r/chess•
SecBite

I think this has been mentioned before, but wouldn't it be better if there is a separate subreddit for chess puzzles?

Miscellaneous

Out of the top 10 posts of the last 24 hour, only 1 is a puzzle. But the volume of puzzles in the feed is insane, it´s super easy to find puzzles in tons of sites, but finding a good place forum for news discussion and information, not so much.

Edit: Found out r/ChessPuzzles already exists as also a massive discussion about this https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/l712ci/unpopular_opinion_this_sub_would_be_substantively.

Posted Feb 17, 2021, 12:19 AM UTC · edited

3732
7Ne4_0-1•

Should we have a counter for the latest time someone complains about the number of puzzles spamming in the subreddit ?

40
[deleted]•

[deleted]

23
zue3•

So valid criticism is also not allowed here? Gotcha

11
qwertyZZZZZZZZZ•

Nope

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
vaca_profana 1500 lichess rapid | 35 puzzle storm :p•

Or maybe create a separate sub for such complains :p

2

Yes, the puzzles are obnoxious, typically of low instructional value, and drown out any substantial content. Instead of a separate sub, I think we should have a Tactics Tuesday, or something like that, where for one or two days a week puzzles will be allowed.

24
academic962400 rapid (10+0) lichess•

I'd love a game analysis thread/day

5

You and me both lol.

1
pier4r/r/chessbooks - /r/chessnewsstand•

Yes I agree. One idea would be: 1 day a week (more days are not helpful as one has to think that some content tends to stick due to upvotes/timezones) + other subreddits (some exists already) and thus a sub-subcommunity can be formed.

Like having r/chess as overview, giving space to each subtopic regularly and subreddits that are specialized being always open to that subtopic.

5
sirxez•

I feel like there is so little content on r/chess already ...

Maybe that's just me, I don't come here a lot since there isn't anything to see.

2
pier4r/r/chessbooks - /r/chessnewsstand•

you can check the other chess subreddits or post content that you like yourself. Relying on "someone would do it" is not always the best in a community.

1
sirxez•

Sure, I should be the change I want to see.

I just don't really know what chess content I'd like to see ...

1
academic962400 rapid (10+0) lichess•

what, you want r/chess to lose 90% of all its traffic?

18
LeftyMcLeftFace•

There should be a daily mega thread for puzzles. I agree with Op, the amount of puzzles cluttering the feed is insane.

15
academic962400 rapid (10+0) lichess•

Oh I agree, I'd love to see more game analysis from players of all levels

4
SecBiteOP•

Out of the top 10 posts of the last 24 hour, only 1 is a puzzle. So it would be quite the opposite, loosing 10% that messes all up and focusing on news and information and discussions.

5†
andysaurus_rex•

I think this could be solved with a stickied thread for puzzles. It would lump them all in one place and keep them together on the same subreddit as everything else.

9
[deleted]•

Decent idea but the chess ai bot would have to get updated to deal with it.

3
andysaurus_rex•

I mean the poster could also just upload the solution in a spoiler

1
SecBiteOP•

Yes I haven't thought of it but sounds good!

1
Based_Commgnunism•

Daily puzzle megathread

6
andysaurus_rex•

I like it

2
CogentArticulation •

I think this deserves to be discussed. The issue is solved by muting the flair. Frankly, though, given that we're so fragmented as it is, we should focus on consolidating r/chess. I wouldn't do as many puzzles as I do (a paltry number anyway) without this sub.

EDIT: I also like the idea of a modded daily puzzle thread like others have suggested.

4
DenseLocation•

There was a massive discussion about this a couple of weeks ago: https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/l712ci/unpopular_opinion_this_sub_would_be_substantively.

I think the mods are looking at it.

4
SecBiteOP•

Hahaha I can´t believe r/ChessPuzzles already exists.

1

No clue what you are complaining about. You specifically say that only 1/10 posts when sorting for top are puzzles, but I just went through new and it isn't like that is 70% puzzles, so that can't be the problem either.

In general I feel like post people look at just the frontpage, so they see a reasonable amount of puzzles and if you do look at EVERY post, then it is just additional content, because there isn't too much content to consume all of it currently, so also not something to complain about.

​

But yes this has been said a million times, but people like having showcased some puzzles and inevitably when some puzzles are allowed there will be a more than just the absolutely best puzzles, because people disagree with what puzzles are best and it is easy to create/share content.

3
fight_for_anything•

imo, a good idea would be a daily puzzle megathread.

specifically make it daily, so there is always a new one every day.

also make the post itself the first puzzle. the thumbnail for the post should be the puzzle. it shouldnt just be a text post. that way there is a at least one new puzzle daily.

top comment will be something like "discuss this puzzle in this comment chain only".

then other top comments are reserved for people posting other puzzles that day.

there would still be all the same content, it would just be cleaner and more organized.

it also is better than putting it in a different subreddit, that way all the traffic can stay here.

4
Cd206•

Completely agree. Will always upvote posts stating this.

3
[deleted]•

You want to see less chess on the chess subreddit? Personally I'd rather see a puzzle than a post complaining about puzzles.

1
BcnStuff2020•

What is it people want instead of puzzles here

It’s a chess subreddit, and puzzles are literally chess. Do people want more drawings of beth harmon? photos of chess sets people bought? Drama between youtubers that play chess?

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AbandonEarth4Peace•

I think this has been mentioned before, but wouldn't it be better if there were a separate subreddit for complainers like you.

0
AlmightyDollar1231•

We should have a different subreddit for posts asking for different subreddits.

-1
Gorn340•

I really don't understand why people on a chess subreddit don't want chess puzzles here. Like, wtf? Just scroll past them. What is a chess subreddit for if people are gonna come and tell you that you can't post chess puzzles here? Ridiculous.

-1