Biscotti SOS: Can you save Christmas?

Hi friends!

For Christmas this year, I want to make each of my siblings some biscotti to go with some nice coffee I bought. I did a trial run of a recipe I selected last night and while the taste was great, the texture was not what I think of for biscotti.

This is the recipe I used and I found that the texture was too moist, more like a cookie. I'd like it to be super crispy and porous, not dense and moist. When I dipped it in my coffee, it didn't really soak up the coffee so the coffee flavour penetrated the biscotti...it just kind of got wet and soggy.

Is it the recipe? If so, what should I look for in a recipe to ensure a light, crispy, porous biscotti? Or does anyone have a recipe they know gives the right texture? Or is it my technique/execution? Did I not do the second bake long enough?

Pics of my biscotti here. I do know that I underbaked during the first bake resulting in that inner part being super dense and essentially raw. However, even around all the outside, it is not crispy and light.

Any suggestions, recipes, tips, are appreciated!! If I can't get this right, I do* know what else to get them with the coffee and I already bought the cute boxes!

Edit: don't know!!

Posted Dec 13, 2020, 7:48 PM UTC

38
WhiteCat2338•

Did you wait for them to cool down after the first bake and firm up before you slice for the second bake? If you didn't, when you cut them, they get squished down and get denser. Also remember to use a sharp knife and do a sawing motion while cutting them in order to not squish them.

Finally that recipe looks a bit short in the baking time, I would do 20 minutes on each side for the second bake (keep an eye on them in case they colour too much) - that might not make it porous, but they will be crispy.

5
BButFirstCoffeeOP•

Ohh that could be it. I did not wait after first bake. I actually didn't even wait til they were cool enough to handle per the recipe as I had two screaming babies wanting their bottles... probably should have left them (the biscotti, not the babies) but was worried they would get super firm upon cooling and I wouldn't be able to slice.

Will modify that next time as well as increase cooking time... and/or lower heat per other comments

2

The “place cookies cut side down” is new for me. We’ve always done the 2nd bake sitting the cookies up. I’m guessing cut side down would lower the surface area and blah blah chemistry

3
BButFirstCoffeeOP•

I would be worried about browning the bottom too much but I could try lowering the temp in addition to not flipping them to the cut side...

2

Yeah! We (pastry kitchen) would freeze after cutting and throw them in under room temp. Seems like you need a small test bake. S’luck!

3
nizzi521•

If you’re looking for an iron-clad biscotti recipe, I always use one from Brown Eyed Baker. Scroll down past the ads and check out all the flavors. I’ve always had amazing results with each and every one.

3
antslizard516•

I would try giving them a third bake at either 300 or 325 and see how they come out. I have a recipe for almond biscotti that is very similar (minus the honey) that calls for dropping the temperature from 350 to 325 instead of 300. I have also under-baked my biscotti on the first bake, and ended up with a more dense texture, so that could have been your problem. A third bake didn't completely fix that, but it did improve things.

2
BButFirstCoffeeOP•

Ya I'm wondering if lower and slower in general is the ticket!

2