AskReddit is for questions only
That should be fairly self explanatory.
Also, this rule excludes moderator posts berating all of you.
Posted Oct 25, 2011, 1:41 AM UTC
That should be fairly self explanatory.
Also, this rule excludes moderator posts berating all of you.
Posted Oct 25, 2011, 1:41 AM UTC
Yeah, but if I ask a question and then throw "I'll start." at the end of it, then I get to tell my cool story, right bro? Right?
I prefer it when it's a reply and not part of the OP. You can't upvote the question but downvote the story separately.
I wish more submitters adhered to this idea.
I wish they stuck this in the sub-reddit rules.
Problem: the subreddit rules already say "for thought provoking questions." And "Hey, what's the craziest place you've ever banged a chick?" isn't thought provoking, even if it isn't followed with "I'll start"
[deleted]
And while we're wishing for things, I'd like a pony.
In a sense, it is, when they talk about polls and the like. A reasonable person would be able to extrapolate that similar behavior should be used when asking questions of the community.
They would just be accused of karma whoring.
no because then those people just reap in karma from it. if it's in the original post you can just downvote it out of the spotlight. when they post their story as a comment they're bound to get comment karma out of it and we don't want those idiots to benefit in any way!
I don't see what harm it has? They'll only get the karma their story's worth.
Can't get karma from self posts.
I would like it better if it were in a different subreddit. Something for anecdotal stories, share one if you have it or just ask if anyone has had a similar experience (note that r/coolstorybro actually does exist, but with very few readers). That is more or less what AskReddit has become, with the occasional actual question thrown in every now and then.
I really enjoy those stories. The OP ones arent always that good but many of the comment anecdotes are really interesting or funny or creepy. They're one of my favourite things on reddit.
I like some of them. The problem is that it's not really supposed to be a part of this sub-reddit. People are using AskReddit for this because the number of readers is large enough to guarantee an audience, and because they are getting away with it.
It's hard to deny that the "Hey, what's some random thing that happened to you?" or "Share some story about some aspect of life" are very popular, but in a sub-reddit that's supposed to be about "thought-provoking, inspired questions" they don't really belong here.
I think making r/shareastory a default sub-reddit would help alleviate the problem.
I think there are already some subreddits for this. I thought r/redditstories was one, but after checking, it's not, so I don't know what they are.
I'm helping!
the fallacy, then, is that askreddit is for thought-provoking questions, rather than for anecdote-sharing around a common topic.
If voting changed anything, they'd make it illegal.
I think both have ways of helping the thread. in some cases the story gives an idea of what the author has in mind for the thread. sometimes the subject is clear but other times the sample helps get people started and give a flow to the thread before it can take off.
Until people start doing this, I've taken to downvoting any post with a detailed question that ends with "I'll start."
Thank-you. That drives me nuts.
I go to AskReddit for thought-provoking questions, but in the past year the trend has been: Redditor thinks he/she has an interesting story, and so poses it in the form of a question, e.g.
Have any of you lost a leg in a threshing accident?
I'll start: This morning, I lost my leg in a threshing accident and here's my long-winded story, which I normally wouldn't be able to get other Redditors to read, but now everyone who comments in this thread will feel obliged to. Long boring story follows of no interest to anyone except OP.
The problem is that it leads to uninspired questions, which are essentially little more than DAE posts.
I also hate the common rhetorical question tactic:
Why do people think that it's OK that marijuana is illegal and yet everyone drinks alcohol?
The OP has already clearly made up his/her mind that it's not OK and is just looking for others to agree with him. Again- there's no genuine interest in actually posing a thought-provoking question.
Oh, and finally, there's the poorly titled question, in which the author hides the question in the accompanying text, rather than put any hints in the title, e.g.:
What do you think would be appropriate in this situation?
My boyfriend and I have been going out for 4 years. He has this friend, who lives 10 miles away, whereas I like to visit my aunt every second Thursday, blah blah blah blah.....
Wall of text follows
Finally... So should we buy a new puppy or not?
On that last note, why do people keep going to AskReddit for relationship advice? At least r/relationships has people willing to read and comment on relationship problems, why would you think 'My relationship is really strained, and my girlfriend has a suspiciously shady relationship with her new gym coach - also I followed her and watched her fucking him through a window - I want to know if she's cheating. I should ask the people with all the funny roommate stories!'?
I want to know why they even thought it was a good idea to look for relationship advice on the internet, let alone AskReddit.
Relationship advice in general is pretty stupid, from strangers. You set your own boundaries, and if something upsets you, that's how you are. Although r/relationships are usually a foregone conclusion, I'd guess 85% of the posts there are by people who are already being cheated on.
Where do people go for the non-thought provoking questions? Where are people supposed to tell their stories and ask for similar stories?
And what would you consider a "thought-provoking" question?
You say this now, but the truth is questions with no stories from the OP that are relevant to the question in the OP usually get downvoted because the first things posters say is, "You first" or, "Where's your story?"
Or the question is just downvoted because there's no story to interest people.
The OP should put his/her story in the comments same as everyone else.
I've started a few threads in Askreddit and I always thought that if I put my story in the comments, people would think I'm karma whoring.
I've seen this happening a lot.
[deleted]
Man I hate those posts so much. Anyone that includes, "I'll start" in their ask reddit thread really just wants to tell people their story. It's pretty much the same thing as DAE. These people are ruining reddit.
[deleted]
This post is due to this submission
But can we have a serious conversation about the removal of r/reddit.com. We started to have a good conversation about it here but post is now deleted.
I completely agree, and I asked the admins to re-purpose r/reddit.com for posts just about Reddit. I heard back from one of the admins and he said it's a good idea, but it might take a bit for them to determine just how to implement it.
Serious question: What is there to determine?
I don't know, exactly. I think they want to make sure that people know it is not an official subreddit, run by the admins. It will probably be approved-submitter only at the beginning so that people see what type of content it is supposed to be, instead of the "anything goes" subreddit that it was originally
Aren't we describing r/metareddit?
Why are you being downvoted bro? That is the reason they removed it. People would see "reddit.com" and think it was as important as r/announcements.
Is there a reason that "Anything Goes" is a bad thing? I liked r/reddit.com, it had a lot if interesting content and it was a great subreddit for submissions that didn't fit well into the framework of other subreddits.
Just how to implement it.
They probably want to recruit mods other than admins to handle it, but want it moderated within guidelines that are set by reddit. Both of which take time on top of everything else they have going on.
I don't know, exactly. I think they want to make sure that people know it is not an official subreddit, run by the admins. It will probably be approved-submitter only at the beginning so that people see what type of content it is supposed to be, instead of the "anything goes" subreddit that it was originally
Fuck off.
I thought r/circlejerk was for posts about reddit.
So is r/theoryofreddit, but both r/circlejerk and r/theoryofreddit are quite specific with regards to what about reddit is discussed there. PHOY et al are calling for a catch-all subreddit for things that don't fit in more specific subreddits.
I said it over there, but I'll repeat it here.
Why not just create a new subreddit for these purposes. The only difference between that and what you're asking for is special treatment as a default subreddit.
Momentum is a factor - people have tried, but having a general space with 900,000 subscribers is pretty helpful.
Like I said, the only difference between starting a new subreddit to do what these people want and getting r/reddit.com back is getting easy access to default subscription status (and the number of subscribers who go along with it).
Isn't that what r/bestof is for?
I completely agree
Just about reddit...? r/theoryofreddit , r/truereddit, r/truetruereddit
truereddit??? That's quite the opposite of being about reddit. Except if you meant "it's about what reddit used to be all about" in which I agree wholeheartedly.
Yes, I have a soft spot for truereddit.
Out of curiosity, what was the content of the post?
It was just another 'this Redditor sent me stuff' post.
I don't remember exactly, but some guy from Australia sent something of value to the OP to add to his collection of all things Jack Daniels. Might have been BBQ sauce related.
I love it when mods shutdown lame karma grabs!
It was a self post to be fair to the OP of that post.
Grow some balls and delete the submissions that break the rules, no matter how popular it gets :)
They did that today.
They still managed to have a post get 2,000 upvotes, despite being flat-out retarded and off-topic, before any mods got a chance to delete it.
If it gets upvoted that high without any of the 23 mods here noticing, then maybe we need mods that actually show up?
To be honest, I think there was somebody gaming the system somehow.
I have never seen a post skyrocket so quickly, and yet be entirely devoid of content.
The post had no meaningful statement, was inane babble, and all the comments were either criticizing it, or saying some really weird-ass and retarded shit.
It was up to ~100 points in an hour, and ~600 points with an RES estimated ~2,1000 upvotes in three, before the mods hid it.
And I can't be the only one to have reported it as soon as I saw it.
Lurkers and commenters are different people. It's not too unusual to see a submission reach the front page with most of the comments criticizing it.
All of that could have been solved if the mods that were active did something about it. But what do I know ....
Reasons for the report button, if you're sitting there watching it get upvotes may as well report it.
Temp banning offending users might be a good idea. Posting an offending post that later gets deleted may be worth a user's while if they get karma for it (they don't lose any accrued karma upon deletion). So add in some leverage by barring them from the community for a spell to think about what they did, and then perma-ban repeat offenders.
Thing is, whenever that happens, there's usually a crazy shit-fit on the front page. Reddit seems to hate it when moderators actually do anything.
Better a shitfit over a mod doing their job instead of moronic chaos
You're right, and btw hows Ian doing?
Lan is doing well, trying to save the world while doing cancer research.
[deleted]
Perhaps it might be possible for the mods to move the submission to a different subreddit whilst keeping everything intact.
Mods don't have the tools to do that.
Mods should have the power to boot a submission to r/all without actually deleting it.
Should but they don't. That is something that only the admins can do, if it's even possible.
Maybe you should turn on your moderator thingy for this...
Those pants were in the wash.
Okay, I do remember that this Hannah Montana account has a male behind it.
Yeah, I wonder how many people reported this one too.
I'm Ron Burgandy?
Does that include rhetorical questions?
What do you think?
ಠ_ಠ
No, because I seen this subreddit where they be asking for dumbshit, and they get like a thousand upboats. What I don't get is what the fuck are upboats? And who the hail is raun Paul?
I love pie
Does anybody else love pie?
~~ IAMA pie eater and I love it, AMA!~~
If you had to choose between eating pie or punching Michelle Bachman in the womb every day for a year, which wold you choose?
Askreddit is hard.
Punching Michelle Bachman's pie for a year.
Do I get pie for a year?
It's a simple question, even a baby could answer it. Would you eat the moon if it was made of ribs?
Can I pick the pie? Do you pick the pie? Are you setting a cap on how many womb punches one can have per day?
Hey reddit! Look at this awesome tattoo I got!! OMG lol!!!
What I can't believe are the posts that actively know they're breaking the most basic rule of this subreddit. There was one earlier: "I know this isn't a question but..."
If you're aware that it's not a question, don't post it in a subreddit for questions. I don't get how hard it is.
You can't tell that all those lame posts from today are from some spammer who made a million accounts but doesn't really understand how to post on Reddit?
Who the hell is this guy?
He is posted again and again, and for some reason, even without context, creates the urge in me to smash in his face...
I haven't noticed anything?
Well, shit. I ask questions on there and nobody gives a fuck... unless they come up with a joke answer.
i feel ya man
To replace r/reddit I created GeneralReddit.
It's a catch-all for posts like the one that spawned this thread.
"Reddit Classic."
Occasionally I go through the AskReddit "new" page, skim the list, and downvote anything that's not a question (though some titles are ambiguous and I click on them to check, even if they have no ? at the end).
If more of you joined me in doing this, then non-question posts would sink pretty quickly. It doesn't take much time.
I don't consider it a question if it has the words "I'll start" or if the author in any way is just using it as an excuse to tell their lame story.
When I first started I made this mistake way to often and now that I have been here I see how truly annoying it is.
Hence I down-vote anything with "I'll start" in the title without even reading.
You know, I hate off-topic threads, but I don't hate "I'll start" threads.
It seems like people only click on threads if there's already something to read there, so a lot of good questions get ignored if the OP just asks the question.
If they say "I'll start", or explain a lot more in the post, they get comments. You almost never see people clicking on empty posts.
It seems like those threads often generate really interesting responses so I don't mind them.
I'm Ron Burgundy?
I just woke up the other people in my house laughing at this. Upvote for you, good sir!
So is this a better place to ask you why the admins are giving user IP locations to moderators?
Who cares? I come to reddit to read interesting articles/stories/comments. Not to obay some inane and/or obsolete rules.
cake upvote, you karma whore.
Uh oh. You guys got in trouble. Neener, neener, neener.
Not me of course. I always play by the rules.
Well that's ridiculous? If it's for questions only, then how are any of these questions going to be answered?
I think you need to rethink this?
Is AskReddit for questions only?
You have to phrase this as a question:
"Is AskReddit for questions only???!!!"
[deleted]
I'd say "Do you fuckwits not realize that AskReddit is for questions only?"
I'd say [annoyingly] "Is askreddit for questions only? I'll start..."
I'd read his exception clause.
A slight difference. I'd say in the title " Is AskReddit for questions only?" Then inside, " Why yes, yes it is. "
You know the rules, and so do I.
Upvote purely for username. My Dale fidelity is strong.
Okay, so I was looking up penis enlargement surgery. I'm looking for approximately 800% growth, hopefully within the next six to eight months. Should I stick with the pills? I think Jimmy Johnson is a douche but those big boobed girls seem to be digging his package.
Tough crowd.
Third time is the charm.
I'll take anal bum cover for $200.
"A red liquid substance, that, when introduced into the anus provides a pleasant burning sensation. Also used in food preparation"
What is chili sauce?
That is correct!!! $200 for winitforsparta.
Your turn again
What is Chipotle?
Absolute Shit Food -> or ASF for the TL;DR Crowd.
Did that guy ever actually go through with it?
It is not 'The Rapists' Mr. Connery - It's Therapists.
my FUCKING FAVO(U)RITE line from Celebrity Jeopardy
That is a yes or no question. Better is "For what reason are we (the moderators) creating this post?" with the top response being "People are being idiots."
Since when is Karmanaut back? I'm very drunk.
or "hey when did you gents and ladies start thinking you can post whatever the fuck you want on this subreddit?" well thats what i thought the post really meant.
Is the pope Catholic?
Go fuck yourself San Diego.
DAE think AskReddit should only be for serious questions?? I'll start.
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
Dammit, we want answers!
WHAT DID IT SAAAYYYYY!?!?!?!??!
Wow. A whole watermelon?
I must know
Aww comon! What did it say!?
What's in the box?
[deleted]
[deleted]
I was about to point out the same thing.... Then I saw the exception...
[deleted]
What is the idea that AskReddit is for questions only?
You didn't end it with a question mark :'( If you don't, it's not a question! Edit: Sarcasm of course
[deleted]
¿Really?