ELI5 If airplane tyres are made to be strong and durable why are we not using them or the technology in ordinary cars so that they last longer and prevent accidents from exploding tyres ?
Posted Feb 25, 2021, 10:37 PM UTC
Posted Feb 25, 2021, 10:37 PM UTC
Because airplane wheels are made to withstand fairly extreme pressure changes and temperature shifts in the short term, and are replaced every 100 flights or so (unless Google badly misled me) due to the rough treatment of landing and supporting a huge aircraft on the tarmac. Plus, aircraft tires are pumped to 200 PSI - about six times that of a car tire. You don’t want that to explode on the highway just because you forgot to change the tires after the month’s commute to work. :P
Simply put, airplane tires are made to endure very high stress for shorter periods, and must be replaced around every three to four months. Car tires can go for six to ten years before they need replacing. It’s the very different use patterns they were designed for.
We do use the same technology on car tires, but you've got it backwards...a car tyre lasts *far* longer than a typical airplane tyre and is much less likely to become a problem if it bursts.
Car tyres last 10s of thousands miles, airplanes are good for a few hundred miles.
If a car tyre bursts you usually just slow to a stop and change the tire with no damage to the vehicle. A burst airplane tyre can cause all kinds of damage...the airplane is designed to take it, it's not unsafe, but it's going to make a huge mess.
[removed]
[removed]
Do you want 1000 pound tires on your car?
Most of their strength comes from having aramid (kevlar or similar) reinforcement and being pumped up to around six times the pressure of a normal tire. Blowouts become less frequent, but when they do happen, it's like a grenade going off. So, would you rather keep your high speed steering ability, or half of your car?
Because it’s more expensive.
Airplane tires are chemically the same as normal car tires, it’s the same material, but the physical structure of the tire is different. Airplane tires have special threads that run through the rubber as a reinforcement, almost like steel running through concrete, and this increases the cost of the tire.
So, cars, which are meant to be more affordable for your average joe, use a cheaper design.
But, this is starting to change a bit with modern car tires getting stronger and stronger.
They're not meant to be strong and durable, they're meant to withstand the extreme load of a landing plane. If you notice, most of the time, there isn't any weight on a plane's tires while in use. It's only during takeoff and landing that you get any wear on them. It goes maybe 1 mile on tires before takeoff and after landing
In contrast, a cars tires need to be able to withstand thousands of miles of continuous, dirty travel.
Those use-sets are vastly different, and you can't guarantee that things that are good for one are good for the other.