Hikari Ipoe VNE Service Quality Question

Hi Everyone,

I'm trying to wrap my head around switching form Fleets Hikari and Gaming Plus, to Docomo hikari in order to save money by bundling my phone with my home internet.

I'm really happy with the ipv4 speeds from Gaming Plus, but I understand they are just reselling an IPv6 VNE's internet service? In this case it seems like JNE since their IPv4 over IPv6 technology is v6 plus, and they link to JNE's website for compatible routers.

So for my move from Fleets to Docomo Hikari, I want to stay with JNE I think, but I can't seem to find which VNE the Docomo Hikari providers use.

"Docomo Net" says it uses a combination of OCN Virtual Connect and Transix for their ipv4 over ipv6 solution. Does this mean its possible to have multiple VNEs and Docomo net uses both OCN and Transix, or do VNEs also sell their ipv4 over ipv6 solutions to customers using a different VNE for ipv6 internet connectivity. If so, can I check my current VNE in case Gaming Plus does not use JNE, since my youtube speeds are good, and I want to stay with the same IPv6 VNE, as well as IPv4 over IPv6 provider.

And finally, is my ISP at all involved in either IPv6 IPoE, or IPv4 Over IPv6. Like, does JNE give my ipv4 packets to Gaming Plus after it gets to their AFTR(or Map-E equivalent) or is it just handled by JNE? I'm only interested in switching if I can get the same service I do with gaming plus, because I have had slow internet with OCN before and it was really frustrating, and not worth what I would save by moving off of fleets.

So if they are just reselling JNE I think @ -nifty also mentions it uses v6 plus for IPv6 over Ipv4, and seems like they would be using JNE as a VNE(?) meaning I would be getting exactly the same service as I do on gaming plus? Maybe +or- DNS server speed, email account, customer service?

Thanks so much for any help and apologies if I'm misunderstanding anything. I attempted to do a lot of research but eventually got stuck, possibly due to my poor Japanese to google for the right answer.

Posted Jan 2, 2021, 7:03 PM UTC · edited

215
jbankers•

Gaming Plus is reselling JPNE's VNE service, but you should check the IPv4 address at the end of the tunnel (ie: that shown by 'what is my IP address?' sites) to see whose netblock it belongs to, as it may be that there is a dedicated BR for the Gaming Plus services, so that the IPv4 addresses you can make use of are located closer to popular gaming servers. If the addresses are simply in JPNE's IPv4 allocation, then there is nothing special about them. Generally, ISPs will offload IPv6 to IPv4 translation service to the VNE and will have nothing to do with your connectivity unless you use PPPoE, and this is of particular advantage when using junk-grade ISPs such as the 'FreeBit' brands.

To verify your VNE, find your global IPv6 address and look it up using WHOIS (https://www.nic.ad.jp/).

If you want to continue to use JPNE as your VNE, then you need an ISP on the DoCoMo Hikari menu that provides 'v6 Plus' service (https://www.jpne.co.jp/service/v6plus/). You can find a list here: https://www.nttdocomo.co.jp/binary/pdf/hikari/provider_list/ipv6/IPv6_compatibility.pdf

Note that BIGLOBE is also using MAP-E, but they are their own VNE: https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E4%BB%AE%E6%83%B3%E5%9B%BA%E5%AE%9A%E9%80%9A%E4%BF%A1%E6%8F%90%E4%BE%9B%E8%80%85#%E3%83%95%E3%83%AC%E3%83%83%E3%83%84%E7%B6%B2%E3%81%AB%E3%81%8A%E3%81%91%E3%82%8BVNE has a list of VNEs.

If you are particularly set on JPNE, then @Nifty and GMO will allow you to continue using that service if you switch your billing relationship from NTT West/East to NTT DoCoMo.

When you cease to be an NTT West/East retail customer and choose either the collaboration or the NTT DoCoMo billing model, your choice of VNE is limited to that which your PPPoE ISP allows you to select, and you may only select one VNE per FLETS circuit.

OCN Virtual Connect is MAP-E, and it appears that they also have a contract with Transix (operated by Internet Multifeed: IMF - themselves a VNE) for those whose CPE is not MAP-E compliant: Transix will only perform the AFTR role for those B4 devices whose IPv6 address lies within a prefix allocated by one of their customers: most Transix users are users of the IMF VNE, but the OCN setup has NTT Communications (their own VNE) allocating your IPv6 address, which will then be accepted by Transix for use with their DS-Lite AFTR.

Presumably NTT Communications does not wish to implement DS-Lite on their own network and has outsourced it to IMF - depending on where the OCN Virtual Connect BR nodes are located, they may be closer to you. Because your own equipment supports MAP-E it should probably work with OCN Virtual Connect without issue, but you won't be using JPNE's network.

4
level3commOP•

Thank you for the very detailed reply! It looks like I am indeed using JPNE ipv4 and ipv6 addresses!

It sounds like, based on your explanation, the double circles in the PDF that do both "OCN virtual connect, and Transix" are just using OCN as the VNE, and if your device supports MAP-E using OCN virtual connect, and if only DS-Lite using Transix. So I could attempt to use Docomo Net as my ISP and try OCN as a VNE. I had them as a PPPOE isp before and was unhappy with the speed, but that might just have been general PPPOE infrastructure issues.

I do wonder if OCN's MAP-E different from JPNE's. My router claims it will do "v6 Plus" MAP-E, which BIGGLOBE and JPNE use, but I wonder if OCN's is just different enough to be incompatible, since they only List NTT HGWs and the Docomo Router as supporting OCN virtual connect, rather than having a list as big as JPNE's.

2
jbankers•

I would encourage you to try 'DoCoMo Net'. If you want to change the ISP later, that is possible without a cease and reprovide, although there are some fees applicable.

PPPoE issues are due to NTT West/East network planning limitations: I and others have discussed this in detail before (search for 網終端装置服装).

My personal belief is that telcos should not involve themselves in IP routing, and that they should focus on layer 2 transport: 'IPoE' involves the telco in routing, and results in the trap that is it necessary to take out a 'Hikari Denwa' service to obtain anything larger than a /64 - the access network operated by the telco should always be a 'dumb pipe' (土管屋), and the addressing specifics should be between the client and the ISP.

BIGLOBE is no longer providing JPNE service to new customers: the 'v6 Plus' option is now closed to new subscriptions, because BIGLOBE is now a VNE in its own right. The 'v6 option' is what they provide now.

For actual compatibility you will need to ask the device vendor or run the risk: at least with both MAP-E and DS-Lite, you have more options. As 'v6 Plus' is a trademark rather than a specification, NTT Communications (OCN) cannot refer to their MAP-E implementation as such.

Incidentally, if you subscribe to the 10 Gbps service, PPPoE is not available (because PPPoE interconnections with NTT West/East are not capable of anything close to that speed), and thus the ISP branding is completely irrelevant for the purposes of choosing the quality of the connection - everything comes down to the VNE, and the 'ISP' is reduced to a reseller.

3
level3commOP•

Thank you for the reply!

It seems like BIGLOBE's v6 option uses the exact same MAP-E as JPNE does though, since their website mentions v6 plus compatible routers will work with their service. Or is this incorrect, and its only for when they used to use JPNE?

1
jbankers•

https://support.biglobe.ne.jp/ipv6/option.html

"MAP-E機能を搭載している市販の機器においてもIPv6オプションをご利用いただけますが、すべての機種でIPv6オプションを使えることを保証するものではありません。また、当社では当該機器の動作をサポートしておりません"

Basic MAP-E support should be sufficient, but there is no guarantee, especially for inbound port fowarding. BIGLOBE should not be referring to 'v6 Plus' compatibility with their own VNE's MAP-E implementation, as 'v6 Plus' is JPNE's trademark.

2
bloggie2•

There's a decent summary of available V4 over V6 options here: https://internet-manual.net/flets-ipv6-ipoe-connect-services/ about halfway down the page, and it also answers your docomo-related questions. As far as I understand re: ISP involvement, no. since you just connect to transix or whoever directly.

2
level3commOP•

Thank you! Excellent read.

I think from reading it, it seems like you can only use 1 VNE per ONU.

I wonder then in the case of Docomo net, is it somewhat random wether I get OCN virtual connect or Transix?

My Router can do v6 Plus and DS-lite(Transix) but not OCN virtual connect. i wonder if there is a way to tell before I switch?

1
5hJack•

I'm trying to wrap my head around switching form Fleets Hikari and Gaming Plus, to Docomo hikari in order to save money by bundling my phone with my home internet.

I'm going through a similar conversion at the moment, so I've probably looked at a lot of the same resources you have. I may be wrong on this, but doesn't (NTT) Docomo just act as an ISP for the (NTT) FLET'S Hikari infrastructure? If so, you should be able to keep whatever back-end services you have right now when you transfer the account.

2
level3commOP•

Yeah that's one part I'm unclear on, like I wonder if PPPOE usernames and passwords intended for Fleets would work on Docomo Hikari.

I know NTT Fleets and Docomo Hikari use the same lines, but I think with Docomo for the IPV6 IPOE option you have to choose from this list of providers, since they need to apply via Docomo to apply to NTT to set your ONU to start giving out IPv6 Addresses. Sadly no Gaming Plus in the list: ドコモ光のプロバイダ | ドコモ光 | NTTドコモ (nttdocomo.co.jp)

2
jbankers•

'DoCoMo Hikari' is just billing sleight of hand.

You still have a FLETS circuit, and in most cases you will also keep the same ID number (that is, the circuit ID starting with CAF or COP).

There are four modes of billing:

  • Original FLETS: you subscribe to FLETS from NTT West/East, and you pay them for the circuit only. You can then add an ISP, a VNE, Layer 3 VPN service, TV, etc., by making separate arrangements.

  • Original FLETS billed by ISP: as above, except your ISP may also collect the charges due to NTT West/East.

  • Collaboration model: the ISP wholesales FLETS service, and the options you can choose are limited. Some options can be added by making a separate contract with NTT West/East. Collaboration used to be a roach motel in that migrations required ceasing service, but this issue has been addressed.

  • NTT DoCoMo discount system: like the collaboration model, but you have your choice of PPPoE ISP/IPv6 VNE (choice of ISP implies their choice of VNE).

While the billing interface/support responsibility changes with each model (and along with it complications about what services can be used), the access network is still vanilla FLETS, with all its warts and foibles.

Your ONU has nothing to do with your IPv6 address allocation: it's just an intelligent media converter. All configuration is done in devices outside your premises.

2
level3commOP•

Interesting, I wonder if its possible to buy just the line from Docomo and use gaming plus.

It seems like Docomo has to bundle an ISP with their line rental, so I may be stuck unless I want to pay for two ISPs... which somewhat defeats switching to Docomo, even the 10% discount won't make up Gaming Plus's 3000 per month fee.

1
jbankers•

That would be self-defeating. If you want to use JPNE's service, simply choose an ISP that subcontracts JPNE for the VNE, such as GMO.

2
bloggie2•

You don't need a username/password for ipv6 at all. You just plug stuff and you get autoconfigured ip address. you most definitely can use different providers over same flets line, if you use pppoe - you can increase session limit by paying some extra fee and connect to several providers. not sure how v6 would fit into the picture - probably have to enable it in one provider and disable for the rest.

1
level3commOP•

I think part of my confusion is that Docomo bills you for both your ISP, and the line fee. This is good since with the Gold Dcard you get 10% off making it much cheaper than Fleets and many of the IPoE ISPs. Even if you consider the annual fee, and the 1% cash back opportunity cost of using a different credit card.

With Gaming Plus, I had to give them my NTT customer information for them to get the ONU to stop giving out NGN private IPv6 addresses and give out public IPv6 addresses. I don't think with Docomo Hikari that we get this NTT customer information, so I think I could not use Gaming plus. Even with Fleets you can only have one IPv6 IPoE ISP per line, you need to submit forms to NTT to change it.

It's not super important since PPPoE has been too slow to be usable for a while now, but since you don't need to give them any information about your NTT line, its not unsurprising that PPPoE for other ISPs would work with Docomo Hikari.

2