FCon Consolidated Stress Track House Rule
I'm thinking of using FCon with a single consolidated Stress track for my next game. Rather than using the higher of Will or Physique to add stress boxes, I was thinking of the following as a house rule:
Characters have a single track of 6 1-hit Stress boxes. A character can use a maximum of 3 Stress boxes against a single attack. Having a higher Physique/Will increases the number of boxes you can use per hit for physical/mental attacks respectively (the table on P12 of FCon reflecting the max number of Stress boxes than can be used per hit, rather than total Stress boxes).
For example, a character with Physique 1 / Will 0 has 6 Stress boxes, and can use a maximum of 4 Stress boxes against a single physical attack but only 3 Stress boxes against a single mental attack. A character with Physique 1 / Will 4 can use a maximum of 4 Stress boxes against a single physical attack but all 6 against a single mental attack.
This has the benefit of allowing both Physique and Will to contribute, differentiates the kind of attack without requiring two stress tracks, and has the potential of making Consequences come into play more often as characters won't necessarily be able to use all their Stress to absorb a hit, giving it a more "Core" feel.
Posted Feb 7, 2021, 12:16 AM UTC
There is already the combined track optional rule. The issue I see to this is that players no matter what version always decided how to attribute stress based in their available stress boxes and consequences that are available.
If a player could have absorbed the stress damage all in stress points but because of your rule you are forcing a consequences you could lead to situation where due to additional rule you are creating a way for the player to be taken out as they are unable to absorb the stress. That could lead to resentment from players.
I know there's already a combined track optional rule. This house rule uses the unified track idea from FCon, with a different approach that allows both Physique and Will to affect the track, rather than just the higher of the two - and it also differentiates between the kind of hit the character is taking or delivering.
Quite a few people on this subreddit have commented that the FCon 1-point Stress tracks feel more like hit points, as there's less of an incentive to spend Fate Points to Invoke Aspects or take Consequences until all Stress boxes are checked off. This is especially the case when using a unified track that can go up to 9 Stress boxes.
I mean, this may not be an issue in your games, but it's something others have brought up when saying why they prefer the way Core handles Stress.
Quite honestly, as far as "leading to resentment from players" goes, this house rule doesn't change things from the way things work with separate Stress tracks in FCon, as far as the maximum Stress one can take in a single hit:
Under separate Stress tracks, a character with Physique +1 will have 4 Physical Stress boxes, which they could use on a single hit (and have none left). With this house rule, they'd have 6 Stress Boxes (using FCon's base for a unified Stress track) and could use up to 4 Stress boxes on a single physical hit (and still have 2 left). Granted, using FCon's unified Stress track, the same character would have 7 Stress boxes and could use them all on any hit, physical or otherwise. But, also consider that, in Core, the most Stress any character can take in a single hit without resorting to Invoking Aspects or taking Consequences is 4.
If the issue is that the number of Stress boxes being lower than the unified track rules in FCon seems unfair, having both Physique and Will adding Stress boxes probably wouldn't unbalance the game (although smaller hits would drag an encounter out). In this case, a +4 Physique/+4 Will character would then have 12 Stress boxes (6 base, +3 for Physique, +3 for Will), but could only use up to 6 of them on a single hit.