PoGo advice for new players: Is it better to have a low cp-high IV pokemon or high cp-low iv pokemon.

So I recently starting playing pokemon go with my kids but I have no idea how to play. My 5 and 8 year olds are my teachers. So they are teaching me to toss my potions and revive in favor of pokeballs (which I am now realizing is a bad move) and evolving pokemon as soon as I get enough candies (also, ill advised.) So my question is this: Is it better to have a low cp-high IV pokemon or high cp-low iv pokemon? I have a perfect iv magnamite, but the cp is so low that the mon faints after two hits. I don't have any revives or potions and the one pokestop that I can walk to gives the shittiest gifts. I get stickers and 1-2 pokeballs. On community day, I stayed at the pokestop for the full hour waiting to get pokeballs, potions, and revive. I got 15 ball (poke, great, ultra), 1 revive, 1 potion, 2 max potions, an egg, stardust and and a bunch of stickers. So I couldn't really do anything other than wait. I probably would have been better off walking home and driving to a location with multiple pokestops, but I was too lazy. I was stalking the binocular tabs to see if I could try to earn more anything and did eventually earn 15 great balls, but it was a lot of work for 30 balls. On a brighter note, I did use my last ball in caught a shiny pikachu, so that was good

Posted Feb 25, 2021, 8:42 PM UTC

910
GreenWolf32•

It really depends on what you intend to use them for. For raids and gyms, ivs don't matter as much. For the PvP meta it can make a difference. Considering it sounds like resources are scarce for you I'd say stick with high CP-mon for the time being. Evolve a few mon to carry you over while you gather resources for mon with good ivs. It does mean you technically waste resources on pokémon you intend to box, but it won't leave you frustrated while trying to build up the pokémon you want to keep. After that, once you've got a good spread of pokémon with good ivs that have been leveled up you can focus on good iv pokemon exclusively.

7
HowDoIGetToFacebookEevee•

This. Also, keep in mind that evolving a Pokemon restores it's HP so if you have a Pokemon that's dead that you plan to evolve anyway, don't give it any revives or potions because it'll be a wasted resource. And definitely don't throw away any Pokemon with perfect IVs, even if it is low CP. You can always power them up down the road.

I evolve Pokemon as soon as I have enough candies because I only ever use them to get coins from gyms. They're literally tagged as "Gym Placements" and as soon as they come back, they're out. It helps to level up quickly because evolving a whole bunch with a lucky egg gets you a buty-load of XP which will help down the line.

1
Ok-Assignment-3735•

If the “appraisal” button returns a 1-star rating, I send the Pokémon to the professor. I only keep 2-star Pokémon, and dump those with low CP. You got to catch them all but they don’t mention keeping them. It is such a bummer to catch a high CP Pokémon only to find it’s a one-star or less.

5
2205037:mystic: Mystic•

You can always change the cp but not the ivs.

4
GoodeSVK:instinct: Instinct•

First of all, if you get anything with 100% IV just keep it. IVs work like some kind of potential, you may not see it on low level, but you will see it with high level. Also I would reccomend to keep anything with high level (usually these are weather boosted pokemon). And safe all those hundos or even 98, 96 and 93% IV pokemons for times when these pokemons will get usefull or you will have enough stardust so you would not mind to power it up.

When it comes to evolving, Im usually doing it when I found a good IV one (91% with 15 attack) or when its a good PvP pokemon. I think those evolution XP and pokemon registering XP are not worth speeding thought it.

3
[deleted]•

If you didn’t know the IV’s only factor in 10% of a Pokémon’s stats, the rest are the Base Stats of said Pokémon

You would want a Low Attack IV for Great and Ultra League but for Master and Raids I would recommend the Highest IV’s Possible

It seems you’re pretty new so I wouldn’t worry to much about Combat Power right now, you could power up the Perfect IV Magnamite for Raids if you needed it.

But I would recommend you save up that stardust for now, you could get a higher CP Mon you or not, but from a LV29 Person Stardust is pretty much needed to get my Mons to a good CP

2
RipeWithWorryOP•

I have stockpiled 200k stardust. I stopped purifying my shadow catches until I know I will use them.

2
ihgibdhhv•

I would just subsist with high cp mons and save as much stardust as possible. My friend saved 500k barely powered anything besides a few to help her in great league. She just hit level 33 and caught a perfect psystrike mewtwo and maxed it with 2 moves. (She saved all her rare candies for mewtwo as well). She has a few other good mons too. And she’s very new.

3
josephriviello•

First of all congrats on the shiny pikachu.

I usually like to get a combo of both good IV’s and good cp. but as far as CP goes if u have a lower cp Pokémon with good IV’s you can still keep it to use in the great leaugue (or atm the Kanto cup) where the limit is only 1500 cp

1
AmazingAd2765•

Unless you are competing in the PVP leagues, stats aren't that important because they only account for a small part of the total attack/def/HP. Higher CP is needed for raids and to beat rocket leaders though.

1