Who/whom: can't determine subject/object in this sentence

quick grammar check

In sentences that feel like the objects are being split in two separate clauses, I'm not sure whether to use who or whom.

Ex:
The firm doesn't do business with those who have criminal records.
The firm doesn't do business with those whom have criminal records.

The first sounds correct, even though with whom feels more grammatically accurate, and the traditional he/him replacement doesn't work for me, here (they/them, in this case.)

"The firm doesn't do business with them" (whom)
but also, "They have criminal records." (who)

In the overall sentence structure, "the firm" is the subject, making this a whom situation, no? I'm confused.

Posted Feb 2, 2021, 6:27 AM UTC

168
poilsoup2•

The who/whom rule is done on a clause basis, not a sentence basis.

The firm doesn't do business with those [ _____ have criminal records].

So take out that whole clause and apply the who/whom rule:

______ have criminal records. -> they have...

so it would be who.

Another way to look at it, the whole clause [ ___ have criminal records] is the object, not just the ____ part, so ____ is not an object.

who is used for subjects, not subjects of the sentence, but for things/people that are doing actions in the sentence.

I gave money to whoever was at the cash register. Whoever, because the thing/person is doing something (being at the cash register.)

You gave it to whom? Whom because it is the sole object of 'gave it to'

30
spinalcloudOP•

This helps to clarify, thank you.

4
rocketman0739•

Another way to look at it, the whole clause [ ___ have criminal records] is the object, not just the ____ part, so ____ is not an object.

Considering a whole relative phrase as the object is a great technique for sentences with "whoever," but it's slightly off for this sentence. The object is "those who have criminal records," while the relative clause is just "who have criminal records." So that clause is part of the object, but it's not the entire object.

3
Karlnohat•

In sentences that feel like the objects are being split in two separate clauses, I'm not sure whether to use who or whom.

Ex:

  1. The firm doesn't do business with those who have criminal records.
  2. The firm doesn't do business with those whom have criminal records.

.

TLDR: Your 1st version with "who" is grammatical, while your 2nd version with "whom" is ungrammatical for today's standard English.

Actually, your example follows the typical (simple) pattern of a relative pronoun having an explicit antecedent, where "those" is the antecedent for the relative pronoun. And so, the relative pronoun ("who") has, at the most, merely the case requirement to match the case of its function within its relative clause.

For your specific example, the case requirement is that the relative pronoun have nominative case due to it being the explicit subject of the relative clause.

Consider:

  1. The firm doesn't do business with people [who(i) have criminal records].
  2. The firm doesn't do business with those people [who(i) have criminal records].
  3. The firm doesn't do business with those [who(i) have criminal records]. <-- same as the OP's 1st version
  4. The firm doesn't do business with them [who(i) have criminal records].

For all those above examples, there is an explicit antecedent for the relative pronoun. And that relative pronoun is the explicit subject of its relative clause. This means that the relative pronoun has nominative case, i.e. "who".

ADDED: Note that my examples have been oversimplified, w.r.t. the parsing markings. The relative clause modifies an antecedent noun or nominal, not a whole noun phrase that has an overt separate determiner (as in my #2 where the parse markings are misleading since the antecedent is part of a noun phrase with such a determiner, that is, the antecedent of #2 is merely the noun "people").

4
hypohelioplastic•

“Who” functions outside the main clause as the subject of the relative clause, “who have records,” so the main subject is irrelevant for this test. The test seems to yield different answers because in the first one, you are actually replacing the word “those,” which is what “who” is referring to, but the two words are serving separate grammatical functions in separate clauses. TLDR- it’s “who”

2
Smash_Factor•

I would just assume to use who.

But if I was unsure, I would rewrite the sentence to check.

"Those whom have criminal records can't do business with the firm."

"Those who have criminal records can't do business with the firm."

1
amorifera•

I'm not certain, but I think in this case it's referring to who has the criminal record. Thus, it would be "who".

0
[deleted]•

[removed]

-1