Kaepora•

Props to the Tor team for being responsible about it.

23
w0lrah•

If I'm understanding this correctly, an attacker who has either compromised or set up as a honeypot the last leg of your communication on the Tor network (either the exit node or the node hosting the hidden service) can associate a client cert with the traffic.

They then can determine which guard nodes you're connected to, defeating the purpose of the relay nodes.

If any of those guard nodes are compromised, your cert can be directly associated with the IP address your Tor connection is coming from. This could technically be used against historical logs of certs, if I'm not mistaken, so anyone who has used the vulnerable versions to access anything questionable would be wise to upgrade immediately to ditch the old cert.

If none of the guard nodes are compromised but they are under surveillance, traffic from your cert to the compromised end node could be correlated with traffic seen at the monitored guard node to identify which real IP it came from. This would not be usable against historical logs of certs alone, but would be usable if the guard node was being monitored as you accessed the content.

If you're worried about Joe Random Hacker finding out your identity, this probably isn't too big of a deal. If you're worried about government(s), I'd be scared.

Standard I-am-not-an-expert disclaimer applies, please correct me if I got it wrong.

edit: Rereading #3 on the article page it seems that it's also possible for an internet site to determine which guard nodes you are using without even knowing the cert. I haven't read the paper and thus can't explain how it works, but I think it would then allow for similar traffic analysis to the second option above if the guard node was being monitored.

7
TwistedBrother•

Does anyone know when they will have a torbrowser bundle with this version?

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Upgraded my relays, and my clients. Awesome that they fixed it so quickly.

5
cryptogramTrusted Contributor•

Good post.. might have taken me a few days longer to get this updated otherwise. Not too worried it'd be exploited and cause issues for me though.

1
TheGoddamBatman•

Again... please stop telling people to use Tor. :)

-8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
BrowsOfSteel•

Why? :)

5
TheGoddamBatman•

We've been over this before. I have, anyway.

Nobody agrees in the comments because r/netsec is irrationally exuberant about Tor for reasons I don't get, and disagreements descend quickly to ad hominem, but whatever.

I wonder how long this and other kinds of de-anonymizing vulnerabilities exist in Tor before being reported and fixed? 0day doesn't exist in a vacuum.

-2
mickeycTrusted Contributor•

People in the comments disagreed with you not because they were being irrational, but because you made provably false claims.

Your claim that people shouldn't use Tor because it might have vulnerabilities is as nonsensical as somebody claiming that people shouldn't PGP to encrypt their email or SSL to encrypt their HTTP traffic, in case there are vulnerabilities.

4
TheGoddamBatman•

I'm sure I was less than clear, but my central claim is that TOR enables more efficient forms of tracking and eavesdropping, instead of hindering eavesdropping and tracking. Also, the majority of TOR users are (probably) criminal anyway, not that there's anything wrong with that, but this apparently offends people.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5