What is a very simple way to describe Quantum non-locality?

Hi everyone, I need a very simple way to describe this to someone who doesnt know much about quantum physics. Does what I write below cover it (I know its very basic but it needs to be). Please weigh in, and amend it if need be:

"When two particals meet and become lovers (entanglement), they will forever hold a connection. If one partical waves 'hello', then the other one - despite possibly being a million miles away, will return the gesture immediately. It therefore appears that information at this tiniest of levels can travel faster than light- an impossibility we dont yet fully understand."

Posted Mar 6, 2021, 10:44 PM UTC

08
funkyonion11•

I don't think I could improve on the comments you got above, but I just want to let you know Nicholas Brunner has a really sweet review article on the entire topic. It includes all the experimental stuff that's been done regarding nonlocality too(well at least up until about 2013 or so when I think it was published). It's really worth a read if you haven't already come across it.

2
Sentient-RobodogOP•

Thank you buddy I'll look into this

1
Ket_BrahGraduate•

Not really - even with entanglement, information does not travel faster than light, full stop. Entanglement is pretty well understood, so that's a very misleading way to describe it.

If two particles are entangled, it means they have a property that can only be described collectively. If their spin is entangled, you can only describe the net spin of the particles, not particles' individual spins. So, say you have two entangled particles with a net spin of zero. It's not that one particle is spin up and the other is spin down - the only property of one is that it is opposite the other. But, if we measure one of them and find spin-up, then because they must be opposites, we automatically also know the other one is spin-down.

1
Sentient-RobodogOP•

Thank you for the reply my friend.

So we have come a long way since Einstein I assume? He called it 'spooky action at a distance'?

Do I have this right...

You are monitoring a partical by Jupiter. I am monitoring a partical by the sun. They have both previously met each other and become entangled.

I see that mine in spinning up. So we know that yours is spinning down. You measure it, and sure enough, its spinning down.

But isnt it still strange how they know which way to spin in opposite ways instantaneously?

Please know I'm not trying to trip you up, I'm just trying to understand this and be able to describe it to someone else :)

1
HapankaaliCondensed matter physics•

So we have come a long way since Einstein I assume? He called it 'spooky action at a distance'?

Yes, the EPR paradox is considered resolved through Bell's theorem and the no-communication theorem.

3
Sentient-RobodogOP•

I will look into these, thank you

1
Ket_BrahGraduate•

No worries, it's very subtle!

It does seem strange to take it at face value that we know they will have opposite spin instantaneously, no matter how far away they are when the measurement is made. But the important thing is that this wasn't decided when we measured them! It was decided the moment they became entangled - from that point on, it is ordained that whatever one is measured to be, the other will be the opposite.

Also, lets say I measure my particle at Jupiter, and you measure yours at the sun, at the same time. If we didn't know the particles were entangled ahead of time, it would take at least as long as the light travel time to let each other know that we found their spins were opposites. If we did know they were entangled ahead of time, then we would have also already known they had to be opposites, before making a measurement at all!

1
Sentient-RobodogOP•

Thank you so much for your help

1