Death Sentence

In Norway we had a terrorist called Anders Behring Breivik, he killed 77 people from the Social Democratic party (he was extremely right-wing, adored Hitler) Should he be spared? I can’t imagine him walking out on the streets again.

Posted Jan 16, 2021, 5:55 PM UTC

147

"Should the state have the right to kill in cold blood when it decides it's necessary?"

Ultimately, any questions regarding the death penalty boil down to this fundamental question. While in my heart I maintain the belief that there can be no sacred cows, no issue or position that can't be questioned in anarchy, and that we must always work against the tendency towards dogmatism within our own movement, I have a hard time imagining much variation to a truly anarchist position on this question.

​

Now if Mr. Breivik had carried out his despicable act of terror from within an anarchist community, the question might be more difficult to answer. Even then, however, I do wonder what could be learned from such a person. How can we prevent this from happening again? What kinds of outreach and community resources could be leveraged to make it even more unlikely that another Anders Breivik never comes along? Can people who have fallen this far into beliefs that are extremist even among fascists ever be rehabilitated? We'll never know if such people face execution at the hands of an angry mob. Would this individual have even survived the attempt in a community where members are well armed and take personal responsibility for security instead of offloading that role onto a specialized class of police? That's even harder to answer. But I would be very, very suspicious of the convictions of any so called anarchist who applauded even a single cold blooded murder by the state, regardless of how detestable the person in question might be.

15
[deleted]•

I assume if he were walking on the streets again someone affected by his actions would retaliate, which I have no problem with. I am against the death penalty, as that is a statist measure.

6
[deleted]•

Check out the large discussion on this topic in r/debateanarchism... link here

Anarchists are against death penalties and capital punishment in both the short-term (within capitalist state societies) and hypothetical anarchist societies. Not just from a moral perspective, but because these things imply authorities and enforcers which are antithetical to anarchism. It doesn't make sense to say violence and retribution are either proclaimed or prohibited, there is no authority to either impose or prevent them in anarchism (expanded on in my comment in the above debate thread).

5
KatWolfe21•

The death penalty is unpopular among anarchists, but I don't see ourselves as pacifist. There are people who simple put would be better off executed- in this case, Breivik. Should the state have the right to execute Breivik? This is not a relevant question, the question I see more suitable is should an anarchist society have the right to execute someone such as Breivik if this incident was to occur in our society.

Anarchist groups have used execution as a method before- such as the Makhno and the Free Ukrainian Forces-, and I don't see how Breivik would be able to be rehabilated. I'm not willing to waste the time and energy of this community for the CHANCE that he may change his ways once released, because the negative of him repeating the crimes would outweight the positive that he may attempt to repay the sins of his initial crime.

People speak of exiling the criminals. Have we not factored in the cost, time and energy? To where will the criminals be exiled? One could argue a remote island far away- who will guard this island? A member of our community which could instead be here with us as opposed to some isolated island? We have enemies over the horizons, what's preventing them from resucing the criminals we've isolated to be used against us? And besides, here we as anarchist itch for a day where we can claim land for our own- for what reason are we speaking as if we own a piece of Siberia or Australia to send criminals to?

Of course, anarchist will pirotise focusing more on preventing crimes as opposed to punishing- but what do you do WHEN crimes do occur? You have to think of your people. You could argue that this is tribalism. Fair enough, but isn't exiling someone also a form of tribalism? Isn't deciding whether someone should be in or out of our community a form of tribalism?

The people should have the right to decide. If you are a leader of an anarchist society, remember that it is YOU that is answerable to the people, and I highly doubt that THE PEOPLE will be keen on letting an Anders Brevik-type roam free because "we're true anarchist!" Absolutely not, the people will kill him before a vote could even take place.

It's easy to say on the internet that you'd exile him to some imaginary island, but I know myself that if I was a member of the society and I was asked if such a criminal should be executed- I'd gladly say yes to that. We should not be squeamish about such, we have to look after our own otherwise the community we live in falls apart as had happened before. We reject authority from TOP but we don't reject authorty from the bottom- authority still exists in an anarchist society.

2
krayalo•

Ideally someone like this would be exiled, isolated away from all other humans and forced to scratch out a living on their own or die trying. Of course in the modern world this is not really a solution but this would be a theoretically reasonable way to deal with a dangerous sociopath in an anarchist society.

1
SomeRightsReserved•

I personally i believe that the ones affected by this crime (the victims, families of the victims) should be the ones to decide what to do.

1
urban_primitive•

To me, this issue boils down to self-defense. Which begs the question: would he do it again? Would killing him prevent predictable deaths?

I don't know the answer to those questions. In a minor scale, without an ideological influence, I think we could have a decent talk with a killer, understand his motives and reach a common ground that would prevent deaths.

If someone shows however that they can't be trusted to not kill again (for example, by killing again), we reach a problem. This person is a danger to the community.

This should still be looked on through a case by case basis. There is a great number of variables thar can make this go either way. I also tend to see fascism manifested that way as "gone too far". Maybe I'm wrong. Shit, I really hope I'm wrong.

0