I wanna improvements feedback on Bach’s Preludium of BWV 846
Posted Dec 14, 2020, 9:30 PM UTC
Posted Dec 14, 2020, 9:30 PM UTC
I'd use the pedal rather than holding down all the notes. It'll sound a bit better and free you up from doing things like using the 4 and 5 fingers in the left hand for some of those notes next to each other. I'd also play it a bit faster and don't be afraid to use some rubato at certain impact points like when a lower bass note comes out of nowhere like on the D in the first few bars and the G a little later. La st thing, dynamics in Bach are always fun to figure out because a lot of it sounds largely the same. I would just decide certain places to play loud/soft and see how it sounds and change up the dynamics until you find a way you like. Good job though.
Hey, Jerry, thanks for the feedback. I am super beginner so I hope you can help-me further:
-About the pedal, I've learnt this piece from Glenn's Gould, so I really appreciate the sound of each note on the right hand and the pedal would mess with it a little bit. I was trying for a while but to make the chords transitions smoother. I might try to use it all along anyway, any particular bar/note It would help so I can start from there?
-About the speed, I guess it's always a point of discussion when you are playing baroque pieces, but I like it a little fast too.
-About the Rubatto and Dynamics the explanation is Glenn Gould again. I know he doesn't play it entirely flat, but it's mostly flat. I've been listening to lot of other interpretations thought and been trying to add some rubbato and dynamics more often.
Do you think I should stick with a speed/rubato/dynamics interpretation and practice just 'this way' for a while or varying should be good?
Thanks again for your help!
Glenn Gould is undoubtedly one of the foremost authorities on Bach, he’s definitely a good resource for improving your own interpretations. He was also a rather mentally ill savant, so don’t necessarily take it as gospel because the reason he’s so good is because he does things no one else does and makes it work. He kind of defines the exception that proves the rule. Also his Beethoven sonatas are fantastic. As for the pedal, try it every bar and see how you like it!
Gould rules!
Its nice but I think a little faster would be good.
Thanks! I am on vacation so I was in a slow mood. I am gonna try a faster and more dramatic version later this month and I’ll let you know.
I know it’s a easy piece but it leave rooms for improving tempo, dynamics, etc.
Just saw another person posted the same piece 11h ago, lol. It’s popular among beginners.
Sorry for my bare legs!
Good performance! There’s a few different ways it could be made more expressive but I’m just gonna say one thing and it is that I disagree with the other guy about pedal. Beginners always fall into the trap of using too much pedal, especially on a piece like this... by relying on your fingers holding down notes and legato technique you are becoming a better equipped pianist. As for speed, this is a little on the slow side but I’ve heard recordings that make the slow, dreamy aesthetic work (check out Samuel Feinberg).