Does Riot really need to nerf Taliyah in every role when she's only overpowered in the jungle after a jungle-specific buff?

While Taliyah has been one of the least played champs in the game for a while, her playerbase pretty evenly played her between Mid, Jungle, Bot, and Support. However, with the preseason changes, Taliyah was struggling a lot in the jungle, she was one of the worst junglers in the game, so she clearly needed buffs. The single buff she got in 10.25 was:

Threaded Volley

  • Subsequent stone damage against monsters increased to 100% from 50%.

This almost doubled her damage to camps, which is evidently insane lol. This single buff made her one of the strongest and most picked junglers in the game this patch, and considering this patch has a lot of super strong junglers, that's obviously problematic and in need of nerf. The nerf they're going with:

P

  • Movement speed: 20-45% >>> 12-40%

So, as a result of way overbuffing specifically her jungle, their response is to immediately nerf her in every single role? On paper it's a big nerf too, it's a difference of like 20-30 movespeed. I feel like the obvious solution would be to lower her subsequent stone damage against monsters to like 75% or something to, you know, tweak the massive overbuff she got, instead of just nerfing her everywhere? Like I really don't see why this isn't the kind of nerf they're going with.

I've seen the sentiment that "she's being played a lot in the jungle now, so who cares about her other roles." But, ignoring how they already give other champs buffs for roles that nobody plays them in while Taliyah's playerbase actually played her in other roles, frankly I don't really think that Taliyah is going to stay with a high pickrate if she isn't super OP. And I'd assume that nerfing her in every role is just going to hurt her pickrate even more in those.

This just seems like a really poor way of handling things. People complain about her -> they overbuff her jungle -> they nerf her everywhere -> now she's worse in other roles than before.

Posted Jan 5, 2021, 6:00 PM UTC · edited

1.1K351
Loading comments…