r/FATErpg•
MadBlue

Fate of Cthulhu Accelerated Stress Boxes

FoC's Accelerated conversion has a unified track of 4 one-point stress boxes, but in the Condensed rules, it suggests adding 3 one-point stress boxes for a unified track (for a total of 6, not including Physique or Will).

My question is, is FoC's Accelerated track 4 instead of 6 because FoC is supposed to be more deadly, or is 4 what a "default" FAE Condensed would use, based on play-testing with one-point Stress boxes?

Of course, I know I can do what I want in my games, but as FoC is the flagship Condensed product, I was wondering if FoC Accelerated serves as the model for "FAE Condensed".

Posted Dec 21, 2020, 12:35 AM UTC

48
hatredlord•

Check the publish date, whichever is newer may be an improved version of the other. In the end though, yes it may be just a genre thing.

4
MadBlueOP•

FoC uses the standard Condensed rules for Skills and Stress. The only actual example of Condensed rules with Approaches, AFAIK, is the FoC Accelerated document. FCon is newer, but the suggestion in the book is for using a single track with Skills (which can add to the number of Stress boxes), not with Approaches.

I guess, the question I'm really asking is, if there were an "official" FCon FAE character sheet, what would it look like? :)

3
Laurence_MTrouble Is My High Concept•

if there were an "official" FCon FAE character sheet, what would it look like? :)

Probably something like this (character sheet is on page 4. ; )

2
MadBlueOP•

I know about FoC's FAE adaptation and character sheet, but given the advice for adding 3 Stress boxes when consolidating to a single Stress track in FCon would give 6 Stress boxes, my question is whether FoC FAE's "track of 4 Stress boxes" is unique to FoC in order to make it more deadly, or is it what Evil Hat would consider the "standard" for FCon FAE based on playtesting FAE with one-point Stress boxes.

That is, would a "standard" FCon FAE character sheet have 4 Stress boxes as in FoC FAE or 6 as suggested in FCon?

2
Laurence_MTrouble Is My High Concept•

FCon FAE

Sorry, what? You lost me in the middle somewhere. Just to clarify, there are currently three builds of Fate: Core, Accelerated, and Condensed. They're just three different versions of the same game.

Core came first, then Accelerated (it's the same game as Core, just set up a little differently).

The designers tweaked Core a bit for Fate of Cthulhu, and liked it so much that they filed the serial numbers off and released it as Condensed. Which is awesome.

But there's no such thing as "Fate Condensed Accelerated". It's all just Fate. You can (and should!) set it up any way you like.

1
Dramatic15•

Given that the Fate Condensed exists, is physically in print, and has Approaches, and there's nothing on the Evil Hat project status that indicates there will ever be such a thing as "FAE Condensed", its a pretty nebulous question.

If you're intent to have a "word of god" designers take on an issue, you might focus what they have said repeatedly, that there is only one game, Fate, which includes FAE, Core and Condensed. Maybe extrapolate from the almost random way stress changes between between publications (and Condensed even mention that you can use an "old way" if you like) that how exactly it is handled is a minor implementation detail--a "dial". Rather than conjuring up a hypothetical FAE Condensed "edition" for which their ought to be a single definitive answer.

But, yeah, go with 4 one stress boxes. It is the way.

2