Is there a tool to work out how much of a realised trade was actually theta?

Hi gang

I want to analyse my realised trades, and see how much I actually benefitted from theta, as opposed to changes in vega and the underlying.

Is there some tool where you can spit the inputs in and it'll tell you how much was each greek for a realised trade?

I know of course that the greeks give you forward looking expectations but want to be analyse for realised trades, not at inception.

Thanks

Posted Jan 28, 2021, 6:12 PM UTC

34
Boretsboris•

Short answer … no.

Long answer …

The options pricing model is dynamic. Its variables and projections are interdependent and are always changing. The Greeks are essentially coordinate projections within the nonlinear, multidimensional pricing model of options. You can take the entry point and the exit point of your option trade, with all the variables required for the model to map the change of the option’s premium (C/P, K, S, r, t, σ). Then, you can calculate the change in the option’s premium caused by the change in each variable. To do that, you have to choose the order in which you track each variable’s effect on the option’s premium. Do you first account for the change in time, then for the change in the underlying, then for the change in IV, and then for the change in interest rates (if any)? Or do you first account for the change in the underlying, then for the change in time, then for the change in interest rates (if any), and then for the change in IV? Why does the sequence matter? Because a change in each variable changes the Greeks. An underlying move changes theta. Time changes gamma. Time also changes the delta of options that are not at the money. Accounting for time premium first will give you one result for theta decay. Accounting for time premium after accounting for premium change from the underlying move will give you another result for theta decay. How do you choose what to account for first? Everything is happening simultaneously. Underlying price moves over time. Thus, you are left with an impossible decision.

To add insult to injury, you’re dealing with a neat pricing model that does not accurately reflect the messy reality of the options market, where implied volatility (calculated from the market prices of options) is not uniform across strikes and expiration dates. The volatility surface of the option chain can slow down or speed up the decay projected by theta. The volatility surface can also steepen or dampen the effect of the underlying move projected by delta/gamma. The volatility surface itself can morph and change over time, assuming temporary distortions or long-term structural changes.

Thus, the only thing certain about an option is the inevitable worthlessness of its extrinsic value upon the option’s expiration. Everything else is theory and highly sophisticated guesswork.

If you were able to take your premium without getting burned by the liability you assumed with the option(s) you wrote, then you did something right … or perhaps you got lucky. You will never know for sure.

Stay exposed, and may the Greeks be with you.

5
pennyking91OP•

Thanks for the erudite response ! So the answer is basically short answer no, long answer...no

3
Buffscuttle•

So Im not super well versed in this, but to my understanding. Any money made on premium is essentially theta. The other greeks are just adding or subtracting the price of time. Higher volatility makes your time more expensive so iv rises and your theta/time value becomes more. Like I understand there are delta moves etc, but it is still time value you are always getting/selling with premium(your time just happened to become more expensive). As for underlying. just do (Current cost of share-price paid per share).

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
pennyking91OP•

I don't think this is right although no expert.

If you sell puts the day before earnings, and the stock moons and your option is at 80% of max gain the next day, that's just not theta. That's caused by a change in the delta. And vegagang strategies exist to profit from contractions and expansions in volatility right?!

1