[ANALYSIS] A Study into Ghostbur’s Stability, according to My Interpretation of DreamSMP Lore
(or: A Desperate Request For u/WilburSoot's Character to Get Some Therapy)
I am fully aware that the Dream SMP is a roleplay. I am also fully aware that Wilbur does not presently have a drafted character arc for Ghost!Wilbur. I would like to create more content like this, nonetheless, as season two progresses, and things develop further. (If the plot stays at this breakneck speed, I may not be able to, but I can dream…)
I am also still prepared to have this essay end up completely wrong. That’s still okay! I am genuinely just having a good time, analysing and wiki-updating. I am literally just vibing.
CONTENT WARNINGS: This essay includes references to trauma, past suicide, and depression. There will be mentions of in-game theories of substance abuse. Keep in mind that any reference to ‘Wilbur Soot’ is referring to his character, not the streamer himself. I’m not going to diagnose a real person with real disorders, that’s weirdchamp.
This essay will spoil Wilbur’s entire character arc so far, particularly his presentation in season two. So... be careful! I will be posting it later on Tumblr under the username general-light.
This essay is shorter than before, and is broken into approximately four sections, with about 3k words. I know it’s still a lot, and I don’t expect much of a reception on social media. Still, if you read it, thank you a lot!
--
As you are most likely aware, in death, Ghost Wilbur (shortened to Ghostbur in the duration of this essay for ease of understanding) is experiencing a severe degree of amnesia surrounding his past life. Most people are quick to assume it is because of his death that he is experiencing this amnesia, and it may become clear that real!Wilbur (Realbur) intended for that to be the case, but contextually speaking, I do not agree with that assessment of canon.
In my past essay, I attributed the memory loss to trauma, giving it the name of ‘dissociative amnesia’, but I didn’t linger on the topic very long, in order to favour the mental strain of his living self.
In this essay, I am going to go through my thoughts and analyses of this characterisation choice properly, alongside how other newly introduced plot elements may affect his development, and I will seek to properly run through my assessment of its effect on Ghostbur’s mental state.
Key note: There may be times when Wilbur’s own lines with contradict my assertions. Before you counter me with them, remember this key fact: Actions speak louder than words.
---> Table of Contents
> 01. The Nature of Forgetting – Why’s It Happening? (Recap)
> 02. Further Repression – Both Voluntary and Not
> 03. The Nature of “Blue”, and other Illegal Substances
> 0X. Conclusion
--
> 01. The Nature of Forgetting – Why’s It Happening? (Recap)
As I stated earlier, a lot of people have come to the conclusion that the only reason Ghostbur experiences amnesia is due to the fact that he is dead. Without context, this is a fair assessment of his character – it only makes sense that a ghost would forget parts of their identity, right? However, with prior knowledge of living Wilbur’s spiral and breakdown (from this point on, I will refer to living Wilbur as Alivebur for clarification), this theory begins to fall apart somewhat.
We know that Ghostbur only forgets things that caused him some degree of major despair, or trauma. I know this is relatively obvious, but it should be noted that this is only based on his personal assessment of the situation, not anybody else’s.
A common rebuttal for this assertion of the canon is Ghostbur's recalling of his death, for example. I stand to claim that Ghostbur remembers his death fairly clearly because, for Alivebur, his assisted suicide could ultimately be considered to be a freeing moment in the backdrop of chaos. Alivebur had ultimately wanted to die, and he was desperate to die, so therefore, Ghostbur remembers the happiness when he achieved his death – even if he forgets the emotional distress of begging Phil for it in the first place.
This fact (alongside the fact that he is still forgetting in death, which I will bring up in depth in the next part) calls the theory that he simply forgets because he is dead into question. Normally, the first memory to fade in popular media about ghosts that exhibit this trait is how they died – it’s why they go about their lives in old residences almost as if they never passed. Unlike them, Ghostbur is very vocal about his method of death – and unlike other situations in which he was reminded of “bad things” through old writings and songs alone, he produced the memory from his head rather unprompted.
The assessment that Ghostbur forgets because of his past traumas makes further sense when we consider what he has forgotten.
He does not remember Eret, or Eret’s betrayal. Before you refute this with scenes from the adoption plot, remember how uncertain Ghostbur is when he mentions Eret being a bad person. When bringing it up, Ghostbur mentions how ‘it says it in the song’, likely referring to the National Anthem (which he has a copy of in his personal library). Therefore, it is far more likely that he still does not remember Eret, and simply supplements lost memories with his reading material.
Ghostbur does not remember anything of his spiral, even going to far as to completely block out Schlatt winning and exiling him with false memories of the election. It can be assumed that Schlatt and Wilbur were once friends, much like Tommy and Tubbo are, as Alivebur once trusted Schlatt to endorse his political party, which explains why the betrayal left such a mark on him as a person. He does not remember betraying his nation, or working with Dream, or anything of note during the entire exile. It is, so to speak, a complete blank spot.
Ghostbur also exhibits spotty memory surrounding Fundy. He remembers the happy moments, of how Fundy grew up, and how they were a happy family for an unknown period of time, but Ghostbur does not remember Fundy disowning him, or burning the flag. Once, Ghostbur claimed that Fundy was only 14, despite most likely not being that age in canon, hinting at the idea that Fundy’s effect on Ghostbur’s memory is more drastic than we know currently.
TL;DR for this section: While some assume that Ghostbur’s slipping memory is a symptom of him fading, or simply being a ghost, I do not think this is the case at all. His memory loss follows the pattern of skipping memories that distress Ghostbur, and as a result, it seems to be trauma-based instead – memory loss is a common defense and response towards trauma in general.
--
> 02. Further Repression, both Voluntary and Not
Ghostbur’s memory loss does not stop at his past memories. He is still actively forgetting, losing memories of events that have happened to him after death. Some have taken this to mean that he is slowly fading away as a spirit – I do not think this is the case. Instead, I think that Ghostbur’s ongoing repression and continued forgetting speaks volumes about his continued battle with mental health problems, even as a spirit.
The majority of Ghostbur’s repression of the past is involuntary, a continuation of his symptoms of dissociative amnesia. He forgets things that make him stressed, and that’s basically it explanation-wise.
For example, he forgot writing the book “What I Remember”. This book was like a journal of life, in which Ghostbur attempted to recount as much as he could from being Alivebur. The end of the book would grow increasingly vague, before ending in a stutter of ellipses and a statement of ‘I don’t know’. It would appear that the act of remembering is distressing to Ghostbur, from this hasty end, and this theory is further exacerbated by his subsequent forgetting of writing it. Later, Ghostbur would admit that he tries to remember his past while alone, but every time, he forgets whatever he can recall.
After encountering Fundy and learning of the adoption process, Ghostbur was visibly very distressed, as we know clearly (since it is the only event we got to see in his POV). Later, when encountering Fundy, though, we would learn that Ghostbur proceeded to completely forget having had said conversation, losing all of his recollection of the future adoption. His memory loss would allow him to act happy around Fundy again, which cements the idea that it is a defense mechanism of the mind.
Recently, Ghostbur has also started to persistently forget that Tommy is exiled, not on vacation. It is possible that this forgetting is because the concept of exile is very distressing to Ghostbur, and so his mind simply can’t hold on to the information, in an attempt to let him be happy.
Ghostbur never means for any of this repression to happen, mind – it is all involuntary, done by the mind to save him from a second breakdown. However, Ghostbur does sometimes actively repress his past when he knows he is tipping too near the breaking point. This is clearest in his dissociation from Alivebur.
Ghostbur is persistent in reminding others (and himself?) that he is not his living self, because they do not share the same memories. He persistently refers to Alivebur in the third person, even sometimes requesting not to be called by his ‘alive name’ of Wilbur. It is possible that this is because Ghostbur hates the idea of Alivebur, or he is scared of ever falling as far as Alivebur allegedly did. His perception of Alivebur is incredibly limited, but after experiencing the consequences of whatever he did, Ghostbur is reasonably quite… resentful of Alivebur, so to speak?
Ghostbur makes his assumptions of Alivebur solely through other peoples’ assertions of him, only seeing the bad side to him. Remember, Alivebur was not fully bad, and he was not fully black in his morals (the concept of black and white morality does not exist on the DSMP, friends). Yet, Ghostbur does not see the good in who he used to be, solely because everyone around him only ever reacts to the bad. This sends him into a rather despairing state of mind surrounding his living self, to the point where Ghostbur cannot stand being associated with who he used to be.
This poses an interesting problem for character development, because it hinders it. Ghostbur cannot grow, because he refuses to accept that he is Alivebur. He cannot even fathom remembering, because he is desperate to separate his current self from his alive self. Ghostbur and Alivebur are the same person, mind, and I believe no growing can happen until Ghostbur takes the scary step of accepting that, and trying to come to peace with the suffering of his past. Until then, he is bound by his dissociation.
TL;DR for this section: Ghostbur is still forgetting things involuntarily, out of a continued state of dissociative amnesia. However, he also actively represses his past due to his limited perception of Alivebur – this is limiting his character growth and keeping him in the chokehold of his narrowed worldview.
--
> 03. The Nature of “Blue”, and other Illegal Substances
Now, we don’t know what the hell “Blue” is, or where it came from. A lot of people incorrectly source it as having arrived in season two. This isn’t true – Alivebur was the first person to use Blue, in the finale of season one, handing it out to people as he saw fit. This could explain why Alivebur remained so calm during his final battle alongside his supposed allies, but it brings a lot of concerns to the table.
What is Blue, and why did Alivebur have it? (I recognise it was likely spawned from an impromptu bit, but now it’s here, it should have some proper lore, no?)
Why is Ghostbur so fixated on it? Why is his never transparent? And, more importantly, what does its association with Ghostbur mean for his character?
As of right now, the best canonical assessment of the nature of Blue is as follows.
Blue is an item that starts out as being entirely transparent. As someone holds it, and feels sadness, the Blue absorbs the emotion, until it becomes an opaque blue colour (hence the name).
I imagine that excessive use of Blue is not the healthiest thing in the world. I liken it to substance abuse because we know that Ghostbur is never seen without it, handing it out as he sees fit. We do not know how much Ghostbur uses blue, but we do know that his character is not mentally alright (he experiences bouts of sadness and emptiness that allude to his ongoing depression, as we most recently saw in his venting to Tubbo about not having a gravestone).
The fact that Ghostbur goes about with a smile on his face could, scarily, imply that Ghostbur uses Blue as a crutch to continue avoiding his emotions – but Blue does not seem to solve the sad, it simply quells it. So, Ghostbur has a lot of it. Tommy once made the observation that Ghostbur’s blue has never been seen transparent – and, that may be a mechanics comment, due to the ingame item used to be Blue, but Ghostbur immediately refused to address it in the similar way he dodges all discussion of his wellbeing. Once again, he is just like Alivebur, keeping his emotions under lock and key.
Blue does supposedly work on humans, so it is not a spectral thing. We do not know the effects of Blue on the human body, if there are any, though it is too early to call. It could inadvertently exacerbate Ghostbur’s symptoms of dissociative amnesia and general dissociation, as it offers an easy outlet to drain sadness without actually addressing it or its accompanying symptoms of stress (which, friends, is not how you should deal with your emotions).
The fact that Ghostbur is handing out Blue could imply he is trying to avoid sadness as a whole. He likely knows that most folks see his dead body and have an adverse reaction, so he has taken to handing it out freely by instinct. Ghostbur voiced clearly that he just wants to help, and this could be seen as him trying to make amends for his deeds as Alivebur. Tubbo even likened him to being a therapist (which is a bad idea, really, Wilbur’s character has been chronically awful at handling or sharing his own emotions, even in death).
But… we don’t know who gave him the Blue. We don’t even know if, for Ghostbur, it has addictive properties. There is far too little known about its nature, or its effects on spirits. It could even come out that Ghostbur is relatively unaffected by Blue, which would raise even more questions.
Ghostbur once admitted he has a lot of experience with potions, which are basically the in-game variant of real drugs. This essay section poses more of a question, really, because it would appear that Ghostbur has a continued reliance on potions in order to disappear from sight. Despite being for pranks (and having nothing narratively to do with actual substance abuse, ahaha), most likely, Ghostbur’s habit of going invisible could be another sign of Ghostbur intentionally trying to disappear from sight.
Ghostbur would use Invisibility when following Fundy on his fishing trip, for example, despite his own desire to interact with his son. It is possible that Ghostbur fears being a burden on those around him - this idea is furthered by the theory that his ultimate goal is to be helpful.
He is aware of his effect on others, and knows how others treat him differently for Alivebur’s actions, so it could be reasoned that Ghostbur likes to avoid unnecessary contact, hence his backing out of Schlatt’s funeral and his once-great stockpile of Invisibility.
TL;DR for this section: “Blue” is a substance that we don’t know much about. We know it first appeared in season one’s finale, with Alivebur, and it has properties that allow it to absorb blue – notably, though, it does not seem to be a very healthy way of dealing with emotion, as it only takes the feeling. Ghostbur also may rely somewhat on Invisibility potions as another method of repression.
--
> 0X. Conclusion
Ghostbur might be doing his best to make the rest of the server happy, but even if he does become the server therapist, by God, he needs to see one himself. Ghostbur’s repression of his memories, identity, and emotion is unhealthy, and after the self-detonation of Alivebur, it can’t end well unless he addresses his issues with his past, or his state of being.
Though he claims to be at peace, his own word can not be trusted when he persistently exhibits his symptoms of dissociative amnesia and displays a reliance on the sadness-absorbing Blue. Ghostbur is desperate to please others, going so far as to completely disown his old identity in an attempt to mould himself into a pleasant shape for the rest of his living family.
Until Ghostbur accepts that he is Alivebur, he cannot grow from his experiences from life, or repair his relationships. As much as Ghostbur tries to fix what his living self did, until he truly accepts that they are not separate beings, he will forever be cleaning up a mess he doesn’t even remember making. There is a high chance that, unless this dissociation is resolved somehow, Ghostbur will continue to repress his stressful memories, and I don’t know if he will ever be able to stop.
I assert that Ghostbur’s potential character arc (as well as Tommy’s, I believe, as Tommy persistently separates ‘Real Wilbur’ from who he was in exile, leading to his denial of the fact that kind-hearted people can succumb to stress very easily) hinges on his dissociation from Alivebur.
Take my deductions with a grain of salt, though. I’m no writer, and a lot of this may be unintentional! I encourage further reading into the plot.
Thank you for reading! I hope I didn’t sound insane, again. I really like analysing this character, and I’ve had a blast writing his character page on the Dream Team wiki. I really hope I get the opportunity to do more in future!
Posted Dec 9, 2020, 5:11 PM UTC
Good post and thank you for working on the wiki. I enjoyed reading the posts.
I'm glad you liked it. Thank you for reading :D