Is Pi-hole really worth implementing?
I’ve been running Pi-hole for a while and have now looked at what it is actually blocking, as well as my subjective experience of reduction in advertising displayed.
To give this some context, we are a two adult household in the U.K., no children or grandchildren and a pretty normal range of devices (including a lot of Pi’s!) on our network. Neither of us in an online gamer; our internet use is pretty “middle of the road”, with the possible exception that we scarcely use FB, never use Twitter, Instagram and similar - by choice, seeing little value in them.
The vast bulk of what it “blocks” is “calls home” from Microsoft software.
I understand that some people inherently distrust and do not want such activity, but from all I can research, unless you are pretty deeply into corporate distrust, most of this is at least harmless and in some cases part of legitimate function (checking currency of “to do” lists for example).
Actual ad servers are so far down the list of blocked domains they don’t even show up, with a few tens of calls. I’ve run identical devices with and without PiHole as their DNS and there is no discernible performance difference (not that I expected any!)
The data involved also seems minimal. We are on an internet deal that has no practical data limits, so that does not matter anyhow.
Subjectively, whilst there seem to be less ads, it’s no big deal. I’ve never found it tempting to click on them and the distraction is minimal. In any event a growing number of sites seem to host their own ,neatly circumventing attempts to block!
To get to the point - I’ve concluded that, for us, the gain from Pi-hole is minimal and I’m going to deploy the Pi to other purposes.
However, before I do I would like to know what others have observed.
Do any others find the same? Is it a function of our particular internet use? Does anyone identify particular circumstances that do make it valuable - ie very significant numbers of blocks of actual advertising?
Thanks for sharing your experience!
Posted Jan 17, 2021, 3:10 PM UTC · edited