Why do I need to pay tributes for peace even if I clearly have the upper hand? [e1.5.7]

Question

I steamrolled Vlandia pretty well, took many prisoners, incited heavy casualties while took very few losses, and I am stronger than them on kingdom tab, but still I need to pay a tribute of 1230 for a peace agreement? It is that because:

​

  1. I did not bother to get the dragon banner, so my kingdom lacks legitimacy?
  2. or because I am an independent kingdom?
  3. or because my kingdom has only one clan, which has only two parties (my party and a companion party)?
  4. or because Vlandia is not properly beaten and I should grind them more? Now all they can do is to Banzai siege my towns with armies of recruits... but I do want to keep them alive and let them recover so that I can fight knights in shiny armour...

need to pay a tribute of 1230 for peace

I destroyed everyone on my last play through and never thought about having peace [e1.5.5].. but this time I want play slower and take a break to do some shopping. I started a new game on e1.5.7, according to the patch notes having peace should be easier now:

​

Factions which lost territories were usually requiring high tributes to establish peace or were declaring new wars while already being in one. Weakened kingdoms are now not that aggressive.

​

Posted Jan 22, 2021, 12:19 PM UTC · edited

1114
Akasha1885•

because my kingdom has only one clan, which has only two parties (my party and a companion party)?

It's this one.I had the same issue with the Dragon Banner active.
Until I recruited some lords from my enemy. (you can raise rep well if you beat them and release them a lot) In fact taking Prisoners isn't worth it, except the Leader of the clan faction/the leader of the main clans army. Since good rep is worth so much.

5
nikocompOP•

Thanks, this seems to be the case, I then persuaded Calatild's dey Arromanc (T6 clan with lots of members) with overstocked loot and vola! the tribue is now down to 500ish

Still does dragon banner make any difference?

1
Akasha1885•

I don't think it does, it just triggers the main-questline.
Which can be annoying or useful.

1
sedeslavSouthern Empire•

just administrative expenses! don't worry! :D

2
nikocompOP•

If that's Rhagaea I can swallow it, but, but this is DERTHERT!

2
Ecl1ps3_O•

The MOST broken thing about the game, for me. When this is fixed and you can make companions lords, I’ll play again. (

2
nikocompOP•

e1.5.7 have got better, but TW may still tweak it a bit. I am ok with war and understand medieval warfares involve lots of levys but slaughtering never-ending hordes of recruits and T2 troops, who were just some poor lads like you (probably) and me, makes me sad...

2
RedBeardV77•

From what I have seen when playing this happens when you are the one that requests for a truce. The quicker you request the truce after the war starts the higher the tribute will be which may have a calculation based on how much land they still have. More than likely this is from the changes they made to prevent faction snowballing but makes the diplomacy less intuitive.

1
nikocompOP•

Ohhhh I see, but historically grinding is a bad choice if there are other ways to end the war... I hope when snowballing is addressed, TW can make a sensible diplomacy system.

1
Universal885•

Im pretty sure if you take land and then make peace you have to pay tribute for the land you took, probably to try and balance things out but idk.

1
nikocompOP•

That's sad, my meta-strategy revolves around sieges (because I cannot help to cheese the sieges), I hope there is an option to sack a settlement...

1
Jorlaan•

If you talk to a noble/merc of the nation you are at war with you can negotiate peace for straight cash/trade with no tribute.

1
nikocompOP•

yes I can bribe some lord for peace, the price varies a bit around 200k ~ 300k, but that's overpriced for a crushed faction lol and I only have a bit more than 300k...

if you are curious why I only have 300k... since e1.5.7 money somehow becomes tight and I use mods to dramatically reduce the item prices (excl. horses and goods) so I don't earn much from the loot.

1
BlueMachinations•

Yeah, super annoying when you're smashing a kingdom in a war but they're like "nah gimme 2k daily, fucker"

1