r/dndnext•
_Wraith

What races would not be present on a world disconnected from the planes?

I'm working on a campaign world/setting and one of the unique aspects I've decided on is that it is, currently, disconnected from any other planes a few thousand years ago. This will have various effects on the world, but what I'm deciding on now is what races may not be present in a world with no connections to other planes. (Purely for lore reasons; no balancing reasons behind any of this)

The races I've already picked out are Aasimar, Tieflings, and Genasi as they seem the most obvious to me. So really just looking to see if anyone has any other thoughts on ones that might not exist, and why?

Posted Mar 9, 2021, 5:25 PM UTC · edited

1235
Winged-Angel•

Centaurs, Satyrs, Eladrin Elves and Shadar-Kai Elves wouldn't exist in that world either.

Centaurs and Satyrs are both fey, similarly, Eladrin come from the Feywild, and Shadar-Kai come from the Shadowfell

20

All elves, really. They originated from the Feywild

5
Winged-Angel•

Yeah, but we don't know when the split took place, so it's likely that Elves in general are there, but not the Eladrin that stayed in the Feywild, and not the Shadar-Kai that the Raven Queen brought to the Shadowfell

10

Yeah, I had to read the other comments. Yours was top. Seems it was cleared up below

3
LUV2FRAGU•

Elves have fey ancestry so they wouldn’t be there depending on if the world was ever connected to the other planes or not

7
_WraithOP•

Elves, at least the basic ones, may exist. The full lore is that the world was connected to the planes, but became disconnected a few thousand years ago. So, with the longevity of Elves, I could see some of them existing. Maybe.

Definitely something worth considering though! I'd somehow forgotten that Elves originated from the Fey. Thanks!

5
LUV2FRAGU•

Fair enough. Some others would be aarakocra and tritons as well

7
ASharpYoungManBladeling Fighter/Warlock•

Would be interesting if their fey ancestry was starting to fade away... Perhaps some elves are starting to lose their fey ancestry and trance features but are gaining others in their place?

Perhaps some kind of attunement to the world itself? The old 2nd Ed elven handbook had a feature called Manifesting, which allows elves to seem larger and more imposing - simmilar to Movie Gandalf proclaiming that he was not a conjurer of cheap tricks. Maybe something like that?

5
_WraithOP•

That is an interesting idea! I might have to consider that for some of the races!

3
The_Ginger-Beard•

Eladrin wouldn't... although Aasamir and Teifling might still

2
steadysoulCleric•

Tiefling definitely would unless they were prevented from breeding

1
epicazeroth•

In most D&D settings, Elves immigrated to the Material Plane from the Feywild a few thousand years ago. You could have Elves but no Eladrin.

2
KyokaSuigetsu94•

Kalastar and Gith ?

7
_WraithOP•

I'd completely forgotten about those 2. Thanks!

3
Saelas•

It depends if it was allways disconnected or it happened sometime later, because if i am not mistaken elves are from the feywild and orcs and goblin are too someplace else. (I may and probably am very wrong here, not sure)

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
epicazeroth•

I know this isn't really the question you asked, but what effect will this have on game balance? Are Warlocks' Patrons, Clerics' Gods, and Sorcerers' bloodline ancestors not going to be able to reach the Material Plane?

7
_WraithOP•

The general lore is that at some point in the distant past, a pact of "non-interference" was signed by the various leaders of the external planes that caused this world to be shut off from the rest.

So, there will still be Clerical divine powers, they'll just be praying to ideas rather than gods (since as far as they know, gods don't really exist). The gods related to those ideas may respond to prayers, but in ways that do not directly influence the world. Basic idea being the gods are aware of the world but cannot touch it directly.

For Warlocks, it will depend on the patron and I'll have to think on that a bit. I can see GOO patrons not really caring about the pact signed by the others. And Fiends have recently begun an invasion (the first external plane to connect to this world in a long time) so those will be a simple solution. The rest... I'll have to ponder on.

I hadn't really thought of Sorcerors at the time, so I'll definitely have to think about that.

Thanks for bringing those up! Lots to consider with this setting design choice!

3
minusthedrifter•

And Fiends have recently begun an invasion (the first external plane to connect to this world in a long time) so those will be a simple solution

If fiends and devils have broken the pact then I don't see why the other planes and deities would remain shut off from the world. They'll certainly notice this breech and respond accordingly.

4
_WraithOP•

That's definitely part of the planned story

2
IanorenWizard•

Probably could have Tiefling slaves escaping the fiends. As a note, unless a devil found a loophole, they wouldn't break a pact. Demons on the other hand, well yeah they don't give any fucks

4
_WraithOP•

Oh that's a good point! I hadn't really fleshed out all of those details so it was just generic "fiends" at the moment, but I'll definitely keep that in mind when I get those details hammered out!

3
SyegfryedOrc Warlock•

planetouched races, like tiefling and aassimar and races that descend from the residents of the planes like elves an firbolgs who both have fey ancestry

5
TheBigMcTastyNow that's what we in the business call a "ruh-roh."•

Triton lore has them native to the Plane of Water, I think, so if there's never been any contact with that plane, they wouldn't exist either. Neither would aboleths or krakens, I think.

3
Amarhantus•

One thing is if you don't want those races, another thing is if you think they don't fit in your world. because there is always a way to reskin them.

For example Genasi could be no more of planar heritage but of fey heritage, they could be the products of the coupling of humans and feys bonded to vulcans (fire), lakes/rivers/seas (water), land/mountains (earth), winds (air). One example of fey bonded to water are the Undines.

Tiefling could be the descendants of a civilization so wicked and evil that with time they became no more human or that have been cursed by the gods. You may choose to make them resemble more humans or keep their demonic apparence, depending how much you want weird shaped adventurers.

Aasimar could be blessed babies, very rare, not really a race but babies bornt from a normal human couple but blessed by the gods. Think about Jean D'Arc but more fantasy.

2
_WraithOP•

I don't have any particular opinions on the races myself. I was more trying to make the world as "cohesive" as possible with the idea of not having much/any extraplanar influence.

These are definitely good ideas for reskinning, so that's something I'll keep in mind if I have a player that really wants to use a race I'd put on the "no" list. Thanks!

2
Amarhantus•

You're welcome ^ ^

1
Manigros•

Kalashtar, Gith, Centaurs, Satyrs, Genasi, some elves (Eladrin and Shadar-kai I think) maybe Tieflings and Aasimar (disconnected from fiendish and celesital Energy and beeings)

Minotaurs maybe, since they are Born by demonic worship, but can reproduce naturaly....

Definitily No gnolls(are No Player Race anyways)

That should be Most of them

2
Tharati•

When did this separation happened?

2
_WraithOP•

That seems to be a common question, so I edited the OP to add the info. But my general thought is that it happened a few thousand years ago, at least. Effectively, I don't want anyone living (or at least very very few) to know anything about the other planes.

1
jethomas27•

Would the oldest metallic dragons remember? Golds can live up to 4400 although that might be not long enough. I would expect it to be a few generations of dragons so some of them might know. Just a idea if you need to have someone tell the party about it

3
_WraithOP•

That's definitely an interesting idea! I'm still working on some of the hooks to get the players/characters into the story, and to provide them with some of the lore.

1
Scientin•

Aarakocra and Tritons both have origins in the elemental planes, so they're out. The new Hexblood might also be out, depends on whether or not you want Hags to be locked to the Feywild or if a few can still persist in the material plane.

2
Vulpes_Corsac•

If you're going with the default Forgotten Realms lore (and the disconnection from the other planes includes stuff like souls traveling to/from their gods' planes), then elves would be going extinct, unless the souls started to reincarnate without going to Corellon's plane first. Anything fey that's still around just didn't leave in the first place. Tiefling and Aasimar aren't FROM a different plane, but are rather mortals (humans) whose lineages were touched by planar powers. Thereafter, their children need no influence from the planes to be their race, but that's just the default lore and you're more than allowed to change that for your setting. And the proclivity for people to hate tieflings and for aasimar to go adventuring means they could've certainly died out. Genasi, if they knew about it before hand, would've probably gotten off-world before your sundering, but would be in the same boat as the other two you mentioned otherwise. Aaracockra are native to the elemental plane of air, so no flying bird people either.

The Gith travel in the astral plane all the time, and thus also probably wouldn't be on-world.

2
Spoolerdoing•

So Dragonborn are originally from Abeir in Forgotten Realms, with the main FR planet being Toril, they're technically on the same material plane but Abeir is in a pocket dimension out of sync with Toril. According to the lore, in the most recent Spellplague, they were transported to Toril (not even accurate to say -to- the prime material plane since they were technically from it already, albeit a messed up subdivision thereof).

Up to you how you want to interpret that, or if you want to use the FR interpretation at all.

Also, Dwarves were literally made by Moradin, so if the upper planes have no way to interact with Adriftworld, our best stout boys are out of luck. Similarly, Orcs and Gnolls will be completely different, free of the influence of Gruumsh and Yeenoghu.

Edit: Oh yeah, remember you'll need to come down one way or the other as to whether your world has Warforged. In fact, having them with certain traits of banned races might be a way of allowing game mechanic focused players play certain concepts. Similarly, MTG supplement races like Vedalken, Aetherborn and Simic Hybrid aren't technically planetouched but they're from elsewhere in the multiverse.

2
_WraithOP•

All good thoughts, but I also like "Adriftworld" lol

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1