Isn't Anarchism incompatible with collective action? (e.g. climate change)

To my understanding, Anarchism prides itself on voluntary, non hierarchical, and democratic relationships. I have two questions that flow directly from this

  1. how does anarchy deal with the problem of tyranny of the majority? If out of 100 people in voluntary organization, 51 vote one way and 49 vote another, what happens to the will of the 49 who lost? Do they just leave and form another org? Would this not ultimately lead to a purely individualist society in practice, as envisioned by American ancap-libertarians?

  2. How are solutions to large scale collective problems handled? For example, with climate change, anyone emitting carbon into the atmospheric commons contributes to the problem. But what if there is a democratic organization of only 70% of the population who is willing to stop, how do you deal with the 30% that isn't WITHOUT resorting to coercion or nondemocratic means?

Posted Jan 22, 2021, 8:42 PM UTC

45
humanispherian•

Large-scale ecological problems are arguably very much the result of individuals, nations and companies feeling that they have "rights" to exclusive control and use of resources, with very little demand that they be responsible for anything but the most immediate consequences of their actions. In a genuinely non-governmental society, there are none of these alleged "rights" — nor is there any majority-rule democracy. Under those circumstances, the faction who wants to continue to act in ways that jeopardize the welfare of others on a planetary scale don't have the protections that they do under capitalist and governmentalist systems. And they just appear as attackers, who may expect to be resisted by people engaging in individual or collective acts of self-defense.

17
DecoDecoMan•

Why are these protections and rights so powerful? How are they maintained to the solidity that they have now?

1
Cyanovarr•

I don't think that most anarchists care for democracy, maybe with the exception of specific things. Consensus is usually preferred.

10
subsidiarity•

Consensus just transfers power from the group to who ever controls what is voted on.

Do we have consensus that we will not kill Jim? That measure did not pass. Sorry Jim.

-9
post-queer•

Democracy isn't anarchy and climate change sounds like the result of large scale collective action. Maybe working on smaller, more human scales wouldn't create the sorts of problems that are unsolvable.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1