Question about Mushoku Tensei for LN/WN Readers (Spoilers)

SpoilerQuestion

So I started watching the anime of Mushoku Tensei and spoiled myself a bit about the relationships of the MC while browsing the wiki. Basically I read that Rudy gets together with Roxy, Sylphy and Eris and they all become his wives later in the novels. Personally I really dislike Polygamy and would’ve much prefered if he only gets together with one girl, not all three. So my question is: Is it explained/justified in a satisfying way why he gets married to all three instead of choosing one? Or is it simply going the harem route to make all the shippers happy? Also how does it happen exactly? I don’t mind spoilers.

Posted Feb 7, 2021, 5:23 PM UTC

027
m_leandro•

Yep, all justifiable and I hope the anime show the motives and all

8
IXajllOP•

Could you please tell me the reasons if you don’t mind? I don’t mind Spoilers.

1
restiaest•

Huge Spoiler alert:

Sylphy: After Eris “left”Rudy, he got so traumatised and got diagnosed with an illness(ED), Rudy got together with Sylphy after discovering his feelings for her. Note that this is when Rudy thought he was abandoned by Eris (but actually not)

Roxy: both of em are always in good relationship, Roxy started having feelings for Rudy when he saved her from danger. when Rudy is depressed over “someone’s” <—(huge spoiler) death, Roxy is the one that got him out. People around him knew him as a strong guy and would be able to move on. However Roxy knowing him since young, she knew he always had problem opening up his world and moving on. As for how Roxy got him to move on, they did it. yup, that. This happened when Sylphy is not with him, and Rudy is kinda throwing himself away. TLDR: Roxy saved him, and Rudy not wanted to let her down after “that” and knowing that he himself have feelings for her since young, they got together and seemed permission from Sylphy.

Eris: She’s the first person that did it with Rudy, after which she left him to grow stronger in order to protect him after a huge incident where he almost lost his life. Rudy thought Eris abandoned him which is why he ended up with Sylphy, which escalated to Roxy later on. After resolving some misunderstandings, they got together.

tldr: Rudy is faithful and responsible for his action.

8
IXajllOP•

Thanks for elaborating. Maybe I misunderstood something but the way I got it is just that you explained that all the girls seem to love him and he loves the girls. But why do they seem to be okay that Rudy is married to them all? Like do they just not give a fuck that Rudy has 2 other lovers besides themselves? Is it just explained like „well it’s a medieval fantasy world where it is normal for a dude two have multiple wives“?

2
bonesandbillyclubs•

Because polygamy really isn't a big deal jn that world, outside of a certain religion. His dad had two wives too. The reason zenith got so upset is she follows that religion. And he does love them all and they all love him. Hell, sylphy and roxy told him to marry eris, to his face.

2
restiaest•

firstly, Rudy is someone that reincarnated from modern world, so he has a mind conflict regarding polygamy. But looking Paul as an example, Rudy realised that as long as he love em all.

secondly, the girls just find their own acceptance along the way, like: this is how Rudy is, or how they accepted that they are all loved by Rudy, and not being thrown aside by Rudy the moment he found his “new” love.

ED: just to add on, Rudy observed how Zenith and Lilia interacted with one another despite Lilia being the mistress. Zenith is seen to be living in happiness and seems to get along with Lilia to the extent that she called her family.

1
akaicewolf•

It’s basically what you said. The justifications is that Rudy is a horny guy so of course he can’t keep it in his pants that’s why all the wives are okay with it.

And yes they kind of don’t value themselves. Rudy cheats on a pregnant wife and she doesn’t mind because Rudy is Rudy. The series is a 13 year olds wet dreams come true

1
m_leandro•

This! I couldn't have put it better myself

1
iammobed•

can you please take time and answer my post here please about zenith https://www.reddit.com/r/mushokutensei/comments/lf188l/for_mangaln_reader_why_didnt_they_save_zenith/

1
akaicewolf•

Rudy is not faithful. He cheated on Sylph with Roxy. He also offered Roxy to basically bang each other until he gets back home to Sylph. This was after he married Sylph and told her he would be faithful.

1
Timmaaah85•

To add to what has already been said, you'd be hard pressed to find a better written harem in LNs. At the very least, I have yet to see one.

It feels more organic than any of the others, and it all happens over a long period of time. There is something like 8 volumes between him marring Sylphy and Eris. The process of them all feels organic and doesn't feel forced in there.

The biggest thing is that the girls don't feel like cardboard cutouts like most in harems do. They have their own dreams and desires, both with and without Rudy, and they feel more real than most harem characters.

The other thing to remember is that most of this is coming from the WN, that used a lot of MTL. Things maybe different or better explained in the official release.

3
IXajllOP•

Thanks for your response. To me it’s just very hard to believe that girls (anime or not) would just be okay that their lover/boyfriend/husband was having other girls on the side. I guess that comes from the fact that I despise polygamy in general and a lot of people seem to not mind it all which is kinda weird to me. Also what does MTL mean?

2
Timmaaah85•

Yeah, that's fair enough. I also know that I wouldn't be ok with sharing someone I loved with someone else. But different people have different mindsets. There are a lot of people out there that are in open relationships or part of swinger groups, so it's not just in fantasy where you see this kinda thing, just by law you can't marry more than one person in most countries.

It's been probably 3-4 years since I read past what is currently officially out (I'm reading again with the official releases) but I'm pretty sure that Sylphy had to deal with her jealousy as she was the original wife, and it was the others that were joining later on. The other 2 knew they were getting in to someone that was already married so knew from the start that they wouldn't have his full attention all of the time. The author also does spend time going over the dynamics of the relationships after they all get together.

To be fair, there is a bit of wish fulfilment having all 3 of them with him, but a lot of that is also because the female characters were fleshed out well enough that I wanted them to be with the person that they loved. It didn't feel like the author was just adding them for the sake of adding them like in The Master of Ragnarok.

MTL is machine translation. It's when they use something like google translated and then just touch it up. Basically it's not the best translation out there. You'll get the basics of what happens, but nuance is lost and lots of errors are possible.

1
IXajllOP•

Thanks, those are some interesting points actually.

1
iammobed•

can you please take time and answer my post here please about zenith https://www.reddit.com/r/mushokutensei/comments/lf188l/for_mangaln_reader_why_didnt_they_save_zenith/

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1