TN Troubles. Changing Port of Entry?

Writing on behalf of my wife.

My wife has applied twice in a few days for TN status at YYZ. The first time she was rejected because the company didn't put in a precise job title on the letter (they put Scientist instead of Chemist). The second time she was rejected because they left the internal job title (Research Associate) in the letter, and CBP took it as a multi-category application (even though she's definitely not trying both).

She's in contact with the lawyer at the company hiring her. Is it worth suggesting trying a different port of entry? On the one hand, recent reading of the internet suggests YYZ scrutinizes things pretty closely. On the other, apparently port of entry shopping also looks bad.

Driving across the border is not an option either way.

Any assistance or suggestions would be appreciated! Thank you!

Posted Jan 14, 2021, 7:54 PM UTC

17
powder_gwn•

As a general rule, you need to work through the PoE that you applied to. Going to another PoE (PoE shopping) is very much frowned upon.

​

Does the lawyer review the letters prior to sending to wife - is HR providing letter ?

I would escalate things at the company to seek additional help with a good quality TN package....

3
EltargrimOP•

First letter HR provided the letter. Second letter was handled by the lawyer. As best we can tell the only issue is with the job title, nothing else has come up; but CBP isn't exactly laying it all on the table.

0
fvalerach•

When I did it I read online that some PoE had specialized agents for TN applications. One of those was the PoE on your way to Buffalo (I know there are severals) so I went there and immediately as I told them I was applying for the TN visa they sent me with this other officer which understood and made everything easier. Now may I ask: why driving is not an option? I am sure wherever you go they would know she has applied twice.

Now that I am thinking about it I think at some point I read someone saying to avoid changing ports as they would take it as you are trying to find someone more forgiving and would just make it hard for you to get it

2
EltargrimOP•

Now may I ask: why driving is not an option? I am sure wherever you go they would know she has applied twice.

Doesn't have a car; she flew into Canada for the holidays, got a job offer while she was there, and is now trying to return to the US. She was previously present under J-2 status (dependent on my J-1).

Appreciate the perspective. YYZ is supposed to be one of the specialized ports, but anecdotally I've just found that they're also supposed to be harsher, I don't have evidence either way.

0
1660CBBW•

Port shopping looks bad, i almost got rejected just by doing that. Has her employer tried filing change of status? You can get approval while in canada, then just cross border to present approval to get official tn stamp. In my experience peace bridge poe is the best, they have the biggest foot crossing for handling tn.

3
EltargrimOP•

Good to know. If you don't mind me asking, what's the story behind "almost"? They let you in in the end?

The employer hasn't tried filing change of status, for a couple of reasons. The first is that we were under the impression that getting it at the border was fairly straightforward, and she was already travelling. The second is that we're not entirely sure if we're subject to the J Two Year Home Residency requirement; if we are, she can't change her status, but she can apply at the border.

0
1660CBBW•

Answering your second question, you are wrong. At border crossing you are subject to the whim of the one TN officer you meet. If he/she is having a bad day, or is feeling racist that moment, you are screwed, like how your wife was rejected twice. Given how trump changed the tone of the country in the last few years, i dont think the racist part is an exaggeration. When i was there, they were literally playing his speeches on repeat on a TV. If you meet someone who takes a liking to you, they will let you thru. If not, even if other officers feel you should be qualified, they will not risk contradicting one of their colleagues. Dm me if you want to discuss the first question, i dont feel like publically commenting about that.

2