How does the French government spend 56% of GDP?
In 2019, the US federal, state, and local governments spent about 36% of GDP. In France, it was about 56%. Yes, France has universal health care, on which it spends about 11% of GDP, but government spending on health care in the US is about 7% of GDP, plus the US spends about 1.5% of GDP more on its military than France does. So together these two factors explain about 2.5 out of 20 percentage points.
France doesn't have a UBI, and to the best of my knowledge they have more or less the same kinds of welfare programs that the US has; why is spending as a share of GDP so much higher?
Finland, Belgium, and Denmark also had government spending in excess of 50% of GDP in 2018, so if anyone is more familiar with the situation in those countries, I would be just as interested in an answer based on one of them. Denmark might be even more of a mystery, since it's more comparable to the US in terms of unemployment and GDP per capita.
Specifically I'm asking about the late 2010s, after recovery from the Great Recession but before COVID-19 spending got ramped up.
Posted Feb 28, 2021, 2:12 PM UTC
Per the OECD, in 2015 France spent 43% of its government spending on "social protection", which is basically all forms of transfers, while the US spent 21%. That accounts for 12 percentage points out of the 20. The US actually spends 1 percentage point more on healthcare and education than France according to the OECD. And like you said, the US spends 1.5pp more on defence. The US also outspends on public order.
The biggest component of the unexplained 10.5pp is from "economic affairs" - that explains ~3pp, and is where France's state-owned enterprises are included. The rest is just generally higher spending on all sorts of things (administration, public works, environment, culture).
The data I referred to is from 2015, when the US was actually at 37.7% and France at 57%, so there is also 0.7pp accounted for in rounding errors :)
Maybe this should be a separate question, but is there an agreed upper & lower bound on what a country should spend on education? For example, maybe 5% of GDP is too little see a productive return, but 80% is too high. And what about healthcare and unemployment benefits?
[deleted]
I agree this question is very difficult in practice, but in theory it has an answer that could be found in a similar way to the optimal savings rate if you view education as a sort of capital investment in labor in the sashes way as we consider there to be an optimal rate of investing in more highly skilled labor? I’m not sure where I’m going with this but It seems like it could have a theoretical answer that would be practically difficult to find
You're ignoring the normative part.
Or I'd say rather the metaphysical part. Normative can imply the issue is only restricted to norms.
How is it even possible to define an optimal level? What are you optimizing? Picking what you are trying to optimize is a moral question. There isn't a single, objective correct function that you simply need to find where the derivative is zero. Note, the problem here isn't that it's too complicated in practice to write down such a function. It's that by defining such a function you've already injected your own moral choices, so it isn't an objective statement about reality but a description of your personal beliefs about what is good and what is bad.
Similarly, there's no theoretical 'best' savings rate. Theory can't tell you what you should do. It can only tell you a bit about what the tradeoffs are between decisions. It can tell you what the various outcomes are likely to be for different options. But you have to use a different approach to select between those options based on your own moral preferences.
I want to add to what u/Admiral_Red_Wings said. How much to spend may be normative, but I think everyone would agree that if a program has a positive social effect and pays for itself, the government should spend on that program.
Here's a neat interactive chart (by Harvard economists) that tries to identify programs that pay for themselves:
https://www.policyinsights.org/#
Edit: Here's the paper that goes with the interactive chart.
But you didn't get away from the normative part at all. How do you define "positive" social benefit? That's an inherently normative question. There's no way getting around that.
Yes, what is “positive” is normative.
So I will clarify my point: there are things that I think the vast majority of the population think are positives. Therefore, making those things happen when it costs nothing to do so is probably something that most people would want.
Examples of issues that often revolve not on the merits of the program but on the cost:
I think most people would be in favour of vouchers (that allow low-income families to send their kids to the school of their choice), or free tuition, if it would cost the tax payer 0 dollars.
There is always nuance to every issue (the cost isn’t immediately paid back, and one can always find some exception in which a “universal positive” turns out to be a negative), but I think the nuance is not relevant to the broader point I’m making, which is that there are programs that are almost universally regarded as positive but which are not implemented primarily because they would cost too much.
Am I making more sense now?
Edit1: I revised the last sentence so that it doesn’t sound snarky :p
That’s a fascinating article. Thanks for sharing!
Would it make sense then to say that the "correct" amount to spend on education should be up to the point where the marginal benefit (social, financial, and all) of additional spending would equal its marginal cost (including absolute and opportunity costs like the chance to spend elsewhere or not spend at all)?
Maybe! I don’t know sorry, haha. I’m not an economist. I don’t have a perfect grasp of marginal benefits and costs in this context. My intuition tells me you are correct, but there may be some important qualifications to make.
Like u/MadCervantes said, a lot of it is normative. But I think there are lots of normative questions that can have answers. The question with education spending is: what is the goal? If the goal is to maximize gdp/capita (and thus standard of living) I assume your approach would work but I’m not an economist. Hopefully one sees your question!
edit1: spelling
[removed]
[removed]