Help! Protan and Deutan at the same time?

Question/Need help

I've been aware for quite some time that i have a moderate/strong red-green deficiency. However, on color vision tests (mostly ishihara dot tests) I have received "Strong Deutan" and "Moderate Protan" consistently and almost evenly. I've gotten tested well over 5-ish times and I'm getting a mix of either results. I'm doing these tests non-biased and with honest answers, so I can't really figure out what's going on.. Is it possible that I have a mix of deuteranomaly AND protanomaly? If it is possible, how likely/rare is it and how could I confirm whether that is the case?

Thanks!

-Squid

Posted Dec 30, 2020, 12:17 AM UTC

613
exotrxProtanomaly•

Any screen-based test can be flawed / variable. You would really need a physical test. Different monitors can give different results. Even the same monitor like an iPhone can vary with auto-brightness and True Tone settings. Check out this video for a long answer, the YouTuber mentions the same issue with monitors https://youtu.be/ZX73w9gZ3ZA.

Besides that, there are some patterns of colour confusion. What would you say are the most common colours you get perceive differently?

7
chroma-phobe•

Thanks! This is the first time I've seen someone else link to one of my videos :D

2
Squidtakeover97OP•

thanks for that, i'll definitely look more into some physical testing! As far as actual color confusion, i often confuse: red and green and brown (also orange and lime)
pink and grey/white
purple and blue
i also have lots of trouble depicting different colors in the sky, mostly during sunsets as everything just looks blue and yellowish-white

anyway, thanks for the reply!

1
Flinten_UschiDeuteranomaly•

Sounds like strong deuteranomaly to me. Can you turn on the blue-light-filter (night light) on your phone and do the ishiara test again? If you get a 'better'/ less severe result I'm quite confident you're a deutan.

1
exotrxProtanomaly•

Yeah, sounds like it could be either or.. as a protan my confusion areas are maroon/brown, pink and gray, purple and dark blue, and neon/lime green and yellow. Sunsets are equally colour-simple to me... oranges however have always been clear cut to me. Nonetheless, it can manifest so differently from person to person, physical test is the only real way.

1
Squidtakeover97OP•

sorry for the delayed reply! but that's so weird because it sounds so familiar! I've always thought to be a deutan but i also have a considerable amount of trouble with maroon/brown, pink/gray, purple/royal blue, and lime/yellow just as you said. That being said, I generally come back as deutan and i still have common deutan mix-ups as well. It literally almost feels like i have moderate or even strong deficiencies both ways. I do plan on getting tested professionally fairly soon, so I'll give updates then.

​

That being said, I can't help but to wonder if it would be possible for me to be a deutan and protan at the same time, because the more i look into it the more i realize i relate equally to both kinds

1
ReviloMDeuteranomaly•

This video may be able to help: https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ

It goes into depth about if its possible and the rarity. It will also talk about screens and other things. Reply if you thought it was helpful!

2
MolliefrenzyNormal Vision•

Hmm, This link is very familiar.

2
ReviloMDeuteranomaly•

No it’s not

1
Squidtakeover97OP•

take my upvote and get out

2
chroma-phobe•

What do you mean that you've "gotten tested"? You've taken an online test? Many of these tests are garbage, to say the least, so without knowing which ones you took, we can't comment on what could be going on.

The most reliable test is the ColorBlindCheck in the Android play store. You can take that and report back your PDT score. Make sure all your screen filters are off and brightness is way up.

Hypothetically, it's impossible (with ultra rare caveats) to have protanomaly and deuteranomaly. The "combination" of the two just leads back to normal vision. Tests giving you multiple answers is either bad test design or bad testing conditions.

1
Squidtakeover97OP•

Hi! when I was younger I had been professionally tested and it came back as strong (something), but I've forgotten what it came back as, so all testing after that has been done from home. unfortunately it is vulnerable to bias by screen differences, but it's the most i have access to for now :<

1
JadenInTheH00DDeuteranomaly•

Bruh Same

1