Help Choosing a Smoker

Hey reddit,

I'm looking to pick up a pellet grill and could use some help deciding which one to get. I already have an Akorn, a charcoal grill, and a gas grill. And I'm in Central Florida so snow/freezing temps is no kind of worry. I'm looking to use the pellet grill mainly as a smoker since I can sear and grill on my others.

I've narrowed it down to 3 choices and I'd love to hear yalls thoughts:

  • Pit Boss Pro 1150 - I like this one since it seems sturdy, has a huge hopper, and a friend has the Pro 1100 and loves it. Plus it's the cheapest. But, I'm not a fan of only being able to set temps in 25-50 degree increments.
  • GMG Jim Bowie - I see this one getting a lot of love here and on YouTube, and my local ACE has a deal where you get the rotisserie attachment for free with the grill right now.
  • Camp Chef Woodwind Wifi 36 - I like the stainless steel and the ash cleanout on this one, and I also like the option to add a Sidekick later.

Thanks!

Posted Jan 7, 2021, 7:21 PM UTC

314
highspeedrace•

I would steer clear of the pitboss 1150. I had one for 5 days and the controller was incapable of keeping temp below 300. If set below 300 the temp would drop like a rock until it flamed out. Also the auger is noisy and sounds cheap. The temp problem is a known issue to pitboss and fairly widespread.

4
DivisionMatrixOP•

Alright, thanks, that's exactly the kind of stuff I want to know about in advance

1
Warlock_062•

I have the jom bowie prime plus and it has wifi with ash clean out port, love the thing use it as much as my wife will let me smoke dinner

2
x32htuom•

I just went through this. One thing I can tell you is that shipping from Camp Chef is more than 4 days to Florida. Tracking says next tuesday, which is 7 business days. For a delivery of that size, I feel it is totally understandable.

2
Jamieson22•

GMG Jim Bowie - I see this one getting a lot of love here and on YouTube, and my local ACE has a deal where you get the rotisserie attachment for free with the grill right now.

Am confused. Why would you use a rotisserie on a convection grill?

2
DivisionMatrixOP•

That's actually a damn good question, maybe use it with their optional perforated tray to get some direct heat at it? Could just be because people like rotisseries I guess

1
dgtyco•

Go with the GMG JB. Better temp range/control. Since you are looking to use it primarily as a smoker you dont need the camp chef with side kick. Stainless steel is more cosmetic and the JB is not too difficult to clean.

1
DivisionMatrixOP•

Thanks, and good point about the sidekick

1
Kanone5•

GMG JB doesn't have wifi or PID, both are worthwhile features particularly wifi. It also lacks the firebox clean-out of the CC, which is a major advantage of the latter. You may not need a sidekick since you have other options. But you might like having it right there plus it comes with a griddle. Haven't used my gas grill in ages.

1
DivisionMatrixOP•

My fault, I was looking at the Prime Plus wifi version I just managed to not write that. Do you think the firebox cleanout is enough of a feature to choose the CC over the others?

1
Kanone5•

Cleaning out the ash in the firebox, or the lack thereof, seems to be the biggest factor in flameouts on long cooks. Never had one in 4 years but that's a sample of one.

Many pellet grill owners on here report using a shopvac every couple of cooks. But my experience, and apparently others, has been using the ash dump every (other) time keeps it down to a big clean maybe every twenty cooks.

2
DivisionMatrixOP•

Nice, thanks

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
LovYouLongTime•

Have you thought of the Treager 575 pro? I have one and I love it! It’s big, sturdy, user friendly, great customer support, and a great community. It hasent let me down yet.

1
DivisionMatrixOP•

I looked at the Traeger 780 pro and just liked the GMG and CC more at that $1,000 price point. It came down to little stuff like the others having a second temp probe and ash cleanouts

1