A new mechanic that will never be printed

Posted Feb 26, 2021, 7:44 AM UTC

Posted Feb 26, 2021, 7:44 AM UTC
But how do you play it if you do not know its mana cost as this is a face down card?
Rather make it a foretell stuff or something.
707.5. At any time, you may look at a face-down spell you control on the stack or a face-down permanent you control (even if it’s phased out). You can’t look at face-down cards in any other zone or face-down spells or permanents controlled by another player.
You as the controller can still look at it, it's just hidden from the other players. That's why manifest and morph work.
Hmm. TIL.
I'm pretty sure this works as written, and I thought it would be a little silly to have reminder text for the reminder text. The design is inspired by the fact that you can't use manifested instants or enchantments except as chump blockers.
I’m not sure why this wouldn’t work. Seems like a better version of manifest to me.
The only concern I have at the moment is playing a card from the battlefield. I didn't see anything that says you can't do that, but it would also be an entirely unprecedented effect. That said, there is one downside to this over manifest, in that the act of playing it gives an opportunity for an opponent to counter it.
Magic's rules are generally permissive, not restrictive. In other words, you can generally only do what the rules say you can. For example, the rules say you can cast a sorcery during your main phase if the stack is empty. They don't say that you can't play a Sorcery during your opponent's turn. Similarly the rules say that creatures can attack and block. Enchantments can't attack or block because the rules don't allow them to, not because the rules say they can't. It's a subtle difference, but it's important to keep in mind if you are designing cards "by the book." So the fact that there's no rule stating you can cast a card from the battlefield does prevent this from working.
For this to formally work within the rules, "Coalesce" would either need to be added to the rules, or the "you may it from the battlefield" ability would need to be in the rules (not reminder) text.
What I meant by saying there is no rule saying I can't is that the rules for casting don't specify zones at all except to say usually from the hand.
The rules for casting (CR 601) do not specify a zone, but the rules for each card type do. For example, rule 302.1:
302.1 A player who has priority may cast a creature card from their hand during a main phase of their turn when the stack is empty. Casting a creature as a spell uses the stack.
Similar rules exist for artifacts, instants, etc.
601.3 A player can begin to cast a spell only if a rule or effect allows that player to cast it and no rule or effect prohibits that player from casting it.
So 601.3 indicates that you can only cast a spell if a rule allows it (and no rules prohibit it), while rules like 302.1 specifically indicate "from hand." This is both what allows you to cast spells from your hand and why casting from the battlefield isn't supported within the current rules.