r/politics•
vph

Isn't OWS a little misled?

It seems that the goal of OWS is to declare wall on the top 1%. Trust me I am on the side of OWS, but I think this OWS movement has been misled (not clear by whom though). Let me explain.

It is very natural for any group of people to influence the government for their own interests. The poor does it. The middle class does it. And of course, the top 1% does it. Everyone does it within their means. The top 1% has money, and they use it to influence the government. In fact, the OWS movement is a testament that some of the 99% is trying to influence with their voice.

So, to say that the 1% shouldn't be influencing the government doesn't make any sense. It's very natural for any group of citizens to gain more leverage for themselves in society.

To me, what the 99% should do is not declaring war with the 1%, but rather aims their justified anger at the government, at specific policies that are unfair to them, at specific congressmen, senators or even president(s), who have created such policies.

Posted Oct 25, 2011, 5:23 AM UTC · edited

08
poetryofreality•

They shouldn't be influencing the government MORE than anyone else. Every citizen gets a vote, the right to protest, etc. But the 1% spends millions of dollars getting policies put into place that serve their interests and their interests alone. The OWS isn't saying those people should have no influence, it's saying they have way too much influence because of their money.

1
SupaFurry•

If you think that they more money you have the more say you get in how the country is run, then you do not believe in democracy and you do not believe in the very fundamental principles of the United States. The path we're heading down right now is the path to a corporate-controlled fascism.

That money has corrupted our political system so that it no longer represents the people as a whole, just the 1 %, is the core message of OWS.

1
curien•

At some level, I don't see how you can avoid that problem without completely obliterating freedom of speech. Ignoring every other complicating factor, a rich person has more leisure time than a poor person (because the poor person has to work to fulfill his basic survival requirements), so the rich one has more opportunity to personally spread his message. Do you regulate how long he can stand on a street corner sharing his views, so that he gets no more time than anyone else?

1
SupaFurry•

[Or a rich person has less time because he is too busy and a poor person is unemployed so has all the time in the world...]

Every individual can lobby their elected representatives, no matter what their free time or economic status is. Not everyone can afford a multi-million dollar lobbying operation that is constantly and tirelessly working to influence the political process in their favor. The politicians that we elected to work for us have been purchased and work for someone else. That is wrong.

Free speech only comes into it if you think money is speech.

1
curien•

I fail to see the philosophical difference between purchasing the services of a lobbying agency and purchasing a bullhorn.

1
SupaFurry•

One allows you to significantly affect the political process in your favor at the expense of others and the other allows you to express your views.

1
jerryF•

To me, what the 99% should do is not declaring war with the 1%, but rather aims their justified anger at the government, at specific policies that are unfair to them, at specific congressmen, senators or even president(s), who have created such policies.

The problem with this is that there are no clear distinction between the two. Firstly politicians are clearly part of the "1%" secondly wall street are the more powerful.

Going after wall street has two purposes (whether intended or not), it makes a symbol of a group of actors who clearly committed criminal and/or deeply immoral actions and they are driving a wedge between politicians and wall street. If ows is successful they can turn on politicians later but the most important is to weaken wall street they hold the power to buy the politicians of their liking.

1

Translation: "Pay no attention to the men behind the curtain."

1