High School Seasons Rewatch

Discussion

Hi, I recently rewatched the High School Seasons (these are the only seasons I own on DVD) and throughout my rewatch, I came here and noticed that a lot of people think that season 2 was the weakest high school season and I just wanted to say that I really disagree. It may not be as good as seasons 1 or 3, but I thought it was much more interesting than season 4. I feel like season 2 was much more important when it came to characters development, meaning that each character sort of went through a separate journey in order to figure out who they are as people before "coming together" in season 3. Seems to me like that was mostly the intent, and I liked it, and I thought it was interesting.

I actually think that season 4 was weaker than season 2 because it doesn't feel like anything happens there. Yes, we deal with some leftovers from season 3 like Keith's murder, Peyton-Lucas-Brook, the accident, psycho Derek (Season 2), but everything else like the point shaving, the calculus test stealing, the clean tean, Mr. Chavez.., they all just feel contrived and uninteresting, and you could tell they already run out of ideas of what to do with this teens who don't act like teens. But I have to say that my biggest disappointment is Brooke ending up with Chase, partly because he's boring, but mainly because I think a more fitting ending for Brooke high school years is to realize she can be happy even if she's not in a relationship.

Anyway, that's just my two cents.

Posted Feb 27, 2021, 1:52 PM UTC

2311
rwatkins829•

I find the Jake baby mama drama way more far fetched than anything in season 4.

I find it odd that you think nothing happens in season 4 and then rattle off a bunch of big things happening in season 4. Two of the biggest things that happened are the Ravens winning the state championship and graduation.

Season 2 feels unfocussed and like outside forces are driving the stories more than the characters (e.g. Haley goes on tour and Brucas 2.0). One of the biggest issues with season 2 is Dan becomes a mustache twirling villain.

13
Few_Day7472•

Yes and also also everyone has to remember it was not the WB anymore in season 4. OTH was on the CW now so it was more adult situations starting in season 4. Seasons 3 and 4 are my Favorite and they were a ton of stories going on.

2
iknowapuppy•

The more I rewatch them the more season 2 becomes my favourite.

11
producermaddy•

S2 is brought down by naley drama (horrible for first time watcher but not as bad on rewatch) and Felix. (Still annoying even on rewatch) it does have some iconic moments like Nathan crashing the race car and dan almost being killed but it’s still the weakest hs season imo

10
frenchfangirl•

I can’t say that I agree, season 4 is my favorite season of the show. I loved the evolution of Leyton’s relationship from friends to lovers. I love how Peyton dealt with the aftermath of psycho Derek (with her brother and later with Brooke), weirdly enough the Brooke/Rachel dynamic was super interesting. And i liked Nathan’s storyline too.

9
realityleave•

thank you! i think everyone hates season 2 bc of naley bring apart and nathan reverting to being an assholw, but its really not that bad. like you said, everyone gets their own growth plotline and i genuinely think that the season 2 finale is one of the best finales of the show. if felix and anna weren’t in the season, it would be sooo much better bc everyones growth arc wouldnt have to split time with those jokers

9
SuccotashTough7468•

I like parts of season two, but hate Chad’s shaved head so much.

5
anestezija•

I can agree with this. 4 is my least favourite of the high school years, but still much, much better than everything that came after.

Season 4 (and late S3) was when the stories started getting really far-fetched for high school kids, and to me, it lost that nostalgic charm of the first few seasons when we were still getting to know the characters.

3
ThePrincessSnowy•

S2 is so much better than S4. I hate Felix but the storyline’s are great and I love Jake. Brooke’s character development was amazing. It was nice to see more of the characters lives outside of basketball.

2
niccizzie•

Season 4 is my second favorite season.... the first season being my favorite. I also really like 2 and 3...

2

I am rewatching for the first time in 10 years. Season 2 is fantastic because of Dan Scott. He is comically evil.

I don’t even care about any of the relationship drama. I just like the basketball and music careers

1