WeDoNotSow•

What happened to on-the-job training? What happened to entry-level positions?

14
ericanderton•

I was gonna say. The other side to this coin is that too many employers are unwilling to invest in the existing American labor pool.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
redenti•

public pressure that forces you into college has happened. everyone's a doctor or a master of something. the fact that universities should be purely to educate researchers was long lost in translation. i know many people who look down upon someone who has no doctor's decree. it's not an american problem. the other part of the problem is governments learning that they can hide much of their unemployed people in colleges... people in the usa are even worse off because it costs a ton of money there, iirc.

globalization has happened and it's taking a big bite out of everyone's self esteem and wallet. most people are big time losers in modern age globalization.

1
Euphemism•

Yepper, in the rush for everyone to be millionaire rock stars, we forgot that people still need plumbers, electricians, carpenters, etc.

Ideally, the very first thing every student should be taught as soon as they are done high school, before they go any further, is a trade. Any trade. That will allow them to always make a living. Then, after they have their trade, they can go on to whatever other post secondary education they wish.

3
rukkygOP•

Ironically, that would probably reduce the demand for such trades as everyone would know how to do the small stuff. But I like it anyway.

5
MrFlesh•

First those jobs have mostly been taken over by illegal immigrants pushing the wages to near minimium wage levels. Second it's more like people forgot that it was necessary to pay those postions a livable wage. Third if you look at other western nations that compete on the world stage (i.e. japan, germany and finland) they've subsidized secondary education. This directly relates to those countries leading the way per capita in technology.

There is so much more to this than some fucking sound bite. I started out as a mechanic but then I moved to LA so my wife could get in to her field.....mechanics live at poverty levels in LA unless they feel like driving from two hours outside of the city. Luckily internet technology has always been a hobby so I was able to switch fields.

We don't need more service jobs....thats what got us where we are today. We need more idea people, more highly trained people, more builders. Not more McJobs.

3
ericanderton•

If people were paying explicitly for unlicensed electricians and plumbers, I would agree. However, I'd be willing to bet that they're not.

My condolences for your woes at being a mechanic. I gather you're ASE certified? Out of curiosity, what does it take to further one's education to become a master mechanic at a dealership or someplace where the billable rate is higher? Would that close the gap, or is it no longer a living-wage at that level?

1
MrFlesh•

I was master ase certified ford technician at southern californias largest ford dealership. The thing with being a mechanic is that its commision based. Its tough finding a dealer that can even find you 40 hours worth of work a week. The problem is pay ceiling which is about 60 grand and will take you 10 15 years to hit. Sounds like a lot until you start thinking about buying a house....any place not in the ghetto near where i worked starts at 800k

3
ericanderton•

Thanks for replying!

That... sound pretty bogus for highly skilled labor like that. And with the cost of living out there? Yikes. Again, my condolences.

1
ivanmarsh•

In the immortal words of Ted Knight "The world needs ditch diggers too."

If a person can't make a living doing an average/unskilled job then there is a serious problem with our society and economy.

A janitor should be able to go home at night being proud of a job well done rather than having to wonder where their next meal is coming from. I certainly don't want to scrub the public toilets.

3
[deleted]•

I call Bullshit. There is nothing on wages in that article. If demand for some kinds of labor is high and supply is low wages in some industries should rise. They ignore this effect entirely.

1
[deleted]•
1
[deleted]•

Meh, my cousins in Croatia live with their parents until the age of 30 and take 8 years to finish college. At the end of the day, Americans are really hard workers with a hard work ethic.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Stercrazy•

Growing up, my father taught me how to do basic plumbing, basic electrician work, and basic auto mechanics. My fiance, born just six years after me, had never even opened the hood on her car or taken the lid off the tank of her toilet. Her cousins, all about the same age, never had either. I think that somewhere in the last 30 years, most parents have raised their kids with the idea that they shouldn't learn trade skills because there will always be someone to do such "menial" tasks.

I think that there's been a large slide in this country away from trade skills, because there's a cultural stigma that such jobs are "for poor people". Never mind that I know many skilled tradesmen who clear upwards of $75k to $100k a year. Until people start coming to grips with the idea that there's nothing wrong with their kids growing up to be something other than tech professionals, then this will probably remain a problem.

1
Tigerantilles•

That's pretty much a good chunk of the problem in a nutshell.

1
MrFlesh•

Sure they can by realizing we have a consumer economy. Which means it isn't business that needs the money it's the people. But don't give them cold hard cash address the problems......

The now full disclosed 16 trillion dollar bailout should have gone to the people. It could have paid off every first mortgage and student loan in the country. What does this do? It frees up thousands of dollars per house hold as disposable income. Oh look consumers are buying again, which means business's need to hire again, which means it's an employees market, which means wages go up, which means higher standard of living...........

A rising tide does lift all boats. But the water isn't made of business, it's made of people.

-1
Zgoos•

That would have been just as unfair and messed up as the bank bailout. You didn't buy an overpriced home expecting to flip it and instead rented an apartment you could afford? Screw you. You worked hard and got a scholarship for college or you paid off your student loans by living below your means and saving? Screw you too. Why replace one messed up situation with another?

7
[deleted]•

One is about giving people a second chance, something that does not mean a third will come. Second, if you have all those things like scholarships and a well budgeted mortgage, you have secondary benefits anyway.

It's not about yelling, "Screw you! I got mine!" Louder than everybody else, it's about getting ahead. If you do that by kicking sand in the faces of everybody around you, you're an asshole. If you get ahead and then help other people move forward, you're an awesome human being. If you get ahead and do neither, you're normal. You're proposing the first.

1
Zgoos•

My point is that it is completely unfair to use the taxes of people who behaved responsibly to bail out those who were irresponsible. That's true if we're bailing out people who got mortgages they couldn't afford or bankers who sold them those mortgages. The responsible people are the ones getting screwed.

4
[deleted]•

Yes, bailing out either institution was unfair, but life isn't fair. What we have to deal with now is how we're going to distribute the unfair advantage.

-2
[deleted]•

The problem is our businesses keep on getting more efficient and that requires quality employees. The current market for potential employees is saturated with people that just never really got good at anything of value, now these people can't find anything to do and somehow that's the governments problem? That's the businesses problem?

People have to take responsibility for themselves. No one else can. You get paid what you are worth. If no one is paying you, you aren't worth anything. Either make yourself valuable or starve.

2
bornagain_whackjob•

People have to take responsibility for themselves. No one else can. You get paid what you are worth. If no one is paying you, you aren't worth anything. Either make yourself valuable or starve.

Can I get an AMEN!

1
MrFlesh•

There are two things going on here. First...most "valueless" skills are not valueless the industries that involve those skills are simply highly competitive. There are simply more losers in these fields than there are in say computer technology or banking. Think this just applies to film, music and fashion? Nope it also includes skills like archeology, architecture, and most research based skills. 70% of those that graduate college do not get a job in their field. It has nothing to do with the value of their skills that's just how competitive the market is.

Second as an economy rises and falls in size and complexity the ability for luxuries and disposable income expands and shrinks. The more money you have for luxuries the more of a market there is for "valueless" skills. If the majority of the U.S. population wasn't living at just above poverty levels there would be more of a market for car custom shops, artists, and play wrights.

The answer isn't to turn out a population like that of india or soviet russia where everyone is a programmer but no one is a designer, but to give the population a way for skills to be easier to obtain and of course a real wage.

1
[deleted]•

It's the truth.

But people still want to blame the rich for their shortcomings.

-1