Played the demo, loved it. Played the release, major issues.

Spoiler

Although I am quite appreciative of the devs for seeing this game to release, it had some major issues that I feel almost break the cohesiveness of the game.

First is the poor quality of translation. Certain translations were so poor that they almost broke the game because I was deprived of critical information I needed to understand the policies I was pursuing. One minor example is the use of the word "centrum" to refer to a "downtown" or "central business district" - this word is NEVER used in English and I had to infer from context what it meant. Not all gamers will be willing or able to do this, and these issues cropped up in every single chapter. I understand that the devs are Turks living in Germany, but, as they were writing the game with an English speaking audience in mind, quality of proofread should be higher on their list.

Second, programming bugs. There are certain segments where I received notifications that clearly were mistimed or the opposite of the decision path I had chosen - like informing Marcel Koronti about the investigations against HOS and Nia finding nothing against him, yet the next day getting a notification that that same failed investigation had found his to the mafia and arrested him. I can only assume the programming in this section had a bug in it that triggered the wrong result. This happened multiple times.

Third, "topicality". From the demo to the release, I noticed a hamfisted inclusion of the pandemic and protests against police brutality into the game in order to make it seem "topical" and give players something to relate to, but in my opinion these detract immensely from the immersion because they were hastily and poorly implemented. Postmodern philosophical theory was in its infancy at the time of this game, and "systemic racism" is not a concept that would have been mature enough to spawn a movement yet - people were concerned much more with imperialism, national liberation, and the awakening class consciousness that Marxism ("Malyevenism") had unleashed. Secondly, if most Sords were so socially conservative at the time, it wouldn't make sense for them to have such an oppositional view to one of the basic functions of a society, which is security. The type of anarchic philosophy behind the modern BLM protests are an outgrowth of a long-growing and postmodern libertarian streak which uniquely developed in the USA. It doesn't make sense for such a traditional society to be moving in that direction, at least yet.

Posted Dec 6, 2020, 5:24 AM UTC

48
Davincier•

I saw the Bluds as a kurd analogue, not some sort of blm reference, and their problems have been going on since before the era the game takes place in

Outbreaks of disease are hardly new as well and the polio vaccine played a part in the cold war!

10
doofpooferthethird•

Yeah I was thinking exactly that. I thought the Blud issue was a dead ringer for the political situation of the Kurdish people in real life.

And as for anarchism, political anarchy was actually way more popular in the old days, unlike today, where it’s rarely referenced by name and is considered niche, except when it comes to organizing specific social movements. In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, anarchists were almost as popular as the communists. That only changed once the communist states purged pretty much all of them, and anarchist thought fell by the wayside to communism in other countries.

And I wouldn’t say BLM is an outgrowth of postmodernist philosophy. Postmodernism is an umbrella term that encompasses a lot of different things. But BLM is an anti-racist movement with parallels to civil rights movements in many other countries, movements which predate postmodernist philosophy by decades. And I wouldn’t characterize BLM as a “libertarian” movement either, once again, BLM encompasses a lot of different political philosophies, with the common thread being opposition to police violence against minorities. However, there isn’t a unified push to minimize or remove the state, rather the effort is mostly focused on reforming the parts of the state that are the most objectionable to them (police, legal system)

If you think ethnic minority protests are a recent US phenomenon that doesn’t occur in “traditional societies”, you haven’t read enough history. Ethnic, tribal and religious discrimination is as old as civilization, and almost every modern nation, even the most socially conservative and authoritarian ones, has ethnic minority advocacy (and sometimes terrorist) groups and movements like BLM.

And yeah, pandemics are definitely not a “topical” thing. In fact, the pandemics of the past, and those still prevalent in underdeveloped countries, can be said to be far more devastating than even COVID.

COVID freaks us out so much because we haven’t had a major global pandemic in a while, and the kinds of death rates we’re seeing are straight out of the early 20th century, and the disease does not spare rich countries with more resources and political power, unlike Ebola, Malaria, Dengue etc.

COVID is an enormous problem, true, but it’s far from the first pandemic the world has experienced, and it probably won’t be the last.

And considering that the game is set sometime in alternate universe 1950s, a polio outbreak is very believable.

2
atasergeynowakUSP•

The topics were in the game since 2017. They haven't been added recently. We had a pandemic before the real one. The same goes for protests and many other subjects.

Our demo only showed the intro of the game not the full experience.

Thanks for the feedback.

7
OdaNova•

It is indeed a flawed game. I found the final third of the game was too rushed for me.

I also find the budgeting far too restrictive, there seems to be great emphasis on balancing the books, or austerity, which we know is a bad policy - it’s encouraged to spend your way out of recessions these days, but the game seems to punish this if you spend too much early on.

I sort of agree on the polio situation, for me it popped up and I spent funding to eliminate it via vaccine and that was it job done. It seemed undercooked.

Also agree on translation quality, there were some sections I came away from confused; the talk with mrs Edwards for example, was clumsy. Or during the reforms talks, everyone sounded outraged, then they’d look at the reforms and go... “oh I like it actuality” which was a massive mood whiplash.

I think they needed another month or two to flesh out situations, like the family dynamic with franc - which seemed to go nowhere, I couldn’t help him apparently, and to make the game more flexible in some areas. Don’t get me wrong I liked the game, it just didn’t get it right imo.

4
4DEATH•

I also find the budgeting far too restrictive, there seems to be great emphasis on balancing the books, or austerity, which we know is a bad policy - it’s encouraged to spend your way out of recessions these days, but the game seems to punish this if you spend too much early on.

I basically never had a problem with increasing spending for everything (and going negative). It actually solves problems too fast in my opinion.

1
OdaNova•

Fair enough :)

1
chrisjwmartin•

From the demo to the release, I noticed a hamfisted inclusion of the pandemic and protests against police brutality into the game in order to make it seem "topical" and give players something to relate to

Oh that is very frustrating. This makes me a lot less likely to buy the game.

0
Bonty48•

It's bullshit though. "pandemic" is not corona or anything of that sort. It is a polio epidemic. You know a common problem back then. And op is probably American trying to see the Sord-Blud conflict as racial tenstions in USA but it is in fact it is about Turk-Kurd conflict of Turkey.

6
TheChaoticist•

OP doesn’t know what they’re talking about, none of it feels hamfisted. Also racial injustice and police brutality are not new concepts, and pandemics certainly aren’t new. Op is getting they’re panties in a twist for no reason other than possible wanting to avoid reality. The game does have some serious problems, but the ones that OP posted are not them.

3
chrisjwmartin•

Worth knowing, thanks.

2