r/lgbt•
SilentAgony

My official statement on the Halloween costume which aroused so much discussion.

An apology has been demanded of me - ad nauseum, and I've refused it. Allow me to explain myself.

Some background: For Halloween, I dressed as a man dressed as a woman. The people in my immediate circle thought this was the most hysterical Halloween costume ever concocted; the vast majority of the trans population of r/lgbt disagreed.

The (vocal, irritated) trans population's side of the story is that I looked like a dude in a dress, which is a stereotype negatively associated with the trans community.

While I can understand this, I felt that this was an intentional misinterpretation. The reason I felt this was an intentional (as opposed to unintentional) misinterpretation is that all my explanations were downvoted off the page, so that very few people probably ever read them.

My side of the story is as follows: I am a genderqueer lesbian. My girlfriend is also genderqueer and although biologically male, identifies as my lesbian girlfriend. I am a very masculine person. I wear typically masculine clothes and have typically masculine features (my haircut, mannerisms, etc). People around me typically refer to me with male terms "(SilentAgony) is one of the boys" or referring to me by my last name instead of my first to avoid female labelling, etc. My transvestism is generally ignored or disregarded as less than transvestism because, generally speaking, MtF transvestism is taken as transvestism and FtM transvestism as taken as "oh cute what a tomboy." I tend to get quite defensive on this subject. I am a feminist and a queer theorist. I do hope you can see where I'm going with this.

My costume on Halloween was intended as a parody of myself, a genderqueer, oft interpreted as male lesbian. People in my circle often joke that when I dress in girl clothes, that is transvestism. Putting aside the obvious MtF-is-serious, FtM-is-a-promotion implications, I thought I'd make a joke of it for Halloween.

I was told over and over that I couldn't possibly be seen as a transvestite because I wasn't exaggerating femininity. I was wearing blue eyeshadow up to my eyebrows, borrowed bright pink lipstick from my girlfriend, and a bright pink boa (not pictured due to itchiness). I don't know any women, trans or cis, who dress this way, so I thought it was exaggerated enough, but apparently not.

I have a lot of gender variant friends, and I discussed the issue with them once my temper cooled a bit. The general consensus was "in context, it makes sense, out of context, it doesn't." I understand that I did not post the picture of myself in my costume with context. I should have, and I'm sorry I didn't, but that's the only apology I will issue.

I maintain the right to parody myself and my double, triple, quadruple gender mishmash dragception to the death. And I'll defend yours too... or your lack thereof.

I am your moderator. I will remove threats and personal information. I will update the logo sometimes for funsies. I am not an LGBT leader nor am I an LGBT spokesperson, unless and until and only in contexts in which you wish me to be. I love this community.

Sincerely,

SilentAgony

Posted Nov 5, 2011, 6:28 AM UTC · edited

45109
backpackwayne•

First I've heard of this but I can basically say that it's fucking Halloween. We are supposed to dress up. Sounds like a great costume to me. So if anyone wants to bitch..., let 'em. Definitely sounds better than some tired old dude dressing like a woman. My god I don't see what the problem is.

In any case the way I look at things is if you didn't piss someone off..., you didn't do it right.

30
zomboi•

ditto everything you said.

First I (a genderqueer/ftm) am hearing about this, sounds like a great costume.

7
1exi•

Transgender people in the LGBT community often feel maligned by their own supposed allies, It can really embitter some people and they will just see everything as an attack, from ignorant misgendering to out-of-context Halloween costumes.

25
ocinleLost in his own eyes.•

It's exacerbated by the fact that there isn't always a clear consensus on trans issues. In all queer areas, there's a clear discord between the gender-binary-affirming camp and the gender-binary-disolving camp, but it's amplified in trans space. The effect of course is that any sentiment will probably offend someone.

Heck, even this Halloween costume fiasco can be interpreted in the binary-affirming vs binary-dissolving context. SilentAgony thinks gender is not a worthy construction, and should be generally fucked with. Others, however, see this as an attack on those who do wish to plant themselves firmly in the gender space.

12
ocinleLost in his own eyes.•

The trans-related subreddits are such a mixed bag. There are a ton of really patient and intelligent subscribers, but there are plenty others who are just mean.

I had an experience a while back where I said something in r/transgender that could be interpreted in multiple ways and also made it clear that I'm cis. It started a small war between those who interpreted my comment as I intended it and those who thought I was the scum of the earth. (I decided not to comment further because I wanted to carefully hear everyone out.) The worst were the long comments lecturing me about privilege and whatnot; it was frankly condescending. The whole thing nearly had me in tears at the possibility that some people were hurt by what I said. If not for a few very encouraging PMs, I probably would have unsubscribed.

EDIT: and so begins a predictable downvoting

5
[deleted]•

I'm trans and i'm with you. I'm getting so sick and tired of being lectured by fellow trans redditors about privilege and how we should all feel attacked every second of every day. It's a sickening cycle of self-victimization that does nothing to help our situation.

I pretty much tune out at any of the following words, since they're used as buzzwords for any situation and their definition is twisted to match whatever the poster decides it means: "Cissexist" "Classism" "Privilege" "Tone Argument" "Marginalized" etc...

It seems like 99% of transwomen I've met on the internet are incredibly insecure people who obsess about political correctness and victimization, and forget how to live their lives. Causing drama and perpetuating it pushes away sane people, fucking stop it, ladies.

5
moonflower•

I think some people are too easily guilt-tripped by the nasty little gang who rule those subreddits ... I briefly visited r/asktransgender and found them in the middle of a Two Minutes Hate session ... I had never even heard of the object of their hate and it was intense to watch, so I made a comment and asked a few questions, and was attacked for not automatically joining in the hatefest without good reason ... by the end of the day I was banned from the subreddit, branded a troll

I maintain that I didn't do anything wrong

1
TraumaPonyhai =^-^=•

Maybe because you're cissexist as fuck?

-8
[deleted]•

ಠ_ಠ

3
moonflower•

I don't really know what that means, all I know is it is a word which a small group made up to insult people, it's not even in the dictionary

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Strawberri•

It's hard for the rest of to comprehend a hysterical, inarticulate victim mentality.

13
iamelbenLaughter, Comedy, Sharing•

I wish I could kiss you for this. Right on the mouth. Seriously. I'm tired of the butthurtness.

1
uragaaruHarmony•

While I can understand this, I felt that this was an intentional misinterpretation. The reason I felt this was an intentional (as opposed to unintentional) misinterpretation is that all my explanations were downvoted off the page, so that very few people probably ever read them.

With the context you've provided, I could sort of see how this costume could make sense as an inside joke about performativity, but referring to the larger community on reddit's reaction as an "intentional misinterpretation" is inaccurate at best, condescension at worst. And furthermore, assuming that a funny inside joke would translate to a large online community sans context is the height of cliquish hubris that is all too common in queer spaces online and in RL.

Forgive me if I'm "misinterpreting" the rationale for this post, since I thought the matter was mostly settled with the thread dying down, but you do understand why dressing up as a guy with a five o'clock shadow in a grandma dress and outlandish makeup (especially with no context) would raise the ire of trans women who basically get shoved that image in their brains by the culture at large so much that a good deal of us have serious self-esteem and social interaction issues because of our fear of appearing to be that costume, yes? And that, especially without context being prominently included, all we have to go on is the rhetoric inherent in the image, which sadly, doesn't include said context? This isn't just to soothe a wounded ego, yes? As the saw goes, intent isn't fucking magic.

I have more to say, but at this point it's degenerating into mishmash, so nevermind. Halloween is over. Who cares, amirite?

18
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

a grandma dress

It's a friend's party dress. This is part of the intentional misinterpretation I'm talking about.

and outlandish makeup

I was criticized in the original thread for the makeup not being outlandish, again...

-5
LGBTerrific•

I am your moderator. I will remove threats and personal information. I will update the logo sometimes for funsies. I am not an LGBT leader nor am I an LGBT spokesperson, unless and until and only in contexts in which you wish me to be. I love this community.

As a mod of a few other communities, I can verify that mods are merely humans like the rest of you human mortal redditors. We basically just check the spam filter. Oh, and update the logo for funsies.

15
Neemii•

The way that I feel like this is very similar to the way I feel about ftm / genderqueer people reclaiming the word "tranny".

As the author of this article put much better than I could:

"Trans men can access both queer men’s and women’s spaces. Trans women are often barred from both with accusations of being “cross dressers,” “predatory men in dresses,” and “transvestic fetishists.” I have heard self-styled queer radicals accuse trans women who are demure of exhibiting “patriarchal femininity” while casting trans women who are opinionated and speak up as “brassy drag queens” acting from “male privilege.” It’s the same double bind that feminism decries when applied to cis women."

"anyone wishing to nastily insinuate a failure of femininity can hurl the T-word at pretty much any woman, but the real recipient of the insult will always be the trans female community."

This is what your costume is doing. Despite your personal context making sense in just that - your personal life - in the outside world it looks just like any other costume of someone percieved to be masculine "faking" femininity.

11
Neemii•

As well, I think that it's pretty sad that you refuse to apologize. Regardless of your intentions and your context, people were offended. The polite thing to do is to apologize for offending them, even if you didn't intend to do it.

If I did something that unintentionally bothered, irritated, or enraged someone, I would feel sorry for it. Even if I felt that I was in the right, I would still at the very least apologize for giving someone the wrong impression of my actions.

Of course you have your right to dress as whatever you want, including a harmful parody of those who were assigned male who prefer a more feminine presentation. But I do think you should have clarified in advance the context, and even then it is still someone from a position of priviledge 'reclaiming' something they have no right to.

11
Shamwow22•

Her costume was a parody of drag queens, not of transgendered people. Drag queens will be the first to tell you that:

A) They have a great sense of humor about what they do, and:

B) They are NOT transgendered.

Drag queens - like RuPaul, for example - are cisgendered and have no desire to transition into the opposite sex, or to "pass" as the opposite sex while in drag; it's comedy and performance art, not a gender identity. In reality, they actually DO identify as a "man in a dress", whereas transwomen obviously do not.

Furthermore, rmuser, who is the creator and co-moderator of this subreddit - as well as SA's girlfriend, is a TRANS WOMAN, and she apparently wasn't offended by SA's Halloween costume. So, I hope that everyone who is offended by her costume idea can see that this is a misunderstanding, and that she really doesn't deserve to be the target of any sort of hatred and infamy.

tl;dr Relax. Don't do it.

10
alsoathrowaway•

Okay, but, you know, not to get into this argument again or anything, the costume didn't say "drag queen" at all - the stereotypical drag queen (and of course bear in mind that that's what non-character-specific-costumes do, is to draw on and play off stereotypes and tropes regarding their subject) would not, for example, have beard shadow or an obviously-stuffed-with-kleenex bra. Now, yes, these things were necessary markers for understanding what SilentAgony was trying to do in context (especially because the rest of the costume wasn't anywhere near over-the-top enough to scream "drag queen"), that goes back to the in-context-vs.-out-of-context thing that she discussed.

I suppose it's a little bit like if Barack Obama had put together an exaggerated blackface costume. Knowing that the guy is himself black, and knowing that he occasionally got shit in 2008 for "not being black enough" (didn't he? I'd swear I remember that happening some), okay, that'd be a kind of funny costume. But if you saw a picture of him and didn't know any of that context, and especially if you were an African American individual yourself, it would probably be pretty offensive.

12
Shamwow22•

the stereotypical drag queen [...] would not, for example, have beard shadow or an obviously-stuffed-with-kleenex bra.

Do you know what the word "parody" means?

par·o·dy/ˈparədē/ Verb: Produce a humorously exaggerated imitation of (a writer, artist, or genre). Noun: An imitation of the style of a particular writer, artist, or genre with deliberate exaggeration for comic effect. Synonyms: verb. travesty - mimic - burlesque - mock noun. travesty - skit - burlesque - spoof - mockery - send-up

The costume wasn't supposed to be a real drag queen; it was supposed to be a parody of a drag queen. Whether or not you personally find it funny is irrelevant; it's about the intent. The costume wasn't about transgendered people at all.

She also said she was wearing a pink boa that night. Do any of the transwomen on Reddit usually wear those around the house, or at work? I don't think so.

5
alsoathrowaway•

Again, aside from the not-present-in-the-photograph boa, there were no "drag queen" markers. And as I had thought I made clear, I understand the intent, but in point of fact the intent is not the only relevant factor. (Nor is it irrelevant, either.)

The costume wasn't about transgendered people, but it's very easy to see how it came across that way.

7
lifeinneonDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

But her parody of a drag queen came off looking exactly like a caricature of the "pathetic transsexual" stereotype.

3
yourdadsbffgaysha gown•

Whoa whoa whoa....rmuser and SilentAgony are together?? We're run by a power couple?

I don't know why I didn't know this before. Huh. TIL.

9
moonflower•

except that rmuser isn't a trans woman, he is a male who enjoys dressing up, so of course he wouldn't be offended, because he is not trying to be a woman, he is more of a drag queen

-11
zomboi•

actually SilentAgony (not rmuser) defines herself as:

I am a genderqueer lesbian. My girlfriend is also genderqueer and although biologically male, identifies as my lesbian girlfriend. I am a very masculine person.

She identifies as a female, not male and is dating a trans woman.

10
moonflower•

except he calls himself male and sneers at people who say he is confused about what gender he is ... I think he is trolling the whole lot of you when he says he is a lesbian ... he is more like a bisexual transvestite

-5
zomboi•

except he calls himself male and sneers at people who say he is confused about what gender he is

Where does she say that? I perused the first page of her comments/posts and they go along with her being female and lesbian.

1
Roombafollower•

Awkward.... Sorry there was so much backlash, we didn't know the whole story and jumped to conclusions and that was wrong. I sincerely apologize.

9
[deleted]•

I'm on your side but saying sorry doesn't mean youre wrong... your costume was really triggering for some people- because your costume is what they might see in the mirror (even if they don't really look like that)

I think the people who where angry at you weren't being understanding enough, and honestly I don't think you're being understanding enough either.

it never would have been a big deal if you just said something like "I'm sorry, my costume is of a cross dressing guy, and I didn't think of how it could be triggering to some people, I'm a trans ally, I was just playing with gender and I'm sorry"

Again, I'm on your side- I like the costume especially now knowing the context of why you made it... but refusing to apologize is kinda shitty. but whatever, in the end I don't care.

8
[deleted]•

I should have, and I'm sorry I didn't, but that's the only apology I will issue.

sigh Would have been nice if you weren't so confrontational to people who were upset about it. I realise you feel like you were being bullied but a lot of people ended up more upset at your reaction than at the costume.

I'm getting dangerously close to a tone-argument so I'll shut the hell up now.

6
lifeinneonDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

Re: Tone Argument, the "tone argument" is "You're speaking in harsh words and therefore your opinion is wrong." or "therefore I don't have to listen to you."

But if you are saying, "You are speaking in harsh words and those harsh words are themselves a tactic of bullying or intimidation", or "those harsh words are making you sound like an ass", that's not really a tone argument. That's just pointing out someone is being needlessly mean and it makes them tiresome to talk to in general.

I encounter this in both trans circles and feminist circles: (Not saying SA did this specifically, mind you) people adopt viciously combative postures and then wonder why those around them find them tedious, even if they're right. They're quick to lob "tone argument" even at allies and friends who are just asking them to stop taking their (perfectly justified) anger out on them.

6
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

Indeed this is very much "you should take our angry downvote brigade in stride." The answer, I'm afraid, is "no."

-8
[deleted]•

Rightey-o then, I was giving you the benefit of the doubt but it seems you really are reacting as badly as r/transphobiaproject was to this. FYI I'm not part of any "downvote brigade", I do my best to educate the ignorant (when I feel I'm not going to get overly emotional about it, but hey I'm only human) or mock the heck out of the stubbornly bigoted. I actually tend to upvote so others can perhaps learn.

-2
rmuserLiterally a teddy bear•

reacting as badly as r/transphobiaproject was to this

How exactly does that work? If their reaction was as problematic as you say, then it's hard to see how the response to that improper reaction could itself be equally bad. If people want to avoid courting harsh replies, then they might want to stop pestering people for no reason.

7
JRutterbush•

I'm with nyoro; side A overreacted to a misunderstanding, and side B overreacted to the overreaction. The fact that side A overreacted first doesn't mean side B wasn't also overreacting.

However, I don't really see that anybody's actually in the wrong here, so much as people had a misunderstanding... as people are incredibly prone to do. I don't think that anybody really thinks SilentAgony doesn't care about the feelings of others, but being dismissive of your "opponent" is a very common defensive response. And I know everybody knows how often and viciously trans people are mocked, so it's understandable that some, seeing a costume taken out of context, might have assumed the worst. I don't think there's any blame here, just a lot of people who are so used to being attacked by the rest of the world that they (both sides) are a little quick to respond to any percieved attack.

7
[deleted]•

If people want to avoid courting harsh replies, then they might want to stop pestering people for no reason.

It wasn't for no reason darn it, that's what SilentAgony has apologised for, the initial misunderstanding. Or am I putting words in her mouth? Fuck, I don't know anymore.

4
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

I rather enjoy SRS myself, in fact I invented my own creative flair for it. Whether you're a part of the downvote brigade or not is frankly irrelevant. The fact is, I don't feel any obligation to respond to an angry mob with profuse apology or self-deprecation.

I realise you feel like you were being bullied but a lot of people ended up more upset at your reaction than at the costume

If the costume wasn't a problem, then their reactions were unwarranted. If their reactions were unwarranted, my upset, defensive responses were warranted.

0
[deleted]•

Jesus Christ people, stop downvoting her. I'm trying to have a discussion here and you aren't helping.

Anyway, there was a misunderstanding about the costume, you have apologised for that, people were upset when they had that initial misunderstanding but you were dismissive to begin with then quite hostile. Both sides were wrong in the way they reacted, you could have come out the better person here but you've brought yourself down to their level.

At least you have apologised for something though, more than what certain others have done.

1
runpmc•

While I can understand this, I felt that this was an intentional misinterpretation. The reason I felt this was an intentional (as opposed to unintentional) misinterpretation is that all my explanations were downvoted off the page, so that very few people probably ever read them.

Welcome to the dark side of r/LGBT. I love this subreddit, but this tendency runs rampant here, and I find it endlessly frustrating.

There's a creepy hierarchy game being played by many members here, and the fact that it's been focused on a moderator is telling. r/LGBT doesn't much feel like the safe, welcoming space it was intended to be when people start witchhunting like this.

5
[deleted]•

I wish you would have said this in the first place instead of saying you were a drag queen and getting immediately defensive and hostile to anyone who took this as offensive. Now you have decided to garner sympathy after the initial backlash died down.

Here is my official statement: I don't care about your costume or that you are a genderqueer, transvestite (btw transvestite is an archaic and offensive term), activist, supporter, lesbian. I care that you are a moderator and had a horrible attitude. When the transgender community in LGBT(transgender) said you offended us, you should have apologized, said it was not meant as offensive and move on. You do not call people idiots and accuse them of threats then threaten to ban them.

That being said your costume was taken as offensive due to the poor use of makeup for facial and chest hair and stuffed bra in a bad dress. Regardless of your intent, putting it up here was a poor decision and I still think you should just apologize and move on instead of changing your story to make yourself out to be the victim.

4
Gemini6Ice•

Please explain why is offensive to transgendereds for someone to dress up as a drag queen, which is a different arena entirely?

3
smischmalshe-wizard•

'Transgendereds' is a funny word because you are taking an adjective and turning it into a past tense verb and then taking that and making it a plural noun.

6
[deleted]•

This whole issue has nothing to do with drag queens or people dressing in drag.

5
[deleted]•

I'm really miffed that she's using the "I'm genderqueer, it's not offensive" excuse. I'm actually genderqueer and I found it offensive, thank you very much.

Honestly, this put the nail in the coffin for me. r/lgbt simply isn't a safe place anymore. That's been increasingly evident. The fact people IN THIS THREAD have the attitude "hurr durr crazy angry t[]" is honestly quite revealing.

2
handmademannequin•

YOU'RE actually genderqueer? Are you implying the OP isn't, even though they identified themselves as genderqueer? Who are you, to assume and label someone's gender identity?

1
[deleted]•

You're assuming that's precisely what I meant instead of getting miffed that another genderqueer person is saying "It's fine guys." Because I'm actually genderqueer myself and find defending it by bringing up one's identity as repulsive.

Getting angry at me because my blood sugar is low and I'm not entirely lucid is pretty unfair.

You're taking it to mean I'm doubting their identity when I mean that I'm genderqueer as well. Their identity doesn't excuse transmisogyny.

5
handmademannequin•

I wasn't agreeing with the OP or taking their side. I didn't even know what this was about, as I missed the drama, but your comment struck me as something a genderqueer, gender equality enthusiast wouldn't say. When you say "I'm actually genderqueer" it sounds like "They're not, but I am, so my opinion means more." Its like a white person, making a racist joke, and me, another white person, saying its offensive; a person of colour can say "I'm actually a victim of racism and I find that offensive" Their opinion is more valid because it actually pertains to them, not the privileged white person (me). Hopefully that analogy makes sense. Instead of "actually" you could have used "also," "as well," etc.

Getting accusatory and huffy at me because you have low blood sugar (which I didn't know in the first place, because this is the internet and I have no idea who you are or your previous medical conditions) is pretty unfair. My partner has problems with their blood sugar so I completely understand the issue, but how was I supposed to know that?

I never said their identity excuses transmisogyny. Nothing ever does.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

It is a safe place but we do have some dykes and faggots who have an issue with life in general.

Yeah that's right I used these two terms since it seems to be ok now to throw around offensive terms like pansy ass pillow biting pussy faggot. Or dog faced dyke carpet muncher.

-4
[deleted]•

It is a safe place

All evidence is to the contrary. This is only a symptom of a larger problem.

0
[deleted]•

The comments of misguided and uneducated youth does not make a place inherently unsafe. The sub is ruled by dykes and dykes hate trannies plain and simple.

-4
profanusnothusSocial Justice, Loudly Demanding Equality•

Or maybe you should lighten the fuck up.

-7
[deleted]•

How so? I should be called an idiot, lied to about threats and accept being threatened to be banned? Please explain to me how I should lighten the fuck up?

Mind telling me what I did to you directly to get a response like this?

3
profanusnothusSocial Justice, Loudly Demanding Equality•

She posted a photo of herself in a Halloween costume. A HALLOWEEN COSTUME. You and your ultra-P.C. angsty whiny downvote brigade jumped down her throat en masse and made her feel like shit for dressing up for Halloween. That pisses me off. This kind of behavior makes people feel like they can't express themselves how they want, or say what they want, even if it's in jest, for fear of a band of stuck-up jackasses attacking them for having a good time. My coworker dressed up as a stereotypical nerd for Halloween. Should I jump on his case because, as a kid, I got the ever-living shit beat out of me for being a nerd? How dare he marginalize a group of people and make fun of them! No. I'm a fucking adult and know the difference between a joke and serious discrimination. Chill the fuck out.

-3
[deleted]•

Settle down, she was hostile. Yes, I didn't like a costume that was in poor taste and put on a subreddit that should know better. This was solved so thanks but I am not going into it again.

The issue was her attitude, not a tacky costume.

0
dshigure•

The (vocal, irritated) trans population's side of the story is that I looked like a dude in a dress, which is a stereotype negatively associated with the trans community.

I am happy that you are understanding of at least this much.

While I can understand this, I felt that this was an intentional misinterpretation

I am not going to derail my comment by picking this apart. I will simply state that I disagree, and leave it at that.

My transvestism is generally ignored or disregarded as less than transvestism because, generally speaking, MtF transvestism is taken as transvestism and FtM transvestism as taken as "oh cute what a tomboy." I tend to get quite defensive on this subject. I am a feminist and a queer theorist. I do hope you can see where I'm going with this.

I want to point out that I am sympathetic with you in this regard. Even within queer circles, the double standards placed on gender expression suck.

My costume on Halloween was intended as a parody of myself, a genderqueer, oft interpreted as male lesbian

This was confusing, given that you said "drag queen". Your circle of friends might have understood, but I didn't have the context.

Putting aside the obvious MtF-is-serious, FtM-is-a-promotion implications, I thought I'd make a joke of it for Halloween.

As a person who spoke out against you in the original discussion, I will concede that this excuses your costume. However this was a context you had to the costume that the people who were seeing the picture lacked. On its face, your picture offended a lot of people, and you were quick to dismiss them all. That is what I personally find bothersome, but again, this is just me.

I have a lot of gender variant friends, and I discussed the issue with them once my temper cooled a bit. The general consensus was "in context, it makes sense, out of context, it doesn't."

I'm glad that they're on the same page.

I understand that I did not post the picture of myself in my costume with context. I should have, and I'm sorry I didn't, but that's the only apology I will issue.

I'm not going to ask for more apology at this point. All I would ask of you is to feel free to dismiss a small fringe who gets offended at you, but if you manage to offend a large chunk of your audience, you should double-check before blaming them. This is not a trans issue, it's the responsible thing to do when offending any large group, or demographic.

I maintain the right to parody myself and my double, triple, quadruple gender mishmash dragception to the death. And I'll defend yours too... or your lack thereof.

Totes! But if you show it to me, I maintain the right to respond to it with how I feel about it.

I am your moderator. I will remove threats and personal information. I will update the logo sometimes for funsies. I am not an LGBT leader nor am I an LGBT spokesperson, unless and until and only in contexts in which you wish me to be. I love this community.

Ok, ok, I'll vote for you come re-election. But mainly because the other party is such a group of assholes :-)

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

You've really been nicer than almost everyone who has taken your position, so I want you to know that the only reason I'm responding to you and not anyone else who has said the same thing is only because I've now had this in my head for a couple of days and you just happen to be the most recent person to make this comment.

The general consensus here seems to be that, in context, what I did isn't really offensive at all. I did apologize for posting it without context. What followed is that a lot of people are insisting I apologize because they were offended by something that now seems harmless, just because they were offended. Demanding that I apologize for something that I really didn't do is quite selfish and entitled, and as a rule, I don't apologize to people just because they didn't like something I did.

I'm a genderqueer lesbian feminist, and as such, I offend people all the time. If I apologized to r/mensrights every time I offended them, I'd be doing nothing but apologizing all day. In fact I think most people here would think it would be asinine to expect me to apologize for defending gay rights or feminism, but people on the other side of these things are often just as offended as you are now. Part of being an activist and a part of a marginalized group (perhaps a different marginalized group than yours, but marginalized nonetheless) is standing your ground and outright refusing when people start demanding you apologize for yourself.

In context, which is now public, my costume was not just a parody of myself but meant to poke fun at people who don't see me as genderqueer or a crossdresser because these identities are the sole property of the assigned male at birth. I will continue to highlight these things, make an example of myself, and parody myself without apologizing for it.

-5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Beigenoise•

Here's my official statement on the matter:

If you can't see that you genuinely hurt people, and do not feel remorse for having done so, you are an awful human being, ALL gender concerns aside. Your apology is an apology to yourself, and a smack in the face of those you hurt.

For shame.

1
profanusnothusSocial Justice, Loudly Demanding Equality•

If a picture hurt you, you need to get the fuck off the internet.

-9
dual-moonA geek, a girl, and trans, respectively.•

This is the exact same bullshit argument used to marginalize gay people being hurt by all the things that marginalize them. Fuck off.

14
profanusnothusSocial Justice, Loudly Demanding Equality•

No, laws and institutionalized discrimination marginalize a people. Jokes do not. A comedian telling black/jew/asian/gay/whatever jokes doesn't marginalize those people. They are jokes. This was a fucking halloween costume. A joke. You are making a controversy for the simple fact of having something to bitch about. People like you make everyone feel like they have to walk on eggshells and make them afraid to express themselves or speak freely. Fuck you.

-5
dual-moonA geek, a girl, and trans, respectively.•

No, fuck you.

I have every fucking right to be offended. I don't bitch just to bitch, but this fucking offended me. I don't give a shit if you think that's wrong or not. You can take your holier-than-thou self-righteous bullshit and shove it for all I care. You can pretend that people making jokes doesn't marginalize, but it does. You can't make something disappear just because you want to. It is marginalization whether you like it or not. Express yourself, who the fuck cares? When that expression is made at the expense of someone else then a line has been crossed. "An it harm none, do what thou wilt." Well guess what; I, amongst others, were harmed by someone who was supposed to be our friend, our ally. When we expressed our hurt, she told us all to fuck ourselves. That is wrong. Not just for a moderator of this entire subreddit, who should be making herself to be a fucking example for others, but for any person. We deserve a rightful apology, not excuses. We won't get it, I know that. SilentAgony has proven to be uncaring. That's fine, it just means that even more people will have to avoid this subreddit. But you have no fucking right to act like I'm not allowed to have concerns.

2
stopthefate•

Chill. Seriously, you don't need to defend yourself. The fault lied with those taking offense where they shouldn't have because YOU DID NOTHING WRONG. Some people in the LGBT community are overly-sensitive about these issues and see everything as an attack because our society jokes around wit the "other gender" all the time, which can be confusing to someone who's gender comes into question or doesn't match their sex. But seriously, I'm glad that you defended your side and didn't needlessly apologize, as that would have reinforced the idea that you were somehow at fault for dressing up for Halloween.

1
wecaan•

lgbt user #1: says something lgbt user#2: OMG I am offended! lgbt user#3: what? What? You're offended? I am offended that your offended because I am 100% lgbt and you're just part time.

why don't you people find something useful to do, instead of turning on each other. So much angst.

1
m0llusk•

If you had gone nude then they would still be upset. There is no pleasing some people.

0

Are we still fighting over this? Geese, give the girl a break already.

-1
[deleted]•

and if anyone gives her shit on #reddit-trans they have to answer to me.

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

<3

0