Is there an evolutionary justification for it being "enjoyable" to do nothing. Surely those who like idleness would've been less successful?
For example, it's incredibly easy for me to spend the entire day Redditing, listening to music, or doing other unproductive things. Why then is it so "fun"? Wouldn't the people who don't like being idle, or doing unproductive things be more successful in terms of natural selection, and therefore "beat" those who like doing nothing?
Sorry for all the inverted commas, English is not my mother tongue.
Posted Oct 29, 2011, 8:39 PM UTC
18
It's simply a matter of energy conservation. For most animals, including early humans, obtaining food was very difficult. When you got a meal, you never knew how long it would be until your next one. This would mean that it was advantageous to conserve the energy once you got it.
Also in the things you listed, they aren't necessarily bad for you. Reddit and music may help you grow, learn and achieve things in places like askscience (though don't go off using that to justify 40 hours a week on here and think you're going to achieve all of your goals!) Think of how much of our knowledge and success has come from people thinking and discussing problems. Sometimes the easy thing to do will help you survive in more ways that keeping up calories!
None of this existed when these traits were being selected for.
I was using that to make an example that when we enjoy doing 'nothing' (though we never do nothing, people associate whimsical thinking as nothing) we can actually be doing things that are very beneficial to our survival and thus are prone to be drawn to evolution. This has added to human 'success' and while my specific example is not directly answering a question, I used it to draw a bigger picture of how idleness can be beneficial.
This isn't as you said, "simply a matter of energy conservation." Just look at alligators who eat very seldom. If it were simply energy conservation, every species would strive to eat as they do. Conservation has a big role, but is by no means the only reason.
You are a bit confused about evolution. These traits evolved before the human species. They are an evolutionary leftover from when energy conservation was more important than everything. We retained these traits, and will probably retain them forever because these traits are not getting selected for or against (so their prevalence will not change to an appreciable extent save for genetic drift).