election, Wilbur’s corruption arc, Schlatt’s villainy, essentially the entire plot up to this point, what do you think the point was (aside from entertainment obviously)? What were the themes of the story, what was it trying to say. To this you can respond with a handful of things, such as the cost of revolution and what it takes to lead a nation, the way power corrupts and the foleys of government. These are all things that the story pays careful attention to, but I think they all fall under the umbrella of one larger, overarching theme.

The story of the DreamSMP centres around one, fundamental question: What does it mean to be the hero?

Let’s talk about how the story is told for a bit. Almost every member of the SMP streams, mostly on Twitch. This is an important aspect to consider especially given how story-based the server often is, because live streaming works unlike any other story-telling medium out there, because of the way the audience is involved. The lines between the events on screen and the fourth wall are far more blurred. Viewers can leave their thoughts, opinions and input as the events happen, whereas the opinions you may hold about a movie or a book won’t stop the story from going in whatever direction it was planned to go in (like you can’t yell POGCHAMP! In the middle of Endgame and expect the heroes to react). The only other artistic medium that has audience involvement of this kind is video games, however even then there is only such a degree to which the characters in question can be aware of what lies beyond the fourth wall. What boils down to is that the audience has an elevated level of involvement and attachment to the story and its characters, which is in turn reflected back onto the audience from the characters. This is only elevated further with how much of the story of the DreamSMP is improvised, meaning that often the characters react just as the audience would to everything that goes down (think about how everyone reacted to Eret’s betrayal or Schlatt exiling Tommy and Wilbur). Okay, but what does this all have to do with heroes?

Well because of the fact that almost everyone on the SMP streams and thus viewers likely have someone they may prefer, it means that everyone ends up following the journeys of their favourite streamers. We tend to start sympathizing with their causes more. Subconsciously or not, we start seeing them as the protagonists of their own story. We may even start viewing them as the good guys, as the heroes.

And because of how much the audience’s feelings can be mirrored by the streamers, this means that some characters may even start to see themselves as the heroes in their own stories. Characters like Wilbur.

Wilbur’s arc is a perfect example of how this mentality can go absolutely haywire. Wilbur was a hero in the eyes of his viewers, how could he not be? He was a revolutionary, a brave man who was willing to go to the most powerful person on the server and tell him to suck it, before establishing his own free independent nation. At the same time, he imposed himself as the leader of that nation, aimed to have a blatantly undemocratic election with his party as the only candidate, tried to make it as difficult as possible for other parties to contest, lost that election and then decided to essentially start a coup. The heroic image Wilbur had crafted for himself was completely inconsistent with his true actions and motives. This contradiction drove him to insanity, and he decided to get rid of L’Manburg not because he did not want anyone else to have it, but because he did not want his legacy to be tarnished by something that was so dear to him. Wilbur WAS L’Manburg, and he did not want his nation to represent the very thing he fought against.

THIS is the danger wanting to be a hero, of wanting to be the protagonist of every situation, something Tommy is known for. There eventually comes a point where you must accept that you can be and often are the villain in someone else's story. This will end up being Tommy’s downfall, because not every situation demands that HE insert himself as the hero or the good guy, because eventually the only person who will see him as such will be himself.

This is why I believe Techno’s speech about Theseus is so profound, because it perfectly echoes the main and greatest theme of the SMP in my opinion: what it means to be a hero and the consequences that come with it. It is a theme that works so well within the medium through which the story is told and it works on a meta level as well, making us question the very way we consume and analyse narratives, who we see as the good or bad guys in a story. It forces us to ponder on who lives, who dies, and who’s story gets told.

Posted Dec 4, 2020, 4:45 PM UTC · edited

87150
Puppyl•

Bro that last line sent chills down my back... probably because it’s reminiscent of “who lives, who dies, who tells your story” which is from hamilton

95
BonablesOPYOOOOOO SUCK IT GREEN BOIII•

That was exactly what I had in mind when I wrote it, glad you caught the reference :D

43
AidanOrphanage•

Man I was listing to them sing in my head while reading it.

8
TheGreatDownvotar•

I love this

67
BonablesOPYOOOOOO SUCK IT GREEN BOIII•

Thank you :D

24
PatitasfritasManberg•

big brain analysis, we love to see it.

56
BonablesOPYOOOOOO SUCK IT GREEN BOIII•

Thank you so much!

17
Night_fall4Technochan best anarchist UwU•

This is a very interesting analysis. After thinking about it, I would tend to agree that one of if the main theme of DreamSMP is exactly what you said: "What does it mean to be a hero?"

42
Firebird_charlie•

He wasn't an english major for nothing

5
phiniteh•

my man. this is incredibly well written and it perfectly reflects the narration of the dream smp storyline. it gives a new perspective on an already well-written speech, and it only makes the story even better. i wish i could compliment you more, but sadly i cannot put feelings and thoughts into words as gloriously as you do. good job. if i were your english teacher i'd give you an A on this analysis essay. much love. (:

31
BonablesOPYOOOOOO SUCK IT GREEN BOIII•

Stop it you're making me blush XP

I'm really glad you enjoyed it!

8
wombatwaferLittle Penis Land•

Uhhh spoilers for the exile stream?

Now that the recent stream is over (with the decision of whether or not tommy would be banished) I think we can really see that no one in the story is the hero. Tubbo was only doing what was best for the country but he soured his relationship with his friend that he had stuck with since the beginning. Tommy is in the wrong for burning down George’s house but Dream was extreme for demanding banishment. From Dreams perspective, he’s only keeping the SMP peaceful. Though, it should be noted that everyone’s perspective is limited and not everything is known to everyone, which affects the audiences interpretation of the story.

Tommy makes a good point when he states that he gave up everything for l’manburg, as he originally gave up his discs because Dream wouldn’t give them independence. However, he traded Dream the discs and then stole one of them back. Is Tommy in the wrong for wanting the discs that he traded back? Maybe. A good thing to think about before trying to answer this question is that Dream wouldn’t let them separate themselves from the DreamSMP if he hadn’t traded those discs. BUT before that they had a duel which Tommy lost... but he also lost a life for l’manburg. However... a trade is a trade. So, almost from the very start there is a bit of a gray area with the person who is most widely considered the protagonist (but this can be subjective as it demands on who you tend to watch the most).

Also another interesting thing is how Wilbur, once he and Tommy left, doesn’t want to think about what alive Wilbur did. Should Ghost Wilbur have to be responsible for the things he did alive even if he doesn’t remember? Another very open-ended question.

The subplot with Mexican L’manburg is also very fun to watch as it lets other people have a role in the story.

Honestly, I think that overall the story does a good job of letting people be able to support whoever they want to. No one IS the good guy anymore, just some people have done things that aren’t as bad as others. It’s just everyone doing what they think is right.

Also it’s really cool seeing people to interpret this story in different ways and I really liked your analysis :)

19

I think Tommy's ego will also be his downfall since he never admits or thinks that's he's when he IS wrong. Doing that will sour relationships with his own allies and friends and Tubbo's responsibility is way greater than Tommy's now since a whole country is in their hands, their actions reflect on the people. Tommy can't mature enough to realize that he has to make decisions for the people, not himself anymore. Tubbo has realized that and decided that even though they will lose their friendship, a sacrifice will have to be made for peace.

12
achen5265041•

Tommy’s Ego is definitely going to be his downfall, since in the end, Tommy’s the one whose acting like he can get away with destroying THE KING of Dream SMP’s home. Not only that, but Tommy’s emotionally manipulating Tubbo in order to stay in L’manberg for who knows why, aside from it being the land he fought for. Tommy is essentially the classic Greek tragedy since during Techno’s stream during the battle for Manberg (It was called Manberg at the time), the aftermath, where Techno entered his own bunker, he reads super chats, and one of which said that Greek Heroes often were tragic due to their ego, which had Techno say that he doesn’t have an ego. Tommy’s ego might have been able to get away from previous mistake, but now it can’t. Dream’s just too powerful. I doubt Dream’s doing this for Tommy, but George is known to be Dream’s friend, which is why Dream is asking Tubbo to banish Tommy. In my opinion, Dream should have asked Tommy to build George a new house, but we know that Tommy allegedly stole as well. This makes me think that Tommy has done too much, and thus why Dream does make a point on banishing Tommy.

7
wombatwaferLittle Penis Land•

Yeah it all comes down to whether Tommy should be selfish for his discs, as they’re not just discs any more, they are basically the physical form of power on the SMP. Is it justified for him to get them back? Should he cast aside what he wants? Has he sacrificed enough to be allowed to be selfish? It just depends on your viewpoint of his character :).

His ego definitely caused a problem because he should’ve know the repercussions to burning down someone’s house and I hope we see an arc about him growing out of his ego; I’d be satisfied seeing him grow a bit more chaotic or grow more into caring for his friends even when he has something taken away from him. Both of those arcs seem like they could be very well written and lead to more interesting plot lines.

With Tubbo exiling him for peace, I get Tubbos decision because it’s HIS country now, even if Tommy sacrificed things in the past for it. Now he’s jeopardizing it, making Tubbo’s job as president harder. Unfortunately, part of me is somewhat skeptical due to the fact that they basically started making a hit list with Technoblade and Dream on it, inevitably just creating another war. That’s just my interpretation though and I really like what you had to say :)!

7

Another thing I think Tommy needs to realize is that the discs are only powerful since he wants them. If Tommy can let go of his emotions for those discs like Dream did with Spirit then he can become way more powerful himself. They are just discs after all.

3
BonablesOPYOOOOOO SUCK IT GREEN BOIII•

That's one of the best parts of the SMP in my opinion: no one is the definitive hero. Everyone has their own stories to tell and their own perspectives on every situation, and it's the kind of story that you can really only convey effectively through live streaming because of the multiple outlooks. Interesting food for thought, notice how 2 of the main "villains" Dream and Schlatt don't stream, how we never see their side of the story?

8
SpookedSquid•

i love this too :o and also no one talking about how dream straight up dethroned george then argued how everyone else causes all the problems- oop

7
Slaya12345•

I just want to say, the best part of this essay is that Techno wrote that speech entirely on his own, independent from Wilbur's scripting for the rest of the story.

13
BonablesOPYOOOOOO SUCK IT GREEN BOIII•

Techno's role playing is genuinely unparalleled once he really gets into it.

4
devastator6395•

YEAH ENGLISH MAJOR

4
SugarAndScarves•

You wrote this so well!!

11
slayerofpoop06•

I wonder if they're going to publicly release the script after the SMP ends?

10
SpookedSquid•

i don’t think they will cuz a lot of things they did were probably improvised and went off script

6
FairyRave•

Considering they said time and time again that it is a role playing server, it’s really unlikely that they actually have a full blown proper script. It’s likely more of a ‘blueprint’ kind of script where it has the major roles each member of the server plays and a general outline on what direction they would move the story forward. Maybe they even include some quotes they may plan to say on stream, otherwise, it all comes down to adding their own dialogue when they stream live and bounce off of each other depending on the situation.

3
KarlolololololoTechnochan best anarchist UwU•

And the fact that It's technoblade who gave the speech is quite fitting. So far, Technoblade is the only one who breaks the fourth wall in full rp mode.

When Technoblade said that he was under peer pressure, or that anyone he kills wil simply respawn, that's not him breaking the immersion, its him seeing beyond the veil. He himself said in character (at least I think so) that he hears a lot of voices in his head telling him many things but mostly they ask for blood. The voices of course, is us, the chat.

We often dismiss his fourth wall breaking as him being a comic relief, or him just plainly not roleplaying. But what if it's something more?

9
BonablesOPYOOOOOO SUCK IT GREEN BOIII•

I actually never looked at it that way, that's a genius point. Wait, so considering that Techno is one of the most OP characters, and that he can see beyond the fourth wall, would that technically make him the Sans of the server 🤔

Just a hunch of course XD

7
spaceyish•

this is poggers

6
XYolbertZ•

this is insane

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
SpookedSquid•

woah

3
capitalinkbb•

This is so true! I've been trying to kind of wrap my head around the themes of storytellimg on the smp. (I only started following around the election so I didn't have much of the foundation, but since then, the story has kind of laid itself out). This gives me a great perspective to continue analysis from. And great writing op. :)))

3
Ender_767•

Yo dude you wrote a facking essay! I love it, lol.

3
Infinity_Ish•

Samee!! It’s so goooodddd

3

I think very similarly, the audience has a very important role in the story since the major plot lines have been decided on audience poles which makes me think that one of the lessons of the story are that, no matter who you are, no matter your ranking, your personality, anything, your actions will affect others in anyway possible. Like the audience supporting their streamer and voting on polls.

3
BonablesOPYOOOOOO SUCK IT GREEN BOIII•

Absolutely. The polls are a perfect example of the greater role the audience plays in the story, and they show just how great of an impact your decisions can have, and no matter what, they will come back to bite you eventually.

2
CheeseBonez•

I actually pondered the meaning of every bit of Techno's speech and you summed up the part I was stuck on exactly how I envisioned it, except I didn't know how to sue words.

Amazing

You can write a book or a movie.

Big brain

3
Fallout_Nerd101•

And through it all, all the fighting and drama. Politics and exiling, Techno knew what would happen if he were to try and step up. So he fled, and started a second potato war with the local village in Siberia

3
Firebird_charlie•

Theyre only villains if we dont hear their story

3
BonablesOPYOOOOOO SUCK IT GREEN BOIII•

Examples: Schlatt and Dream

2
Trash_enby•

im listening to this after i copy and pasted it..... its to late to read

2
Trash_enby•

thank god for text to speach

2