Started a Roth IRA yesterday and have put in my max $6k into it. What now?

Retirement

For more background, I am 23 years old and currently make $54,500. I have put in the maximum $6k into my Roth IRA for the 2020 year and am a bit lost on what to do now with it. Since it's only $6,000 I don't exactly have much capital to diversify into different things (or so I think).

What do you guys think is a good idea to put this first $6k into?

Also, since I'm pretty clueless on investing (but have been reading quite a bit on it the past month), I would really appreciate it if anybody can throw me some essential readings when it comes to Roth IRAs and what to invest in.

Posted Feb 2, 2021, 4:04 PM UTC

90127
BitterPillPusher2​•

Put it into a target retirement fund. Assuming you will retire in about 40 years, do a 2060 target retirement fund. The bots will automatically diversify it for you and automatically adjust it as you get older and closer to retirement.

If you have the money now, go ahead and throw in your $6000 contribution for 2021 now. That gives it almost a whole additional year of growth.

78
Werewolfdad​•

since I'm pretty clueless on investing

Buy a target date fund. Move to a 3 fund portfolio when you have more assets and more knowledge.

https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/commontopics

https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/index#wiki_investing

69
doobie3101​•

I'm personally against Target Date Funds for 3 reasons:

  1. Expense ratios are a tad too high. For reference, Fidelity's is 0.75%. Vanguard's is 0.15%. Not bad, but still more than most ETFs.
  2. Too conservative too early. For reference, Fidelity's 2060 Fund is 10% bonds. If you're 25 and retiring at 65, I think that's too much in bonds. If you subscribe to the rule of 120, it's 5% too much.
  3. It's set it and forget it, but it can be decently complicated if you try to analyze / track it. They~~'re typically~~ can be made up of a lot of funds.

It's not a terrible option, but managing a simple "3 Fund Portfolio" of ETFs / index funds is far better imo.

28
Varathien​•

For reference, Fidelity's is 0.75%

That's their actively-managed version. They have an index fund version that is 0.12%.

Too conservative too early. For reference, Fidelity's 2060 Fund is 10% bonds. If you're 25 and retiring at 65, I think that's too much in bonds.

This is kind of disputed, but there's one theory that having a small bond allocation may improve overall returns, because the regular rebalancing between stocks and bonds causes you to sell some stocks when they're at all time highs, and buy more stocks when the market is down.

23
doobie3101​•

That's their actively-managed version. They have an index fund version that is 0.12%.

Ah didn't catch that. But for those who catch the difference between Fidelity's "Freedom Fund" and "Freedom Index Fund," probably just better to make your own.

This is kind of disputed, but there's one theory that having a small bond allocation may improve overall returns, because the regular rebalancing between stocks and bonds causes you to sell some stocks when they're at all time highs, and buy more stocks when the market is down.

Ooh that's very interesting. Logic makes sense - may depend on how often it is re-balancing. May look into that.

6
sky_cinnamon​•

I'm in a very similar position to OP. Can you help me understand the difference between the actively-managed version and the index fund version? (I assume the actively-managed version has a human monitoring the composition of the fund, but does it actually outperform the index fund version?)

3
Varathien​•

There's zero evidence that active management RELIABLY outperforms index funds. There will be years where the active managers make good picks, but there will also be years where they make bad picks. In the long run, most active managers underperform index funds.

https://www.ft.com/content/7e4c0d91-8b6d-419b-9be3-80131d5cb462

The expense ratio, on the other hand, you can count on. One fund is charging you 0.75%, and the other is charging you 0.12%.

10
Onwisconsin42​•

Yes, active means humans are reviewing the portfolio and making adjustments based on their view of the market. As other poster says- they do not reliably outperform the market. I've read that only about 20% of actively managed funds outperform the market.

2
GarryInPlano​•

I would say just buy VOO . It has a 0.03% ER.... at 23, the target date funds have too much drag trying to allocate. For a retirement Nestegg some 42 years later, allocation should start around 10-5 years from planned retirement. Again... this info is for education purposes...

2
Varathien​•

Putting everything in the S&P 500 is based quite heavily in recency bias, though. The past decade has been AMAZING for large US corporations. But there have also been long periods of time when small caps outperformed large caps, or when international outperformed US.

Avoiding bonds completely is an aggressive but reasonable choice. I personally only have bonds in my HSA right now. My retirement accounts are all in stock funds.

Avoiding international diversification because the US has done really well recently... that seems like a huge mistake to me. The whole logic of index fund investing is to own everything. "Don't look for the needle in the haystack, just buy the haystack." Well, with the S&P 500, you only own half the haystack.

10
GarryInPlano​•
1
GarryInPlano​•

A side note... re-allocation by the professionals means more fees for them to take in.... what a good way to make more money... have all your clients to come in for re-allocation a couple of times a year...

1
Werewolfdad​•

It's not a terrible option, but managing a simple "3 Fund Portfolio" of ETFs / index funds is far better imo.

Oh, I agree, but TDF is perfect to start for someone who is "clueless".

Expense ratios are a tad too high. For reference, Fidelity's is 0.75%.

Eh, doesn't matter for a short period on a small investment.

Too conservative too early. For reference, Fidelity's 2060 Fund is 10% bonds. If you're 25 and retiring at 65, I think that's too much in bonds. If you subscribe to the rule of 120, it's 5% too much.

Agreed.

It's set it and forget it, but it can be decently complicated if you try to analyze / track it. They're typically made up of a lot of funds.

I'm not sure what you mean by this

8
doobie3101​•

Eh, doesn't matter for a short period on a small investment.

Short period assumes OP changes to 3 fund portfolio early on. But for $6k per year until retirement, that 0.75% adds up. Even if it's 0.5% too high (I think it's more), could be the difference between tens of thousands.

Personally, I find it easier to understand my portfolio allocation than to follow somebody else's changes. Vanguard's is simple, but Fidelity's Target Funds have ~30 funds that they actually track. The 50% domestic stock is made up of growth, large cap, blue chip, "opportunistic insights", "discovery," among plenty of others. Sure, it's mostly for people who never look at it, but it can get complicated if you ever do want to understand where you have money sitting.

1
Robotsaur​•

Expense ratio is 0.12% for Fidelity - you need to look at their Freedom Index Funds

5
GarryInPlano​•

Vanguard VOO ER is .03%

1
Onwisconsin42​•

Can you direct me to a source on how to select and implement a 3 fund portfolio?

1
SovietRusOP​•

That's exactly what I thought. You recommend I dump the whole 6k into the target date while I learn?

I am interested in individual stocks and have been doing research on a company, and purchased the stocks separate from my IRA.

7
justhere321​•

Individual stocks are always a gamble and IMO should only be done with money you plan to lose. Then any gains are just gravy. Target date is a great/easy way to start. Other than that a simple 3 fund portfolio has always served me well. With Vanguard I use VTSAX, VTIAX, and VBTLX.

41
SovietRusOP​•

Yeah I've been reading abotu the 3 fund portfolio, but was wondering if 6k is enough to diversify.

2
ArmadilloAl​•

The whole point of the target fund is that it combines your 6k with the funds of everyone else who bought the target fund and creates one giant diversified portfolio. You'll have a proportionally smaller amount of everything, naturally, but it'll be diversified just the same.

It's not really "a 6k portfolio" so much as "0.0001% of a $6 billion portfolio" (or whatever the actual number is).

24
MyDadIsTheMan​•

VTSAX, set it and forget it. Or for some more aggression, a small cap fund.

4
CoolNebraskaGal​•

It is, but realistically you will do just fine investing in a target retirement fund, or even just VTSAX (total US stock market fund) while you learn and decide exactly what you want. If you really just never want to think about it, target retirement funds are perfectly fine. Yes, they’re a bit more expensive, and maybe they’ll hold more bonds than make sense for you, but they really are perfectly fine. Whatever you choose, don’t stress over it too much. They’re all reasonably fine choices.

1
Lord0fHam​•

Individual stocks are not always a gamble and that attitude is very misguided. It’s very possible to pick solid companies with a good track record in different sectors to achieve diversification. You will not just randomly lose your money on companies like Apple, Walmart, etc. Any large cap etf is like 25% in the top 5-10 companies anyway so it’s really not that much different. Picking something like GME is not what I’m talking about.

-1
justhere321​•

If you’re new to investing and/or don’t want to spend a lot time then yes they are. You absolutely could lose your money on a big company like apple or Walmart. Do you think large companies never fail? You could build a balanced portfolio buying individual stocks but 90+% of people will do way better buying low cost mutual funds.

2
Werewolfdad​•

Yup

7
Alexhasskills​•

The target date fund is the safe, no hands approach that many, including myself, in this sub will recommend.

6
SovietRusOP​•

Yeah, until I get enough knowledge of investment opportunities I think I'll stick with the target fund or VTSAX.

3
arkie87​•

You should only invest in stocks for fun and never with serious amounts of money. No amount of research or stock acumen will let you beat the market on average. Your retirement/real investments should be in low expense ratio index funds. Target date funds is an easy way to do that. Getting the average market return should be your goal.

1
vaultboy1​•

Why do you only recommend moving to a 3 fund portfolio when you have more assets and knowledge?

3
Werewolfdad​•

So you don’t Bork it up

9
jillanco​•

VTSAX

21
sfwmador​•

A broad index mutual fund such as a Total Stock Market fund.

15
Pillow_Stalk1​•

Skimming these comments I’m surprised no ones told you yet: you can have $12,000 in your IRA right now if you have the funds. You just contributed for 2020, now contribute for 2021, time in the market beats timing the market.

As far as where to put it, I agree with previous posters that said target date retirement funds while you learn about investing.

I don’t have any readings off the top of my head, but look into the Money Guy show YouTube channel, I learned an insane amount about investing from there.

13
SovietRusOP​•

Oh yeah I know, I just need to keep some cash on hand for a while due to life stuff, but I definitely will max out for 2021.

2
blackswansus​•

100% Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund (ETF or mutual fund).

No bonds, no foreign stock funds.

USA is the place to be.... repeat each year and enjoy a big fat account when you retire.

13
PM_ME_YOUR_MECH​•

Question -- I see some people recommending a target date fund. What's the benefit of doing a target date fund vs. total market index fund like VTSAX? Or should you do both?

6
ZeldaGamer1​•

Target date fund should have exposure to bonds and international stocks while VTSAX is only exposed to the US stock market. There are periods where foreign stocks outperform US stocks so it is helpful to have exposure to them. Bonds are supposed to be for capital preservation (although with how low rates have been, it’s probably a good idea for investors under 30 to stick to stocks only).

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
loop--de--loop​•

The target date should rebalance as you approach the end date. So “safer” investments when you are ready to cash out.

3
roomnoises​•

Are you familiar with the concept of a three fund portfolio? A target date fund is similar to that and becomes more conservative as the date approaches.

A total US market index fund would be one of the three funds, with the other two being international market and bonds.

2
EqualSein​•

The biggest risk to investment is behavioral. There will almost certainly come a time when stocks will be down 30%+ for years like 2008 and there will be a temptation to sell near the bottom as you market time. By sticking with a target date fund you avoid some of the market downside in exchange for some of the market upside. You also don't have to think about rebalancing or getting less risky as you approach retirement since the fund does it for you. Historically bonds have done ok and even outperformed stocks in many years, it's just hard to see that when stocks have done so well recently.

1
freddykruegerjazzhan​•

In my opinion global index mutual fund is fine.

That’s what I’d do. Or an Etf. Probably minimum difference for $6k.

Personally I wouldn’t go into individual stocks without enough money to diversify, or without a portfolio of diversified funds already.

3
SovietRusOP​•

Thanks for that, I was thinking to put a bit into an ETF when I put in the next 6K. I don't mind a bit of risk since I'm young.

2
freddykruegerjazzhan​•

Etf doesn’t have to be too risky. You can buy etfs of Bond portfolios.

What I would look up are global index etfs, which should give you good diversification with just one fund. There’s probably a few, so I’d research fees and performance and pick one.

If you want to be really safe you can put some proportion into a bond fund as well. Again research performance & fees. I do 90% equity, 10% bonds - will increase the bonds as I get older.

2
SovietRusOP​•

I've been seeing that last part a lot, if you don't mind me asking another question, why increase bonds as you get older? Is this for risk management since you're nearing retirement age?

1
freddykruegerjazzhan​•

Yep that’s the idea!

1
travelinman67​•

I’m just going to repeat what I’ve seen, go with a Target Date Index Fund like VTTSX (the Vanguard 2060 fund). We’re about the same age and that’s basically the only thing I invest in.

3
Ulticats​•

I am 24 and I personally am in retirement funds but I also look at more aggressive growth ETFs and stocks just given the time I have till retirement. I’m in things like XLK, VOO, a little in VNQ/VNQI, AAPL (only on dips) and some other tech/healthcare ETFs. I also have some in things like VFF, OPTT, since they are good future technologies but I’d only put what I’m willing to lose. Just make sure you focus on low cost funds. I do manage it pretty actively though and invest regularly and allocate to the funds/stocks that had pulled back recently. Assuming you have emergency savings, I’d go Roth and then 401k if that’s an option. I max out both and then whatever is left I split between saving for house downpayment and individual taxable brokerage (AGI is ~80k)

3
SovietRusOP​•

Yeah I'm looking to get a 403b soon and invest into that. I'm in a decent position where I have no debts to cover and I live at home (and will receive an inheritance in which I can use to get a house for me and my family).

You're investing in those individual stocks through the funds in your IRA right?

1
Ulticats​•

Nice! I do sometimes invest in those individual higher risk/reward in my Roth but for the most part, I keep VOO, VNQ, VNQI, XLK, VUG types. It’s more than the recommended 3 fund style but I am pretty active in it. I invest it once a month (dollar cost averaging) and will typically go heaviest in VOO, and then see which other ones are ‘on sale’ and prioritize those. For example, when tech is pulling back, I’ll go heavier in XLK. If overall market is hit, go heavy on VOO. If RE is down, go a little more on VNQ, etc. Since the gains aren’t taxed, I do sometimes use it for a play on those higher reward plays but often times I do that in my taxable account (just for my own discipline to make sure I don’t mess around too much in Roth lol). Let me know if you have any specific questions and I can try to answer :). I’m also obviously pretty new since I only started working full time 3 years ago but always down to discuss!

1
SovietRusOP​•

Yeah so one question I got (which seems pretty obvious but i'm new to this type of stuff):

When you buy VOO/VNQ/VNQI/etc do you sell those when the price gets high enough to where you want to sell or do you just hold on to those?

1
Ulticats​•

No, with those I don’t plan to sell those at all really until I retire. Those are long term holds and it’s almost always best to not try and time the market like that. Other riskier plays I’ll be watching closely and with those I buy and sell, but with those long term holds, I’d avoid touching it unless it’s some actual emergency. It’s all to build long term wealth so just keep that in mind. Looking for long term value that can pay back in dividends, stable growth, etc.

1
chemgrad123​•

Lots of good suggestions here. I would suggest reading "A Random Walk Down Wall Street" by Burton G. Malkiel. This will give you a good idea of not only what to do now, but also in the future as you continue to build your investments.

3
Eddie_Mush​•

What brokerage? I have vanguard for my ROTH and I have it split in VTSAX and VFIAX. These are total stock market and S&P index funds so I’d do something similar to that.

2
SovietRusOP​•

Vanguard.

2
Eddie_Mush​•

Ok, so yeah. I have VTSAX and VFIAX for my ROTH. I also have like a measly $1K in a target retirement fund 2065 but majority $ is the formers listed.

1
HoneyBadger552​•

Vti, vo, vb, vpu, vglt To get you started. 3 books to read: boggleheads guide to investing, the coffeehouse investor, liars poker.

2
superherotony2099​•

If you are very new to investing, I would take this very simple advice:

Purchase one share of VOO each month. VOO is an index tracker which will match the returns of the S&P, and it has a very low expense ratio.

You will find that as soon as you start investing into anything, your mind and behavior will change. You should get in slowly and see how it feels. By starting out with just one share a month, it will be like getting into a cold pool one step at a time. You will acclimate.

Regardless of what anyone says, no one knows where different stocks or funds will go in the future - the safest bet is to start with a broad index fund like VOO so that you match the S&P. The S&P is diversified and generally beats 90% of actively managed funds. Other S&P index trackers mentioned on this forum are also good, I'd say the difference is negligible.

A huge part of investing is being comfortable with your investments and accepting them for the long term. Best of luck.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Necrosis_KoC​•

I personally put a third of mine into each of a NASDAQ based index fund, the S&P 500, and a science and tech based fund each year and it's worked pretty well up to this point. I plan on putting some into a more stable money market type fund moving forward as well to even out fluctuations in the others.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1