My version of the tier list, inspired by u/Indubitablyahuman

My version of the tier list, inspired by u/Indubitablyahuman

Posted Feb 22, 2021, 11:42 AM UTC

813
Stache23•

you gotta check out 90 mile beach live, its great!

9
Bradnailer•

Came to say this...90 mile beach is one of my favorites.

7
FireproofFerretOP•

Ok, I can honestly say I'd put it much higher now. Thanks!

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Putrid-Existence•

Don't delete the kisses, visions of a life, white leather, you're a germ, moaning lisa smile, yuk foo & giant peach should be in the legendary tier.

5
FireproofFerretOP•

They're all fantastic, but I though keeping my own top 10 in the highest tier was the best choice, despite a lot more songs deserving the title 'legendary'. Yuk Foo is something I need to be in the mood for, as I tend to prefer the slower/calmer ones most of the time, but Giant Peach should have just been higher really, I don't know why I didn't put it in great at least.

1
RelationshipFinal894•

My take, fwiw.

Actually hoping for the return of 90 Mile Beach to the live sets. They played it both times I saw them pre-Visions, but got pushed out of the setlists the 3 shows post-Visions. Ellie's and Joel's voices blend so wonderfully and it's the only time I've seen Joff utilize a slide in a live setting. He has great touch with it. The CODA is just glorious and makes me feel like I'm wrapped in a big comfortable blanket of warm noise and I never want to leave.

3
FireproofFerretOP•

I just listened to the live version of 90 mile beach and it's really good. Pretty disappointed in myself for not hearing it sooner tbh.

2
BedsAreSoft•

90 mile beach so low???? Whaaaaaat? And Giant Peach so low too?😭 I respect it though

2
FireproofFerretOP•

After listening to the live version of 90 mile beach, I wouldn't put it so low anymore.

Also, Giant Peach does deserve to be higher really, I love it. I think I just wanted to actually use the other tiers rather than having everything in Great at the lowest.

1
Indubitablyahuman•

Damn we're different. Sadboy, Giant Peach, and Heavenly Creatures are one of my favourite. But I think we can all agree that Silk is Legendary. Thanks for sharing yours!

2
FireproofFerretOP•

Silk does seem to be commonly high up. Amazing song.

1