r/zen•
aamdev

Right and Wrong

Wumen's verse:

"Three pounds of flax” suddenly issued.
The words are intimate; the meaning is more intimate.
Those who arrive at theories of right and wrong,
Are thus people of right and wrong.

Seems like I am a person of right and wrong. My every action springs from the conceptual lens of right and wrong and I suffer endlessly making the same mistake again and again. It's like there is this judge, sitting here, and I habitually consult him before taking every action... I can't help it. It's only at r/zen, where I seem to take out my lenses for a bit, but otherwise, even saying 'Hi' to someone becomes a task of right and wrong.

Posted Jan 19, 2021, 12:05 PM UTC · edited

1180
royalsaltmerchantSaltyZen•

Three pounds of flax === three pounds of flax

4
unpolishedmirror•

Not four, don't be ridiculous.

3
royalsaltmerchantSaltyZen•

Not five, don’t be demanding.

3
unpolishedmirror•

Two?

The family is starved

1
royalsaltmerchantSaltyZen•

One. the merchant ripped you off

2
slowcheetah4545•

+Intimacy

1
BearBeaBeau•

Sometimes it's wrong to be right and right to be wrong, so... hey, do as the teacher says and you get full credit

3
aamdevOPFenghuang•

Only if I was after credit.

1
BearBeaBeau•

Sure, and if not just do.

Then it's a practical matter.

2
JollyTomBombadil•

"Those who arrive at theories of right and wrong are thus people of right and wrong"

What a right sentiment

3
aamdevOPFenghuang•

Seems like you too are a person of right and wrong.

3
JollyTomBombadil•

You're right, you got me

3
throwa5548New Account•

What makes you think he's right? Nah, I'll shut up😄

2
SoundOfEars•

It's like there is this judge, sitting here, and I habitually consult him before taking every action... I can't help it.

Can you ignore his comments? I mean, we all have voices in our heads, just learn to not confuse those with your self. Every situation begs for a solution, and when we accept that our thoughts are just a brute force computation of the possibilities with the most probabile of those imerging into consciousness, we see that the the "judge" is just a selective function. Who is consulting whom? I'd argue that you are one and the same, both not really existing beyond an idea. Letting of of this additional idea, forgetting the judge and self by juxtaposing them to each other. You will see the whole world emerge in their mutual destruction.

What I am saying is: "So? What are you going to do about it?"

3
aamdevOPFenghuang•

Nothing. I can't do shit about it. I am not even aware of when it happens.

1
throwa5548New Account•

Listen, just listen. Or.. if you identity more closely with another of your sensations use that. I.e. feeling, smelling, seeing, just see.

1
PlayOnDemand•

It's okay to be you.

In fact, I highly recommend it.

3
aamdevOPFenghuang•

What else can one be?

1
slowcheetah4545•

Well that's the crux isn't it. We pretend to be other and we suffer. It's delusion. It's ego.

2
The_Faceless_Face•

It's a trip

1
slowcheetah4545•

It's an always failing, desperate grasp at stasis in an existence that's only always ever changing. It's heartbreaking. It's madness. It's human.

2
jungle_toad•

Sometimes something that seems right in the moment, turns out to be wrong over time. Sometimes what seems right for the collective, is wrong for the individual. Yet, somehow, three pounds of flax is just the right amount.

3
aamdevOPFenghuang•

First sentence is right, second seems not.

2
jungle_toad•

Hahaha. 1000% correct.

1
SoundOfEars•

Are you expecting a refutation or a confirmation from us?

2
aamdevOPFenghuang•

No

1
SoundOfEars•

I would have taken a yes, or a mu, also.

Pretty much no difference in this context.

Well done!

Now, where does one step, standing on a high pole? Answer this or have your tail remain behind the threshold. XD

2
aamdevOPFenghuang•

Where does one want to go? There.

2
SoundOfEars•

I'd argue: here.

Here is my proof

1
BearBeaBeau•

Yes

1
The_Faceless_Face•
2
thralldumb•

Those who arrive at theories of right and wrong, Are thus people of right and wrong.

And what prevents a person from departing theories of right and wrong? Was a ladder cast off?

2
aamdevOPFenghuang•

Right and wrong.

1
thralldumb•

Right and wrong.

"Theories of..." No puritans left England? No Jews left Germany? No South Vietnamese left Vietnam? No Cubans left Cuba? No one leaves a street gang? You may be spending too much time around the cool kids.

1
aamdevOPFenghuang•

I'm too dumb to understand your point. I spend too much time with myself.

2
throwa5548New Account•

How would you spend less time with yourself 😄

2
[deleted]•

You could try seeing it as both. Right and wrong. Most stuff reveals it's influence post choice. "That turned out better than expected" or "Why was that simple task so draining?". Maybe everything can be right and wrong. Then it's back to simple preferences. Which are easier to change.

Edit: To address 3💷s: Waxen Flaxen

2
NothingIsForgotten•

What is the garment made from?

A simple expression.

Can you be natural or not?

2
aamdevOPFenghuang•

Always even when I am not.

2
NothingIsForgotten•

Therefore you cannot.

Naturally.

Where is the 'wrong' to make a 'right'?

Self Discomfit requires separation.

Foyan's mud and all.

1
zenthrowaway17•

You have theories of right and wrong?

Did you write your own bible, or are you just following somebody else's?

2
aamdevOPFenghuang•

It's all my own doing.

1
zenthrowaway17•

So... are the gays allowed?

1
aamdevOPFenghuang•

Only if I like them.

2
zenthrowaway17•

Are you sure you aren't talking about theories of liking and disliking?

2
Cache_of_kittens•

Why is r/zen any different to elsewhere?

1
aamdevOPFenghuang•

You only see words.

1
unpolishedmirror•

You brought yourself up to the gate. Settle this matter for yourself!

1
aamdevOPFenghuang•

I didn't mean to, I can't settle anything.

1
unpolishedmirror•
1
aamdevOPFenghuang•

I'm sure there is some joke there relevant to my comment, I just don't know what it is.

1
unpolishedmirror•

You are the car.

Even having decided that you can't settle anything - this is still it.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
jwiegley•

Your paragraph is from that judge.

1
2bitmoment•

Binary code - are you right wing or left wing, both cases are right and wrong ethics and moralities

What's it mean to not be? Maybe not care about morality? Not care about politics?

But neither to do whatever you want, right? Is what makes sense and consistent and natural right?

I think it's rather that what is is. It is what it is. Neigher right nor wrong, any conceptual imagining is a falsification or rationalization.

1