Muzzle at Dog Parks?

I got my shepherd mix when she was 10 months old from the shelter. I've had her for 3 years now. She was very leash reactive when I first got her (mostly a frustrated greeter) but has always been good off leash, at dog parks and doggy daycare.

I've worked on her leash reactivity and she is MUCH better now, and she still thrives at doggy daycare. But this pandemic has wreaked havoc on her ability to play at dog parks. She seems to have gotten very protective of me so that if another dog comes anywhere near me, she goes after it.

My question is - would a muzzle be appropriate so that I can still take her to the dog park, without worrying she might hurt another dog? And hopefully reacclimate her to the dog park environment. Or would this do more harm than good?

Posted Feb 5, 2021, 3:39 PM UTC

216
littleredtoddJ (stranger danger & dog reactivity)•

If you have good reason to think your dog might act aggressively at the dog park, I would not bring her, muzzle or no muzzle. If your dog ended up trying to attack another dog, even with a muzzle on, it could still be traumatizing to that other dog.

I know it's not an easy or even necessarily fair situation.

11
designgoddess•

If your dog needs a muzzle at a dog park, rethink going to a dog park. I’m not a fan of them for a variety of reasons but one is a dog can get over stimulated and not have a good place/way to self isolate. Also, behavior developed at a dog park can be transferred to daycare.

6
ButterNood•

Muzzles are a great tool, but I’d be looking at the root of the problem, not a bandage for it.

Chances are the dog parks themselves have caused this issue.

Get a balanced trainer to help you.

5
RetiariusOP•

I did just hire a trainer, we have our first session coming up so hopefully that will help as well. It's just odd, she never had issues at the dog park until we simply didn't go for about 4 months when they were shut down during the pandemic. Now that they're opening up again, she's picked up this odd protective behavior. I'm hoping the trainer will have ideas on how to correct it as well!

2
tulafae•

I have had this issue too

1
designgoddess•

What kind of trainer? This is a behavior issue, not a training issue.

0
ButterNood•

Dog trainers don’t just teach tricks. They help solve behavioural issues.

0
designgoddess•

Trainers are not behaviorists.

0
GrandmaCereal•

Muzzles can be great training tools! I would recommend a Baskerville or basket muzzle, so you can still treat her, she can get water, etc.

4
RetiariusOP•

Thank you! I will look into those!

0
Action_Lasagna•

A Baskerville is not biteproof just an FYI

1
mrrustypupVal (dog reactive)•

You run the risk of your dog not being able to defend herself.

Imagine this: you get jittery around a coworker you don’t like. They get close to you and bother you and just in general you don’t like them. Instead of your boss scheduling you two on different shifts, your boss simply handcuffs you and tells you to deal with it.

Not the right approach. Now when that coworker gets in your space you can’t push them away or defend yourself.

I would highly suggest against going in dog parks. That isn’t to say you can’t start counter conditioning outside the park. You can go to the parking lot and do training on a leash outside the fence. Get progressively closer. Let her have interactions through the fence possibly if it’s safe.

But just putting a muzzle on your dog and putting them in the dog park is going to disadvantage your dog immediately and likely cause more harm than good. Dogs that need muzzles shouldn’t be in dog parks. In fact, my personal opinion is that most owners aren’t responsible enough to allow their dog in a dog park. But that’s just me.

3
Kitchu22•

Your dog is telling you that the dog park is a bit overwhelming at the moment. As opposed to muzzling (which only stops her from biting, but not from causing a dog fight if she decides to aggressively react to the wrong dog), I would be cutting the dog park for now and engaging with a trainer to very slowly address the resource guarding behaviour she’s engaging in.

3
Roadgoddess•

I had a muzzled dog, off leash attack me a month ago and although I was happy he was muzzled, i was upset the owner had them running free. I think if your dog is that sever, it probably not the best to have them at the park right now.

3
simplycinci•

If a dog needs a muzzle at a dog park, then that dog probably shouldn’t be at said park.

2
greyseas123•

I’m just curious if you’re planning to let her off leash or just take her to the park to do care free sniffing and leash greetings. If you planned to let her off leash to free play, what is your park like? Do you know most of the dogs there? How many dogs are usually there? Definitely ask your trainer but I would be cautious about free playing with new dog friends in a muzzle.

1