Should I scrap a scene if I’m unhappy with how it’s coming, or finish it and go back to rewrite once the draft is finished?

NEED ADVICE

As I’m working on the first draft for my pilot, I’m writing out the final scene in my second act and I’m not too happy with how it’s coming out. It’s a moment where all my leads are meeting for the first time but I’m not feeling a good expression of each character individually and there doesn’t seem to be as much of a climax as I’d like. Should I stop where I’m at and rewrite the entire scene, or push I through it, finish the draft and come back and see what needs to be fixed later?

Posted Mar 5, 2021, 3:49 PM UTC

112
FoxilyCreative•

Well it's very good you've identified what it is that's the problem as this will help you decide what to do next.

If one problem is that the characters aren't expressing themselves properly, it sounds like you may not yet have a full grasp of the individuality of the characters. You could either go back to the drawing board and really tidy up how individual dialogue and action creates these personalities, or you can skip over for now and finish the rest of the draft. By the time you've finished, you'd have spent more time with these characters and may have a better idea of their individuality.

For issues with the feeling of a climax, that points to issues earlier in the script. In this case, it may be best to go back and figure out what you can add to create more tension, what things you can add to create an uphill journey that's worthy of a climax.

In general when it comes to writing, it's best to remember what Jordan Peele said: "Follow the fun. If I'm not having fun, I'm doing it wrong." Whenever the block happens, find a way to bring the joy of writing back, whether that's skipping ahead to a different scene you want to write or pausing to see how you can make the current scene more entertaining to craft.

Good luck!

3
Written4tOP•

Thanks this helps a lot! I have most of my characters fleshed out but 1 supporting character. He seems to fall flat and as I’m writing it seems to bother me how he needs to fill the gap of what’s going on and that will bring a bit more of a “climax” to the moment. I’ve managed to get a page through today but I’m just making notes of what to revise when I come back.

2
FoxilyCreative•

Well congrats on working through it! It's a daunting piece of advice but to be honest one of the best things you could do is to let someone else read it. Another perspective may show you the small holes you've skirted over or give you insight into that character who isn't quite clicking

1
Professional-Tower76Action•

Finish it.

3
Written4tOP•

Right away boss!

1
dtlapgl•

I’d say think about how well you’ve established the obstacle with each characters storyline - that way once you get to the meet you have a very strong understanding of what needs to be accomplished. Sometimes going back and spending some time with each voice can be a difficult but rewarding process. Regardless, do what you can to finish the first draft. I usually spend 6 weeks writing a feature or 3 weeks writing a pilot all after outlines have been completed - then I run through rewrites with a different goal each time. Sometimes it’s punching up the dialogue / cutting the fat - strengthening voice of characters or simply making sure the sequence of events are smooth and meaningful. That being said - I could get blocked for weeks and it usually takes me finding the right music or playlist to bring me back.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Storylosopher•

Keep it. Make a note of it. Keep going! With a first draft, it's all about getting it DONE. :)

2
Written4tOP•

Thanks! I’m definitely going to do that. I’ve been pushing through the slog of it today and just writing notes on what I’ll do different on the next draft.

2
Storylosopher•

Good idea. Message me if you have more questions!

1
rainingfrogz•

Everyone has a different process and rewriting it right now might be yours.

But I’ve found that making a note and moving on to finish benefits me more. In the beginning, I’d always catch myself rewriting as I worked my way through the first draft, but it slowed me down so much. Starts with one scene, and next thing you know you’re fixing every page.

1
RandomStranger79•

Whatever gets you back to writing sooner.

1
[deleted]•

Second acts are difficult, so don't beat yourself up over this at all!

Let me ask a couple questions, and see if that helps shake something loose that'll help you move forward.

1.) Do you think the end of the second act is too late for your principal characters to be meeting each other for the first time?

2.) Typically, the end of the second act is the lowest point for the protagonist, and presents the strongest complication to your protagonist's goal. Is this the case with your scene? And if so, how will your heroes work their way out of it?

3.) Which character has the strongest desire? And which character is most formidable to them?

4.) What does your protagonist want more than anything? What is the reason they have yet to achieve it?

5.) What is something your protagonist thought they knew, but didn't? Perhaps this is what needs to be exposed on your second act out.

6.) Does the ending you currently have envisioned interfere with the execution of this scene? As in, does it feel like it's not leading to the ending you have in mind?

Obviously these questions are devoid of context, but I believe if you do your best at answering them, it might help you breakout from this brief rut. Hope this helps!

1