Adding privacy is never a good idea.

Lot of people say that, Nano doesn't have a privacy and it is a downside and things like that. My opinion is if Nano adds privacy, it's future will be finished because, government and cash are not good friends. And they most probably ban privacy currencies as it can create tax problems in the future and because nobody will disclose their cash balance if government has no way to find it. That obviously no government will want.

Posted Feb 12, 2021, 11:36 AM UTC

79
Baciwop•

Strong disagree. Nobody wants their account balance broadcasted

13
quokkafury•

You can have multiple accounts. You can use third party services to make them hard to trace (tipbot/binance/etc). You can use change addresses sending 3 amounts to different unused addresses with 1 being the person you are transacting with. No need for the blockchain as a whole to be private.

3
-UnlearnerOP•

In case of privacy coins people don't know the balance of a particular person or account but they can always assume some amount (which is more or less same as knowing exect amount). But governments won't be happy in this case. And they still have a gun I must say. Because of that gun few exchanges recently has delisted privacy coins like monero, dash and few others.

1
JusticeLoveMercy•

Actually some people do.

1

Already Indian government has started to ban private cryptocurrency

4
zergtoshi⋰·⋰ Take your funds off exchanges ⋰·⋰•

Privacy is a double-edged sword. It can have drawbacks depending on how oppressive governments are.

Saying privacy is never a good idea is plain nonsense.

Can you imagine why legions of people started switching from Whatsapp to Signal?
Having access to privacy when needed is important.

1
Teebabs•

Protocol level privacy is not possible. People will use mixers or exchanges

Its a done topic. People who need privacy at protocol level should go use a privacy coin

1
codingbrian•

Yup. This.

Colin has mentioned multiple times that privacy couldn't be added without there being an unacceptable sacrifice (e.g., speed, efficiency, etc.)

The fact is, that based on the software architecture of Nano, privacy isn't going to be added at the base layer.

I've tried to think of second layer solutions, but haven't come up with anything that I think is decentralized enough.

2
eosmcdee•

its a two edges sword

1