Bad Idea: Fearing Power Vacuums
defense360.csis.org/bad-idea-fearing-power-va...Posted Dec 21, 2020, 4:37 PM UTC
4312
Posted Dec 21, 2020, 4:37 PM UTC
Post a submission statement in one hour or your post will be removed. Rules / Wiki Resources
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
[deleted]
SS: this article explores the vulnerabilities produced by "power vacuums" and why three commonly stated concerns about power vacuums may not be so worrisome after all.
The first counter argument is in my opinion, situation specific. See Iraqi in 2014 for an example of what happens when local actors are the benefactors of a power vacuum and have jihad on the mind. There are other cases where there just aren't any local powers, or at least any that can prevail.
The second objection the author raises against the argument of "power vacuums are undesirable" is that some places are flat out inconsequential. I find this intriguing, as I do often wonder if what happens in XYZ place really matters at all. When I lived in Africa, many locals would ask the local geography teacher (me) if the various political movements/violence/activism going on in that country would be heard by the US (my home nation). Had I told them my gut feeling I would have been correct, as there are not currently, nor has there been, as US presence where I was. But why was that the case when similar situations around the world have had a US investment? Many aspects to consider here.
Lastly the author considers "opportunity" cost, or risk-vs-reward of other great powers exploiting a power vacuum. This is another topic worth exploring theoretically despite also being dependent on the specifics of any given situation. Are there any metrics by which to decide whether or not foreign involvement is warranted? Are the costs in capital (political and financial), reputation, and national will worth the efforts?
Let me know your thoughts, folks. Please remember to keep it civil, and avoid low quality, off-topic, and memes.
I agree with antiquated that one of the big problems is that you can never perfectly predict the future, however, it is necessary to know when to pick your battles. Some places can be supported by aid, others by the military, others by diplomatic options.
My main problems are that US pull-out discussions seem to be mostly surrounded by populism, and not planned action and suitable circumstances. Every place is individual and unique and takes knowing the locals. It seems like talks of leaving is always immediate and never waiting for the perfect moment.
In general, I feel as the US is suffering from lack of ideology and selflessness and that is hurting its diplomatic relations and effectiveness of its military operations abroad. The US could do good from being more of the inspiring leader of the true world that it loves to call itself. Walk the talk, not talk the talk. Lead by example by domestic support and foreign engagement.
This is very true. Out of the 300+ years of US history, I can't even think of one example where the US helped a region transition from bad governance (or a lack of governance) to good governance. It is probably a result of their lack of experience in colonization before WW1. Long periods of isolationism in the US have also caused the US to lack the ability to understand foreign cultures.
Well I mean there are certainly a lot of good that the us does and have done. Korea, Taiwan and Japan for example owe their current democracies to US influence. There are endless examples of USA helping during ww2. Nato is to a large degree based around the USA and has helped Europe immensely, and is growing with new members ever other year.
Some places like Afganistan are very far gone at this point, bit I can't help but think policy towards Iraq and Iran has been a failure, and that broken beyond recognition Syria that is today could have been prevented.
Of course hindsight is 20/20.
These places (East Asia, Europe) already had good governance before war; the US helped rebuilding their good governance.
And be careful when you say Korea owed their democracies to US influence. Many Koreans are still bitter about alleged US involvement in the Kwangju massacre. Ditto for Taiwan.
In my opinion, leaving no stones unturned wrt to imposing influence is a product of fog of war and game theory. Country A doesn't know what the rival, Country B, is planning and doing. Therefore, Country A doesn't want to leave a power vacuum to chances by taking another location within its orbit of influence.
This argument doesn’t address the mass bloodshed caused by power struggles which ensue after power vacuums. Civil wars and the like tend to erupt once an invading force takes out the established government, allowing for atrocities to occur unchecked. This wave of violence could cause terrorists to sprout from nationwide frustration with the invaders/the West, which could later bite the invaders in the rear.
I agree, power vacuums will definitely be an issue in both Iraq and Afghanistan. Both KSA and Pakistan respectively support the extremists. I'm more aware of Afghanistan, but the Taliban have gained ground each year, and with the US withdrawl, the "local actors" that stand to gain are the Taliban and ISIL. Just look up the increase of Kabul attacks in the last three months, even with talks happening. The Afghan govt is pretty incompetent with there goals compared to extremists. I do hope though the two sides can at least compromise and finally end the bloody war.
Pakistan has a lot to lose and gain from a stable Afghanistan. For one, it would bring up Pashto separation in Pakistan, plus Af. would ally with India. These aren't great for Pakistan, but a stable Afghanistan means less flow of Afghans in Pak. and stable neighbors are usually a plus.
At that point, it would then depend on what Pakistan values more. My bet is on the former.
Initially, but by definition a power vacuum allows other stronger players to muscle their way in. That's ISIS and Al Qaeda's modus operandi in Africa. Seems like a bizarre deflection.
Again, in the short term sure, but it's hard to know the long term ramifications of ISIS gaining a foothold in Mauritania. Ignoring the moral implications of it, this seems like an unnecessary risk and a pretty lousy deflection of risk. It's not like Afghanistan had strategic value before 9/11, or Syria before the global ISIS attacks.
I guess, but on the flipside there's a lot of upside for the U.S. engaging as well. This ironically seems like a zero-sum argument.
This entire argument just seems short-sighted and not much else.
[removed]