[Historic] [BO3] Mono-Black: Aggro returns (from the graveyard)

Historic

Hey Spikes!

I have been having a blast playing mono-B aggro on the MTG Arena ladder, posting a highly surprising 77% WR on 35 matches from Platinum all the way up to #331 Mythic (just achieved it). Proof: https://imgur.com/a/hDZMZoO. Thought that it would be great to share ideas with the community, especially on sideboarding where I think the deck could be optimized.

Edit: Just reached #35 Mythic while slightly improving the WR to 78% (https://imgur.com/a/SS5yCW1). This deck is nuts!

Why play Mono-B aggro?

Well, aggro decks do not look so favored in the BO3 ladder meta right now, with the notable exception of the ocasional Gruul players (or Goblins plan B). After playing a bit of Sultai and facing the mirror match several times, I decided to play a different, slighlty off-meta deck for a change. Being mono black provides you a lot of mana consistency, gives you access to some of the most efficient removal suite available in historic ([[Thoughtseize]], [[Fatal Push]] and [[Eliminate]]) as well as gives you a lot of recursion from the graveyard, helping you beat those pesky control mages.

What is the list?

Deck

4 Gutterbones (RNA) 76

3 Spawn of Mayhem (RNA) 85

4 Knight of the Ebon Legion (M20) 105

2 Murderous Rider (ELD) 97

3 Rankle, Master of Pranks (ELD) 101

4 Castle Locthwain (ELD) 241

3 Demonic Embrace (M21) 95

4 Agadeem's Awakening (ZNR) 90

2 Skyclave Shade (ZNR) 125

4 Dread Wanderer (AKR) 103

4 Thoughtseize (AKR) 127

3 Fatal Push (KLR) 84

4 Scrapheap Scrounger (KLR) 268

16 Swamp (KLR) 293

​

Sideboard

2 Phyrexian Obliterator (NPH) 68

1 Murderous Rider (ELD) 97

2 Witch's Vengeance (ELD) 111

2 Soul-Guide Lantern (THB) 237

3 Eliminate (M21) 97

3 Kitesail Freebooter (M21) 107

2 Gifted Aetherborn (KLR) 91

The 75 are largely inspired in the deck Mengu played on stream (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAuQB1gmnqI&t=7s) with a few modifications from my end, to better adapt to the meta I had been facing. The sideboard includes options against Sultai, Goblins, UW Control, graveyard and creature-based strategies. You do not have access to answers to artifacts or enchantments in the 75 and yes [[Graffdigger's cage]] is a pain. Happy to hear thoughts on how to improve the list.

Match-ups:

Overall you have very fair game against most of the field in my experience, perhaps standing out against other creature based aggro decks due to the removal package and [[Phyrexian Obliterator]].

Sultai/4c midrange: Although Sultai would be a bad match-up on paper due to extensive removal and [[Extinction Event]], I have found the match-up to be pretty even (I am 6-3 against Sultai variants). Just beat them down and don't overcommit to the board. Board out [[Fatal Push]] and a few 1-drops that would be overwhelmed by [[Extinction Event]] and bring in the [[Kitesail Freeboter]]s as well as [[Soul-Guide Lanterns]] to deal with Uro. Cutting down on [[Demonic Embrace]] can also make sense due to several instant-speed removal.

Goblins: You have no answer to a resolved Muxus one hit KO, although you can take it from their hand with [[Thoughtseize]]. You have answers to everything else and in a fair game, you should win flying over with [[Spawn of Mayhem]] and [[Demonic Embrace]]. Post board [[Witch's Vengeance]] should help you as well.

UW Control: Their exile based removal is your #1 enemy: [[Baffling end]] sucks. Strategy should be to swarm the board with stuff that can be brought back but try to follow a [[Wrath of God]] with double threat, even if they are one drops, as to discourage a Teferi's -3. One important weakness of the MonoB deck is [[Graffdigger's Cage]] to which you don't have a clear answer to and a lot of the UW decks are packing it on MB now.

Gruul Aggro: I think this should be quite a favourable match-up for MonoB, although unfortunately not that common anymore. A resolved [[Phyrexian Obliterator]] is usually GG unless you are massively behind. Other than that, try to control the board not to allow for [[Embercleave]] critical mass and you should be fine. [[Gifted Aetherborn]] post-board is your best friend as well.

Rakdos/Jund Sacrifice: Probably the worst match-ups as they have access to the same removal as you do, but with better recursion/value in the form of [[Mayhem Devil]] and [[Priest of the Forgotten Gods]] as well as [[Dreadhorde Arcanist]] and [[Claim//Fame]]. Fortunately, these are not that common anymore in my ladder experience, having face them a combined 3 times in the past 40 games or so. The strategy against those should be to try and get rid of their value engines mentioned above ASAP.

That is it folks, but before we go just wanted to leave a few topics for discussion:

  • What can be improved in the current sideboard?
  • Should [[Fatal Push]] be in the starting 60? I find it to be a dead card a lot of the time, especially with no obvious way to enable revolt.
  • Should we have one copy of [[Blast Zone]] maybe in the SB to deal with the infamous cage?

All the best,

Rick

Posted Dec 15, 2020, 12:11 AM UTC · edited

8919
Loading comments…