Valeria Card Kingdoms expansions

Question

We were wondering about the expansions for V:CK because on BGG it can be seen that there are a lot of expansions, both small packs and bigger box, and we're losing overview of what it all does.

  1. Which of the expansions, both big and small, do you consider essential of must-have in order to improve upon the base game?
  2. Which non-essential expansions are still good/fun to get? Do any of them add take-that mechanisms?
  3. Which expansions are to be avoided?
  4. Can you play V:CK with all expansions combined or do you need to pick and choose somehow? A max amount of monsters/citizens? Like in Dominion where you pick 10 kingdom cards even if you have many more from expansions.

Thanks for your ideas.

Posted Jan 27, 2021, 10:23 AM UTC

37
KDBA•

03: Agents and 05: Monster Reinforcements are great. Frost & Flame is a solid "more stuff" style expansion and worth grabbing at some point.

The rest of the minor expansions I can take or leave. Shadowvale is also a "more stuff" expansion but in the boring way (it was designed as standalone originally so it repeats a lot).

Crimson Seas kinda sucks. Adds complexity without reward (and isn't properly compatible with everything).

It all just goes in the box and you pull out the bits you want to use. You'll pull one 2-citzen, one 3-citzen, etc. from your various options. A little like Dominion in that regard, yes.

5
SpelunkzillaCatacombs•

I completely agree with this rundown. I was dissapointed with Crimson Seas, it really took away from the core experience. Monster Reinforcements is a must.

Valeria is one of my most played games, but I feel like it's at the absolute end of its design space. I know they recently announced a new expansion and I'm curious to see where they'll take it (but I probably won't pick it up).

2
SerTonyOPTerraforming Mars•

Thank you for your comment. Why do you think the monster reinforcements are a must? Can it be combined with F&F expansion?

1
Dr_CornbreadCthulhu Wars•

Not OP but I can answer. Yes it is compatible, and it adds more variety to the monsters with no added complexity.

3
ShpaanMage Knight•

Hey man, I asked the other poster first but he hasn't answered me yet so I though I'd ask you too. I ordered Valeria + Frost & Flame + Monster Reinforcements (it was expensive and almost sold out - I got the very last copies in my country) and I wanted to ask you if I should play the base game alone for a couple games first or incorporate the expansions straight away. What would you recommend me? Are they a straight improvement? Thanks a lot!

1
KDBA•

For those expansions, just put it all together.

1
SerTonyOPTerraforming Mars•

Thanks for your insight. I will look into the frost and flame expansion. What is your opinion on the other small pack expansions?

1
KDBA•

06: Relics is asymmetric player powers and it is utterly unbalanced. Fun to try out if you're bored with the game as a whole maybe but not worth using for me.

01: King's Guard and 02: Undead Samurai are... fine, I guess? I have them in my event deck so occasionally they'll come up, but I never choose to use them and if I didn't have them I probably wouldn't notice.

04: Peasants & Knights is just a small-size "more stuff" expansion. I've never bothered to actually use it.

2
deathcurse1113•

I also second the Flames and Frost expansion being essential. The monsters just become too easy in the base game otherwise, because you can just load up on magic and do anything. Monster reinforcements pack also helps with the too easy monster problem.

I have similar comments as previous posters about Shadowvale and Crimson Seas. I own them because I'm a completionist though. Shadowvale does have some cool cards (Dragoon 9/10 is awesome) so it's not bad to pick up as a later expansion.

For the other small packs, I honestly don't use them that much. The Kingsguard and Undead Samurai have only been used once and that's because I seeded my event deck with them. The Relics deck might be interesting to shake up the start, but it's always hard when some of them are better than others or force you into a certain type of play so I don't like them as much. Agents are pretty cool for larger player counts because then your excess resources can do something interesting, but they do add yet another thing to do into the game which isn't essential.

I do recommend the upcoming Darksworn expansion if you like cooperative play. The current beta testing for it is really fun.

3
ShpaanMage Knight•

Hey man, I just ordered base Valeria + Flames&Frost and Monster Reinforcements pretty much thanks to your comment (also because it was the last copy for all of them).

Would you recommend me to first play the base game for a couple of games and only then add the expansions or do you think that they strictly improve the base game and should be used from the beginning even for new players? Thanks a lot!

1
deathcurse1113•

Late reply, so not sure if this is still applicable, haha.

I recommend throwing in Monster Reinforcements right away.

I would personally, if it is the first game for everyone, start with a couple of games using the base game only. The cards and interactions are simpler so it helps get you used to the rules. But after 1-2 games you can just add in Flames & Frost with no problems, it's not hard to integrate at all.

1