r/btc•
Metallaxis

A razor for your arguments, courtesy of BSV

Discussion

I think it is the case that many people have been indoctrinated against Bitcoin cash by reading censored forums or listening to influencers that get their information from said forums. As such, the way they tend to think about BCH is very similar to how many people here think about BSV:

That it is a scam coin created by malicious actors for their financial gain, ego, and general self interests, who somehow got gullible people to follow them.

This presents in my opinion a great opportunity for enhancing our arguments when talking to people who have been getting such false information about bitcoin cash. All we have to do is this: Replace BCH with BSV in our argumentation and ask ourselves: If a BSV supporter told that exact argument to me, would it make me research some more, or would I straight out dismiss it?

In the first case, we will know that we have a good argument, because the first win in a dialectic process is not to necessarily convince the other party, but to get them to question their prior beliefs and want to do more research on their own. In the second case, our argument probably is somewhat weak, or at the very least incomplete and needs re-formulating.

Just my two cents for your consideration.

Posted Feb 18, 2021, 3:32 PM UTC

113
mrtest001•

Suing people for hosting the bitcoin whitepaper? yeah, fuck off WITH your coin.

My main technical reason is that BSV claiming protocol v1 of bitcoin was perfect and doesn't need to be upgraded, ever.

That's just an idiotic thing to say on its face. You dont know what the future holds and make that a pillar of your community - I am not going down that tunnel.

8
MetallaxisOP•

What are you talking about?

I do not support BSV, in any stretch of the imagination. I am just suggesting how one can mentally use some tricks to formulate better pro-BCH arguments, even using the existence of BSV to his advantage.

2
mrtest001•

"your" was meant as general you, not you. my bad.

3
Shibinator•

To be honest, arguing about BTC vs BCH vs BSV shouldn't be more than a sideshow. Everyone can argue until the cows come home and no one end up changing their opinion.

Much more important is building new technology, improving scaling and spreading adoption.

Other coins can argue or complain until they're blue in the face - but if BCH is what people are using and what they want to use then there's nothing to argue about.

3
MetallaxisOP•

In order to use it they must first be willing to try it.

I am not talking about arguing, I am talking about argumentation. There is a difference.

And whether we like it or not, that is what is happening in forums everywhere, all the time, so no reason not to be presenting more solid arguments.

1
Kay0r•

If a BSV supporter told that exact argument to me

They cannot.
BSV was made for a number of different reasons. Their official one is 'make bigger blocks, then stuff the chain with every data you can think about because reasons'.
They don't strive to be a replacement for fiat money.

3
wtfCraigwtf•

BSV was made for a number of different reasons.

The biggest reason was to sabotage and take over BCH development, mining, and blockchain. Craig 100% tried and 99% failed to do all of those things, BSV was never even meant to be a coin, and it wasn't about scaling or being useful to the world. Craig said numerous times he controlled BCH. And when Coingeek and their CIA subsidiaries attacked BCH mining with 4Th sustained hashrate, it was no accident.

2
Kay0r•

If you're patient enough to scrub my post history, you'll see that i've been saying this a looong time ago, given that the money to back up the whole circus were coming from Calvin Ayre, and he needed a way out from his legal troubles.
That's why i said their official reason is to make bigger blocks.

1
wtfCraigwtf•

fair point. Just wanted to set the record straight that BSV was 100% bad actors in the space. Sounds like you're onboard with that.

1
Collaborationeur•

The people here are so triggered by your mention of bsv that they cannot even start to apply the razor you suggest in their comments...

You finally found a positive use for the negativeness bsv brought us - hope you brought a new trick to at least a couple of us here.

Edit: spelling

3
MetallaxisOP•

You are so right!

I was surprised at how many couldn't read past two lines and focused on negativity.

But thank you for your comment, indeed, if something useful reaches even a small number of people, it is a net gain imo.

2
22rainy•

BSV and BCH are much more similar than BTC. It surprises me but BTC is still more used for buying drugs and other large financial transactions. It has lost its ability to conduct low fee transactions.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

-8