Best portable ham radio?
Any suggestions helpful
Posted Jan 2, 2021, 6:01 AM UTC
215
Any suggestions helpful
Posted Jan 2, 2021, 6:01 AM UTC
Literally several posts about this today and yesterday.
For?
Here is a Yaesu handheld that does pretty much everything that one does except the digital voice for $80.
Good find.
This is a *WIDE* open question. You need to be more specific. What do you envision using your radio for?
The one you will study about, practice with, and get licensed on.
Want to talk with people locally using relatively cheap radios, possibly accessing repeaters for wider area coverage? Get a GMRS radio and drop $75 on the FCC for the license. No test required, but you do need to follow the rules.
Want to spend many hundreds on kit to talk with people across the globe? Look at something like a Yaesu FT-991A, then add a power supply, speaker, and a couple antennas that you'll need to mount on your house or a pole. You'll need to study for an exam or three depending on what frequencies you want to use and drop about $30 to get licensed.
Want a small handheld ham that you'll throw in a closet somewhere, forget you have it, and never learn how to use it because you can't contact anyone because that's just how radio waves work? Get any small 5 watt handheld radio.
Before you get the radio, get the license. If you had even the most basic ham license, you'd know at least which type of radio would be useful to you.
http://www.arrl.org/getting-licensed
Protip, ham radio will not save you in a SHTF scenario and will be of absolutely ZERO use if you aren't willing to practice with it and make plans with like-minded people.
FYI
GMRS Licence fees are going down to $35.
https://www.buytwowayradios.com/blog/2020/12/fcc-approves-new-ham-and-gmrs-license-fees.html
And "Amateur Radio license fees will now cost $35."
At an unknown date in the future.
Well you don't expect anything the government announces to happen quickly do you? No, don't hold your breath, but it will be going down.
http://www.arrl.org/news/fcc-reduces-proposed-amateur-radio-application-fee-to-35
As a non-ham I'm interested in why this would be
As far as SHTF comms go, about the only thing below ham radio is smoke signals.
Consider that the infrastructure is so destroyed that the internet, landline, and cell phones are all out of business. That means power, too.
Well, if you don’t have your own power generation or a boat load of batteries, your radio won’t even work.
Let’s say you do have your own power generation. Do you know any other hams that have their own power generation? What frequency are they on? When are they monitoring? Did they even survive the SHTF? Ham radio isn’t a super popular hobby, and for most people who are into it, it’s just that, a hobby. Very few hams have their own SHTF resistant power generation radio setup and would be working as communications hubs when the world has gone to pot.
Why all this focus about electricity you ask? Good question! A small, battery powered handheld radio puts out maybe 5 watts of transmission power. With 5 watts, about the most range you’ll get out of that is 10 miles, and that’s in the very bestest of conditions: both you and your target are standing on hilltops with absolutely no obstacles in between, your batteries are both topped off fully, the weather is great, and the stars are aligned. Once you get off your hilltop and there are trees and buildings in the way, you may get a mile or two of range if you’re lucky. This is why power and fancy setups are important. Yes, you can talk around the world on a ham radio. But that radio will use upwards of 100 watts and need a large antenna and the whole setup will cost hundreds of dollars. This isn’t something you’ll be carrying around in your fanny-pack.
Furthermore, even if you have such a setup, even if you can talk around the world, even if you get ahold of someone who isn’t in the disaster zone... what are they going to do for you? Remember, shit is so badly screwed up where you are that your only hope of talking to someone is via ham radio. That means everyone else is off grid too.
In the unlikely situation that the grid is damaged badly enough to destroy modern communications for an extended period, ham radios, especially small ones, will largely be glorified walky-talkies, except walky-talkies usually come in pairs. Know anybody else with one?
—
Now for the planning and practice part. Most preppers who get a cheap ham radio never get licensed, meaning they don’t know how radio communications actually work and they don’t practice because that’s actually illegal. You can write them off because they probably can’t find the radio, it’s not charged, and they don’t know how to use it. Finding someone on a ham frequency isn’t as easy as pressing the seek button in your car radio, even if there is a scan button.
Remember old dial radios that had one dial but different frequencies printed on it that you changed with a switch, fm to am and reverse? Well now imagine that there’s fm, am, and 20 other frequency sets printed on that dial. First you’ve gotta have a radio that supports them, this is where you’ll see 2/6/10 meter or 70 centimeter listed in radios, it refers to the range they support. You’ll also have to have an antenna setup that works in said frequency. But let’s say you have all that. Where on that dial, in the midst of all those frequencies, are you going to find someone to talk to? Sure, you can press the scan button and it’ll search the airwaves for you, but if someone isn’t talking at the exact moment the radio passes their frequency, the radio keeps on chugging. If you ran an all band scan on a dual or tri band radio, it won’t get back to that frequency for 5-10 maybe even 20-30 minutes or more depending on how fast it can scan.
Unless you know other hams and have a plan to talk with them with frequencies, times, SHTF resistant setups, and you practice these plans, your ham radio won’t do much for you at all.
Thanks for the detailed reply. Just to address this point, what I'm taking away from this is that in the conditions you describe, it's not specifically ham radio that is an issue, but any radio communications. Actually in the situation you describe, any communications other than in-person would be gone, so there's no point.
Largely, that’s correct.
Just imagine the scale a disaster needs to be to completely destroy the grid and modern comms for an extended period of time. Something so terribly enormous that not only did it knock out infrastructure, but also destroyed or completely overwhelmed responders and relief forces. In the immediate aftermath of such an event, there would be little use for untrained ham. You’d be stepping more into teotwawki territory where ham becomes useful again, but considering everything else going on, is probably pretty far down your list of concerns.
This is largely pessimistic horse-hockey. There is a reason why ham radio is used in situations when the communications *AND* power grids go down.
Providing it's not a planetary disaster, you absolutely *CAN* send messages to non-ham loved ones. And receive them.
I have a laptop, an HF radio on a deep cycle marine battery, and a simple interface between the two that I built from scratch with some wire and a few resistors.
So what, you say?
That lets me access the WinLink system:
https://www.winlink.org/
I can send and receive e-mails to and from non-hams through that system. So if the entire northeastern United States is completely off grid because of some really widespread disaster, I can let my family in North Carolina, Wyoming, South Carolina, and Florida know if I'm OK or not. That's because I can hit HF gateways hundreds or even thousands of miles away and send and receive e-mails, and other sorts of data (largely things like propagation and weather reports).
In fact, I do that something like 2 to 3 times a week, just to make sure my equipment still works. If you want to know, this is what I'm running:
Icom IC-735 I bought used for $200, running at around 20 to 25 watts (it'll easily do 100 watts, but I keep it turned down). That goes to an antenna tuner to a 102' long doublet antenna fed with 300 ohm window line, up about 30 feet.
The computer is a new 11" laptop with Windows 10 on it, running the newest version of RMS Express (the software to access WinLink). I got the smaller laptop for portability. The interface between the soundcard on the laptop and the microphone and headphone jacks on the radio is one I built years ago. Before that, I used an "air interface". Mic on the radio next to laptop speaker, mic from laptop on radio speaker. Works if you've got a quiet room (not likely in an emergency).
I can have the entire system disassembled and in my car in about 10 minutes, and within 20 minutes of getting somewhere, I can throw my portable antenna (like my home, but 88' long, fed with 450 ohm window line) into a tree and be up and running.
I'm going to be buying an interface for my Xiegu G90 HF radio in my car, so I can use it there too, and for portable use so I don't have to use my portable system. The G90 is my mobile radio, and 99.9% of the time I'm using it for Morse code, but it's a fancy software defined radio so I can have the computer make it do practically anything I want (within reason). I have I Bioenno LiFePo4 battery for it, along with a solar panel and charger, so I'm golden. It's all very portable, so I can carry it quite a distance.
From reading your post, it sounds like you aren't up on the latest ham radio technology. All you really know is the new Technicians with their Baofengs.
That is highly dependent on your SHTF scenario. If you have a group of people with you, ham will still be useful for tactical communications within your group. Saying ham is useless just because shtf is kinda throwing the baby out with the bathwater. It has applications and is very much relevant, but that's dependent on YOUR OWN plans and organization.