[ANALYSIS] Wilbur said he wanted song analyses linking Eight to Alivebur. I will deliver.
This post was initially composed for my tumblr general-light, a week ago. But, Wilbur said he likes stuff like that, so I'm gonna post it here (where he might see it?). I like to consider myself an expert Alivebur analyser as the person who has composed and cited 95% of his Dream SMP Wiki page, so here are my two cents on it.
I’m analysing the FULL song and its relation to Wilbur’s character - because some of it directly proves the things I’ve been saying for months!
/DSMP and /rp for all that follows.
I remember the minute
It was like a switch was flipped
I was just a kid who grew up strong enough
To pick this armor up
And suddenly it fit
God, that was so long ago, long ago, long ago
I was little, I was weak and perfectly naive
And I grew up too quick
Now - I take these lines as meaning pre-Revolution Wilbur. I have always personified General Wilbur, leader of the Revolutionary Army, not as a man built of war - but a man who finds himself in it anyway. And I imagine, the switch is Dream’s declaration of war.
It feels long ago - really, it hasn’t been that long, but Wilbur was naïve then, too cocky in the face of Dream, and far too trusting. He let Eret in despite his readiness to defect at all, and Spiralbur - who this song would be in POV of - finally recognises that General Soot was not the pinnacle of the revolution he was made out to be.
Actually, if anything, he was just as naïve and immature as the rest of his men. But he “grew up too quick”. He took the role of a leader because he had to. Everybody looked to him. Who was he to suddenly turn them down?
Now you won't see all that I have to lose
And all I've lost in the fight to protect it
I won't let you in, I swore never again
I can't afford, no, I refuse to be rejected
This is a simple read: it’s Wilbur’s stance on betrayal. He was betrayed three times in canon from his perspective - once from Eret, once from Schlatt (because don’t forget, Wilbur did trust him enough to endorse his party), and once from Fundy (which may not have been legitimate, but Wilbur did not know that).
So, he withdraws. This is best fit for his character post-Eret, because we now know his Presidential character withdrew, too - remember his line about crying into a pillow, whenever he wasn’t behind a podium? Nobody else knew that. Wilbur refused to let anybody else in.
He has been rejected before - his hand of hospitality has been abused. Wilbur is no longer an open book.
I want to break these bones 'til they're better
I want to break them right and feel alive
You were wrong, you were wrong, you were wrong
My healing needed more than time
This is bad coping mechanisms: the verse! Wilbur sought salvation in destruction. He would isolate himself, starve himself, and deprive himself of sleep during his exile - and if you think I’m head-canoning that up, think again! All three of those things are canon fact.
He eventually devolves to the point where he wants to kill to feel right again. I presume he thought he wanted to kill Schlatt, but it would become clear he really wanted to kill himself and L’Manberg. It’s moreso metaphorical then - breaking his tyranny-infested nation in order to right his wrongs.
Everybody else seemed to hope he would better with time, I think. Give him space, let him breathe - that pattern is evident in Tommy and Quackity backing off when they encountered him in the button room.
They were wrong, of course. Wilbur needed active intervention. God, he needed therapy. Active therapy. If anything, time in his brain ruined him more.
When I see fragile things, helpless things, broken things
I see the familiar
I was little, I was weak, I was perfect, too
Now I'm a broken mirror
I’d like to kiss this line, because it helps prove something I have been screaming for ages. Wilbur saw himself in L’Manberg. Wilbur attached his worth to L’Manberg.
When L’Manberg was small and weak, but perfect - Wilbur coped better! It had worth, so he had worth. Then, Schlatt broke it, and it became bastardised, and Wilbur saw himself in that reflection.
L’Manberg was breaking, and so was he. The symphony reflects its composer. Now, in his spiral, he is aptly described as the broken mirror - a fractured image of the freedom he once wanted to reflect.
I'm standing guard, I'm falling apart
And all I want is to trust you
Show me how to lay my sword down
For long enough to let you through
This line for Wilbur! Mwah! This accents a scene in canon so brilliantly! Not many folks cite this as evidence, but when Tommy and Quackity propose their peaceful plan to Wilbur in hopes of talking him down - he willingly listens.
Wilbur didn’t particularly want to fall apart. Who would? He wanted to believe in Tommy’s hope, and Quackity’s intentions. It’s clear in the way he talks - go listen to a VOD! It’s the October 17th Stream! Wilbur held off his entire last-resort plan for them! That, I think, was his last attempt at trust.
Of course, it failed. When it failed, Wilbur became a lost cause, because the Dream deal came into play. But before then - man, if Wilbur didn’t give a shit, why did he ever listen to them?
Here I am, pry me open
What do you want to know?
I'm just a kid who grew up scared enough
To hold the door shut
And bury my innocence
But here's a map, here's a shovel
Here's my Achilles' heel
This one’s an easy explanation.
Wilbur was always quite open in his spiral. He was always quite clear that he was falling apart. Hell, even down to his finale stream - wasn’t he constantly making it very clear he was the traitor?
President Wilbur buried his emotions for the nation. Spiral Wilbur was tired of keeping them hidden.
I'm all in, palms out
I'm at your mercy now and I'm ready to begin
I am strong, I am strong, I am strong enough to let you in
Wilbur at Dream. The last person he “trusted” enough to work with. His final gambit.
“Let me be your vassal,” Wilbur said. He knew Dream was using him. He didn’t care enough to counter it. It was his last display of strength - to detonate everything he knew - and he needed Dream’s mercy to accomplish it.
All in.
I'ma shake the ground with all my might
And I will pull my whole heart up to the surface
For the innocent, for the vulnerable
And I'll show up on the front lines with a purpose
This is very clearly button-room final-explosion toned. He will shake the ground, quite literally! Those explosions mark Wilbur finally being loud about his descent - remember how he screams in the wake of the sixteenth’s detonation?
Wilbur was at his most raw on that day, in that button room - both when he was solemn, and when he was overjoyed, and he was most certainly on that battlefield with a purpose - even if that purpose strayed from the one of Pogtopia.
And I'll give all I have, I'll give my blood, give my sweat
An ocean of tears will spill for what is broken
I'm shattered porcelain, glued back together again
Invincible like I've never been
Wilbur gave all he had for his nation, let’s be real. He gave so much that it tore him apart to watch it fall. L’Manberg broke, and so did he, and when the sixteenth fell upon the world, Wilbur would give his life for his symphony as well.
I love the shattered porcelain line because it makes me think of a line from a character study fic I wrote way back in September (or October?) implying that Wilbur felt as if he’d really fully died on Election Night, and that his existence ever since was a bitter attempt at a repair job.
I’d like to amend that thought - perhaps the real Wilbur shattered long before, even before the control room. Perhaps he shattered on the day Dream declared war, and he was given authority. Perhaps he shattered when he started burying his own emotion for L’Manberg.
And Wilbur was never invincible. He was always fated to die. Which is why, when the song ends with a sudden blank - it’s fitting. An unfinished symphony.
Because L’Manberg wasn’t the only unfinished symphony of the Dream SMP - Wilbur was one, too.
Posted Feb 15, 2021, 3:09 AM UTC
This is an absolutely wonderful analysis!
I love your interpretation of the song and it’s relation to Wilbur, and you put everything so succinctly. I used to really like the song, and this really brings a new perspective to its meaning.
Also, to bring up something I’ve seen before, the “fragile things” line could also allude to Wilbur’s treatment of Tommy during their time in pogtopia. He could have potentially seen a younger version of himself in Tommy and this warped perception perhaps influenced the way he emotionally abused the boy.
Wilbur’s character is truly a tragic fallen hero. He never really had anyone to confide in and virtually no one could see and understand what he was going through. Thinking about it makes the Dream SMP even more depressing...