Why read non-fiction if you'll forget it all?

Question is posed above. Here's my conundrum.

I enjoy reading non-fiction to learn more about sciences, social studies, and sometimes individuals. However, I've noticed that in a 5 year timeframe, I forget everything of substance from the books i had read.

This goes for all I read- psychology, politics, climate science, economics and biology. I must have read 10+ non-fiction books about climate change between 2012-2015, but I don't remember anything of significance.

'Not reading well'

One possible factor is that I just "read" them, not process them. However, I've read Freakonomics (and the subsequent series) with awe and spent almost a year thinking every interaction in the framework they had provided; but after 7 years, all that is left is that sense of awe. I had taken extensive notes while reading, too.

'Why do anything at all?'

I don't think anyone will respond with "why do anything at all?", but let me explain the thought process. I acknowledge that besides informing oneself, non-fiction books can be read for entertainment, but as someone who wants to be informed, I'm struggling to justify the effort for more technical non-fiction books from authors like Chomsky or Arendt (since I will forget all of it in a few years!). Similarly, I cannot justify re-reading a book that i had thoroughly read before - it feels like re-taking a course in college. The opportunity cost is immense.

--------------------------------------

In natural sciences, where i feel more comfortable with my training, I know that I can only retain information because it is well structured. Reading non-fiction books are fun, but they do not provide this kind of structure- and they would be textbooks if they could!

How is one supposed to read non-fiction and build upon one's previous reading? I am not as much looking for memorization advice - that is plenty on the Internet- but others' answer to this conundrum.

Reading non-fiction during and after 'school'

Let me also contextualize more: I am a student and I have to keep learning for classes. It may be that the demand for learning decreases upon leaving formal instruction, making knowledge from non-fiction books easier to retain. I would love to hear about experiences during and after formal instruction, too.

------------------------------------

I've framed this question from my perspective to avoid overgeneralization. However, I'm sure that I am not alone.

Adding: I've tried to use the search to find similar questions. Perhaps it's my phrasing, but it wasn't much successful. I would appreciate links to similar threads.

Posted Jan 8, 2021, 3:11 PM UTC · edited

532

I think the main reason to read anything is because you enjoy it.

If you're reading with the express intention to educate yourself and then finding that you forget the actual substance of the book after 5 years but you don't wish to reread the book. I would suggest reading books that will help you maintain or further develop the learnings from previous books. Learning is a process. If you're not maintaining the information then you will forget/lose access to it.

22
revenantae•

I would suggest that, should I care to test you, you remember more than you think you do. A book can be packed with information, and simply because you don't have a photographic recall of it doesn't mean you forgot everything.

Another point, you seem to read as if it's an assignment.... do you LIKE what you are reading, or are you doing it because you think 'you ought to'? Find books that appeal to you... as in, when you are finished you want to read it again.

15
albertnormandy•

I think it is almost impossible to retain everything from one reading. I read a lot of history and science. I have come to the conclusion that if there is anything in the book worth remembering I am going to have to read it, or at least the parts I am interested in, at least twice. The first reading identifies the parts of the book worth rereading later. You retain more than you think sometimes.

13
Dostoevsky-fan•

Hahaha. That’s true. I always have to restrain my tendency to say, “actually what you just said isn’t true...” and then pull out of a lifetime of reading some obscure fact about something I’d long forgotten I’ve learned.

It annoys people. People say, “How do you know that?” Me: “beats me. I read it somewhere.” Then they say “well I think your wrong” and away we go.

4
Astra_Star•

The way I think about reading is that I do it for two reasons:

  1. Because I enjoy it and find it to be a fair use of my time.

  2. To help me expand my knowledge and understanding of the world. For that, I don’t need to remember everything about the book. I just need to, immediately after reading it, know the message of the book and think about it.

I hope that makes sense. I just woke up.

ETA: Of course, I might occasionally read a book to learn more specific details, rather than the overview. In that case, I like taking notes.

10
bibliophile222•

I also forget almost all non-fiction I read. However, I have taken away a few important snippets here and there that have made it worthwhile. For instance, the importance of labor unions in the United States was my one giant takeaway from a People's History of the United States. I forgot all the honor details, but it still added to my overall knowledge base.

9
senatorb•

I agree with the other posters -- remembering everything isn't the point. Changing how your brain works might be the point. That takes time and many, many books.

Also, we write things down so we don't have to remember them. As long as we know where we can get the information, there might not be much point in having it clogging up the old gray matter.

But if you want to retain what you've read, you might want to start a book journal. Read a book, write down a few things you want to recall, then review your journal every time you finish a new book. Soon you'll have a good index for your reading history.

9
theshadowofself•

Not op, but I have run into the same issue and I really love this idea. Thanks for the tip!

4
[deleted]•

Reading non-fiction books are fun, but they do not provide this kind of structure

Actually they often do. You have to work on finding the structure though, and it's a key part of deeply understanding them. Also even if you can't remember random trivias about them, carefully reading them and thinking about them should definitely influence you and affect your worldview. If you re-read non-fiction books years later you should realize that some idea you thought came from you or that seemed obvious to anyone with half a brain actually came from those books. It could also be that you read crappy non-fiction books that merely accrete facts and fail to have an overreaching argument that goes beyond clichés. Those are indeed hard to remember.

5
nakedreader_ga•

Do you remember everything from every fiction book you read? I don't. Hell, I just read a book I think I've already read before but can't really remember if I had or not. If you're reading for instruction, take notes. I don' think your contention that reading nonfiction once you're beyond instruction is valid. If you're a big reader, you'll never retain everything you've read.

4
pineapplesf:bluestar:186•

I think it's been well documented that knowledge is a use it or lose it kinda thing. Assuming I don't talk or think about it at all, I remember the basics of books for about a decade after reading -plot, themes, major characters. If I want to remember more I need to either read it again or look at notes or look at a summary.

Nonfiction often doesn't have a "story" making it more difficult to remember. Increasing retention could be reading more on the subject, writing more detailed notes, using it more often, or rewriting it in your head to a story that multiple books can add to. Also keep in mind that humans have finite working memories. It doesn't make the act of learning useless.

3
bendingspoonss•

This thought is actually what led me away from non-fiction and more into things like historical fiction (instead of historical NF). Not only did I find a lot of NF books to be pretty dry, but like you, I never found myself able to retain enough to really justify the effort that went into reading them. Eventually I figured out that what I really wanted was to be immersed in whatever it was I wanted to learn more about, just with a story framed around it that made it more enjoyable to read and, at least for me, easier to recall.

2
Dostoevsky-fan•

I too am leaky as heck and forget almost everything I read. I’m not very smart yet because I read constantly my friends think I’m brilliant. Reading shapes your thought processes themselves and forms you into a person able to think clearly. This is why multiple books and authors are essential. Reading one point of view or sitting in one internet echo chamber shaped you into the weirdest forms. This is how idiotic stuff like Q and the flimsy conspiracy theories happen. People who read nothing. Ever. Then go online and are immersed in reading only that theory. They don’t have their minds shaped and protected by being taught to think by books themselves.

Education should be the thought about in terms of teaching people, to engage in a life long pursuit of thinking itself.

2

Dude, your friends are right in their assessment.
I'm gifted and when I see or hear someone that is intelligent I recognize it. Likely you equate intelligence with (professional) success. That is not the case. Go do an IQ-Test, you'll learn some things about yourself ;)

Ah, and thank you for your insight. Just stopped reading self-help weeks ago because of the exact reason you stated. Self-help books are for and from people that need self-help. By only reading these books you become a person that needs self-help as you only see this perspective while you were perfectly fine before.

2
scattergraphOP•

I hope that you'll discover that an IQ test is almost worthless, and 'gifts' come in many forms, and none of them are even the slightest bit as important or valuable as having a strong work ethic or being a decent person.

3

I get where you are coming from. Intelligence is overrated in our society, just being intelligent is not enough, IQ-tests only measure a limited range of intelligence and empathy is more important in most jobs.

But why are you telling me this? Did I say any different? Reflect on it.

I'm merely telling my height, this doesn't mean I'm a good basketball player. Having a big potential doesn't mean that you use this potential. u/Dostoevsky-fan pointed this out perfectly.
But the insight that being tall is good for basketball players gives me the confidence to pursue such a career. All I try to do is share this insight with fellow tall people :)
And just because I'm tall doesn't mean I'm not a jerk or couch potato.

Do you see how warped your perspective on intelligence is? Comments like yours make it hard for people like us to discover our strength. Please don't.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Dostoevsky-fan•

Your very kind. What I meant (the limitations of conversation via writing like this are frustrating) about brilliant is not what I’ve developed into. I meant Brilliance as a natural gift that sets apart those who are born with a brilliant mind. I recognize I’ve developed my intellect more than most people have just as I recognize that through 50 years of practicing Tenor Saxophone I’ve developed the ability to play jazz very well. I mean... I think raw talent would be a better word to use. Raw talent remembers books and ideas for a long time. I can practice my horn for 8 hours a day and I will never be able to play Coltranes seminal Giant Steps tune. Those astonishing chord changes and he keeps up changing keys every 3 or 4 measures while improvising those solid walls of sound. Talent. I also golf a little and have no natural talent. I’m always hoping to beat 100 and every now and again shoot a mid 99’s game. No natural talent. The exciting thing for me is the plasticity of the human mind that allows it to change and grow even into old age. I just retired after 37 years working at FedEx and now I finally have the opportunity to focus once more on literature and playing my horn more. That is whenever my grand kids leave me alone which isn’t often. Haha.

So it is with intellect. I’m a naturally mediocre mind that through persistence and constant reading have reached (not my full potential) but a very high degree of potential for my mediocre mind. I have taken an IQ test and mine is around 110 or so. My brothers IQ is 140 and my Moms is 135. My Dad read all the time. Both were teachers so reading and conversation filled our home growing up. We went to the library constantly and checked out books as a family outing.

2

You're upbringing definitely left its marks :)
Once again proof that brilliance (in your definition) does not define the person one can become :)

Ah, I'm confident that you'll be able to play similar tunes to the one you've mentioned one day if you now have more time on your hands. Set the highest reasonable goal and work towards it!

1
Dostoevsky-fan•

I was very very fortunate to have such parents. They loved others so well. I have almost no scars from my upbringing from my parents. Similar tunes... well... sort of. I’ve (mostly mastered) the chorus of the song Take Five but when Paul Desmond launched off into that effortless improvisational dance... well. There’s a huge gap between the music that plays in my soul and the music that comes out of my horn. The nerve connections just won’t flow fast enough. That’s the Raw Talent part of each human on earth I’m talking about. I believe anyone can achieve a high degree of proficiency at almost anything but to return to the original discussion.

The OP was asking, “Should I continue to struggle with material that’s over my head and I don’t enjoy reading?” Or perhaps their question could be framed, “If I continue to grapple with material that’s over my head, will I eventually mater it?”

That answer, for most people has limits. Talent. I will never in a million years no matter how long I try have a photographic memory. I must be content to read a book, while I’m reading stand blown away by the Authors insight and the way prose flows so beautifully from that persons Raw Talent space linked with the hard work over ten thousand hours or Mose required to fully develop said talent.

I adore the flowing prose of Pat Conroy for example. The book Beach Music. Wow. I’ve read a few pages of Einstein’s theory of relativity... made me laugh actually. I felt like an average runner trying to race against the gold medal winner in the Marathon at the olympics. He’s out of sight in seconds.

Accepting my mediocrity while doing all I can to fully develop my Raw Talent is a constant fight against discouragement measures against the delight I take when I finally (sort of) get a glimmer of the Authors deeper point, his heart, when I read The Brothers Karamasov and ding myself suddenly deeply identifying with say, Fyodor the despicable Father and new depths of compassion for people trapped in their passions and hatred and pride rise up in me. “Crap (I think) when I hear a politician take some childish stand based on his undeveloped ability to look into his own inner person, “I could be Just. Like. That, Guy if it weren’t for my parents helping me, training me, teaching me which direction I should grow in. “As the twig sprouts so grows the tree” someone has said. I have two beautiful apple trees. Planted over 25 years ago in my front yard. I’ve been pruning them and pinching shoots and so on every season. They are beautifully shaped but, I’ve had to work with what sprouts, what flows from the tree. I was hoping it would so sprout shoots in certain directions I could encourage by pruning all the others but it would sprout branches in other directions I had to use instead. Now they sprout suckers EVERYWHERE on the tree and I must cut most of them to maintain the trees shape or it will become a snarly mess. The fruit withering as the out of control water shoots drain all the sap from the fruit and redirect its energy to undisciplined, out of control, competing branches each one striving against the others.

So it is with intellectual development or just reading for enjoyment. I only read for enjoyment these days. When I was younger I’d read a book, get bogged down but in my stubborn pride plod through it anyway, understanding almost none of it and remembering hardly any of it. I’ve read all of Paradise Lost by Milton for example. Half the time I had no idea what I was reading. Then I’d catch a paragraph or phrase that took my breath away. In 10 minutes, that thought was long gone. Oh how my hands can only hold one gem at a time. I must let them slip through my fingers back onto the incomprehensibly huge treasure of Smaug lying all around me.

Oh the treasure lying around in libraries. Too many books too little time! I want to know more than I want to know. I have an insatiable desire for knowledge. To find a way to understand well... everything. How I’d love to fathom the depths of how DNA and RMNA work together to instruct the body to make proteins for example. I’ve read extensively trying to understand the Coronavirus vaccine and how it works. Vastly complex! Wow the process! I’d love to follow that particular branch of knowledge. Not enough time or brain cells in this mediocre brain of mine. Sigh.

I must be content with who I am.

So to the original poster who may not even read this. I ramble all over the place don’t I? My son once told me (he’s got an actual photographic memory. He read the textbook in his Greek class then slept through class and and still got a A) “Dad, sometimes you tend to..... Wax.” I was a little mad then instantly began to laugh. At myself. At my own pride. How I think since I’ve read something about something and so want others to share that enthusiasm, I bore people to tears frequently. So now I bite my tongue mostly and let others speak. I can indulge rambling on and on when I write mine this because I’m in no danger of boring anyone when I write. The reader can choose to read it not. Your not a captive audience when you read.

If you don’t like what your reading, if it annoys you or bores you or if it’s too difficult to grasp.

Move on without regret.

Edit: autocorrect issues on my iPhone. Sorry.

1
Tex2002ans•

Why read non-fiction if you'll forget it all?

[...]

One possible factor is that I just "read" them, not process them.

I answered a similar "forget it all" question posted just 2 hours before yours!

I think you'll need to learn "How to Read a Book"! :P

("How to Read a Book" by Mortimer Adler is actually the name of the book I highly recommend. See post above + linked article/posts.)

I acknowledge that besides informing oneself, non-fiction books can be read for entertainment, but as someone who wants to be informed, I'm struggling to justify the effort for more technical non-fiction books from authors like Chomsky or Arendt (since I will forget all of it in a few years!).

Adler covers this all. He splits reading into 4 levels of progressively more complicated/in-depth reading.

  1. Elementary Reading
  2. Inspectional Reading
  3. Analytical Reading
  4. Syntopical Reading

In Level 2, Adler splits it into two subcategories:

  • Systematic skimming
  • Superficial reading

What you're doing is Level 2, "Superficial reading"—mostly just reading, getting the gist of the arguments, then moving on.

Or in Adler's terms: "reading for information" (and not absorbing) where you want "reading for understanding". (See below.)

In natural sciences, where i feel more comfortable with my training, I know that I can only retain information because it is well structured. [...]

How is one supposed to read non-fiction and build upon one's previous reading? I am not as much looking for memorization advice [...] but others' answer to this conundrum.

Adler covers this in Chapter 1, "The Activity and Art of Reading", especially the last paragraph:

The Goals of Reading: Reading for Information and Reading for Understanding

[...]

The distinction between reading for information and reading for understanding is deeper than this. Let us try to say more about it. We will have to consider both goals of reading because the line between what is readable in one way and what must be read in the other is often hazy. To the extent that we can keep these two goals of reading distinct, we can employ the word "reading" in two distinct senses.

The first sense is the one in which we speak of ourselves as reading newspapers, magazines, or anything else that, according to our skill and talents, is at once thoroughly intelligible to us. Such things may increase our store of information, but they cannot improve our understanding, for our understanding was equal to them before we started. Otherwise, we would have felt the shock of puzzlement and perplexity that comes from getting in over our depth-that is, if we were both alert and honest.

The second sense is the one in which a person tries to read something that at first he does not completely understand. Here the thing to be read is initially better or higher than the reader. The writer is communicating something that can increase the reader's understanding. Such communication between unequals must be possible, or else one person could never learn from another, either through speech or writing. Here by "learning" is meant understanding more, not remembering more information that has the same degree of intelligibility as other information you already possess.

There is clearly no difficulty of an intellectual sort about gaining new information in the course of reading if the new facts are of the same sort as those you already know. A person who knows some of the facts of American history and understands them in a certain light can readily acquire by reading, in the first sense, more such facts and understand them in the same light. But suppose he is reading a history that seeks not merely to give him some more facts but also to throw a new and perhaps more revealing light on all the facts he knows. Suppose there is greater understanding available here than he possessed before he started to read. If he can manage to acquire that greater understanding, he is reading in the second sense. He has indeed elevated himself by his activity, though indirectly, of course, the elevation was made possible by the writer who had something to teach him.

Of course, further in the book he explains how to effectively tie new knowledge to your current knowledge/expertise.


Let me also contextualize more: I am a student and I have to keep learning for classes. It may be that the demand for learning decreases upon leaving formal instruction, making knowledge from non-fiction books easier to retain. I would love to hear about experiences during and after formal instruction, too.

I highly recommend reading the Adler book. In each level, he gives many tips on how to absorb information better.

One method is sort of "prepping your mind for what's to come".

Before you even read the book, you could:

Analyze the Table of Contents—this shows you "what's coming up", how the book is structured, and how many pages are dedicated towards each topic.

Skim the Index—this shows you a high-level overview of what this book is about + what sorts of topics the author believes are very important.

In my two linked posts (see first link above), I gave an example of how this may be helpful.

Table of Contents (TOC)

Before even reading, you can quickly analyze the work at a very high/surface level, like looking at:

  • the order of chapters.
    • Chronological or Topical?
    • Linear (like a Fiction book)?
    • Standalone chapters (like a manual)?
  • how chapters are organized.
    • Parts, Chapters, Subchapters.
    • Wars > Battles > Skirmishes
  • how many pages dedicated to each chapter/section/topic?

Prepping yourself for what's to come gives you:

  • some "main/important topics" to focus on and where they're located
  • potential questions to "ask" before you begin reading

so when you hit those points, you may absorb the information better by having this outline/framework in your mind ahead of time.

For example, let's say you have multiple history books about a civil war:

  • One author may explain in purely chronological order (this lead to this lead to this).
  • The other by main battles (here were the most important turning points).
  • The other by topic (Economic, Social, Military).

Each method of organizing emphasizes different facets of the war

[...]

Indexes

In the other post I referenced, I gave the example:

  • famous philosophers
    • Aquinas, 10
    • Aristotle, 1, 5, 60, 199
    • Socrates, 20, 60

You could use the index to get a very broad overview of WHAT information is covered in a given book. Even the size of the entries can tell you how "important" an author thinks a topic is. For example, the author may consider Aristotle to be more important than Aquinas (4 vs. 1).

Again, Adler covers all this stuff and other such tools in much more detail. :)


Anyway, I hope this post was helpful. "How to Read a Book" really helped me tackle Non-Fiction in a completely different light, and made me actually absorb/retain more.

I can honestly say, before I read that book, "I didn't even know how to read a book"! :)

2

Thank you for taking the time to explain the use of this book!
Couldn't do it any better :)

2
Rmsbasto•

I read books for fun. Even books about history, psychology or economics. It's just themes that interest me and if I forget them I might read them again.

1
Ayearinbooks•

For me the key is not just passively taking on the info but using it in some way. Easiest with practical nonfiction but for e.g. history or politics rhis might mean reading other books on overlapping topics in a reflective way and/or discussing it, including online.

1
TheStrangersCase•

I have severe memory problems due to seizures, but I still read for enjoyment 🤷🏻‍♀️ You can still look things up online or go back into the book (if you own it) if you forget things.

1

I mostly read non-fiction books.
They're not about the facts. The facts are only there to support the ideas. And these ideas change how you see the world. You read them because you want to change your perspective. And this change is permanent.

May I suggest you read "How to Read a Book"? It teaches you how to get the most out of a book.

I haven't read 'Sapiens' to know how we humans have risen through the food chain and created ideologies and technology. I've read it to understand how insignificant the time-spans and problems of our lives are. At least that's what I got out of it.
I haven't read 'Educated' to remember Tara's educational progress. But I now can empathize with those that have never been educated.
I haven't read 'Talking to Strangers' to remember all the stories Gladwell is telling. But I now truly understand that the stranger in front of me is exactly as complex of a human being as I am.

1
xXBadger89Xx•

When you watch a movie are you able to quote every line? of course not but that doesn't mean you didn't get something out of it. You still remember bits and pieces and nobody can remember every single thing. But as long as you feel like you got what they author intended as their main point and remember some of the supporting points that's good and you're learning more than people that don't read at all

1
cjhreddit•

Your brain is changed by the information it processes. You might not remember the high level content, but you will have reinforced some pathways that will change the way you think in future. So for example, I have no recollection of the books I read that improved my reading skills from infancy, but my reading skill is way better than it was when I was five !

There are other books that I read later in life, that introduced new ideas to me, and I constantly use those concepts, with only a vague memory of the explicit wording of my introduction to those ideas. They obviously sank in though, and I can remember the title of the book where the ideas came from, but they obviously had massive effects on my brain that I'm not directly aware of, but which change the way I think.

1
dyrtdaub•

I read travel books from the past so it’s like I’m time traveling! Bonus if you can drive to where you’re reading about .....

1

I only read non-fiction. I've read two novels in the last four years and something like 50 other books in that time. I've noticed the difficulty you describe, the way things slip from my memory even though I put so much time and thought into them before.

So now I keep a casual reading log in a notebook. I make notes on major themes, as well as memorable events, figures, and ideas. I note any connections that stand out to me between ideas in this book and another I previously read. I record the page number of anything I want to look up or explore further in another book. I record definitions of words that I'd like to add to my regular vocabulary. And I try to make notes too of any memorable trains of thought that came up during my reading. I think putting all of these meta parts of the experience of reading on paper helps me to retain a lot more, and I've referred back to my notes many times.

I know this probably looks like a lot of work, especially to a current student. You're already making notes on everything else you read. If that would kill any remaining joy that reading for yourself would offer, by all means disregard. :)

1