Alpinist mag's Dark Machine review

http://www.alpinist.com/doc/web21w/ms-grivel-dark-machine-ice-tools

Glad it wasn't just me :-)

Between the wide tips and the tools' light weight—which puts less force behind every swing—the picks were prone to glancing off divots and grooves on scalloped vertical surfaces. I had better luck dropping my elbow to add a "daggering" motion to the bottom of my swing, but even with the modification, heroic, first-swing sticks were rare for this tool, even while climbing backcountry ice near Ouray, Colorado, in mild, 30-degree temperatures. It seems strange that such a lightweight tool would be so improved by the use of pick/head weights. It's unfortunate that the design doesn't offer the option to mount them. As it is, I would have gladly carried a few extra ounces to have a heftier head and a more forgiving swing.

Posted Jan 31, 2021, 11:57 AM UTC

912
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
atypic•

they are good aren't they? i have them on my tech matrix axes and they have some beef to them

2
gloridhel•

Pretty common complaint with these tools. I much prefer xdreams or nomics.

2
atypic•

Fair comments, except the offset handle "con".

FWIW, I have no problems with one-swing good sticks in great ice, but then I have been told that I "massacre" the ice. I.e. I hit hard. I suspect the tool suits my style of climbing well.

1
Chanchito171•

I added the micro hammer to mine, that seemed to add a bit of weight to the head and I'm getting the sticks I want with these. I'm a beginner however so take that tip with a grain of salt

1
atypic•

i've done the same! love my darkies.

1
Chanchito171•

Would you think the adze would be a good addition? I'm still chopping steps when I'm about to place a screw sometimes... Just don't know if it's long enough to use compared to the less curved shaft of the cobras I started with

1
atypic•

hm! I dunno, I generally haven't used adzes in a long time, but much respect to people who know how to use them. Chopping steps is probably really useful, though it does seem to have gone out of fashion for a bit.

But it will give you some additional weight in your swing, which is nice if you want it.

2
musur_p•

Yeah, I get the impression that these tools suit us "hard hitters" well

1
NOsquidOP•

I think you can make up for the weight and picks with precision and strength, neither of which I possess :-)

Where you climbing out of curiosity?

1
atypic•

Norway! A nice mix of coastal climate ice and then some dryer inland ice sometimes.

I'm not exactly gracious while climbing ice either! Bangs rocks together

2
musur_p•

Tools seem to be a very personal preference. I have a completely different experience from my Dark Machines, and really can't recognize the "cons" here (own Nomics and Cobras also). And never experienced the pommel hitting the ice thing, suspect it's very much related to swing/technique - heard ppl using Nomics complain of the same thing.

For climbing steel hard ice I might bring a heavier tool, but overall really happy with these tools.

1