Export falling out of sync from FCPX
I’ve never had this issue before but I’ve also never worked with a professional mixer until now. I’m a video editor currently trying to get a Final Cut sound mix ready through X2Pro for a protools user and although the AAF is transferring perfectly, my reference .mov file is not. Whenever I place the export back into my timeline to check for sync it’s thrown off by a few frames backwards and forwards. Any suggestions for this? Samplerate does not seem to be the issue.
Posted Mar 10, 2021, 4:33 AM UTC
that sucks. i just did this exact workflow last year and it does work. no clue what this could be.
ACTUALLY i did just remember one thing. if you are simplifying your timeline down prior to turnover (overwriting video/audio to the primary storyline), occasionally this can change total runtime by a frame. i can't remember why this happens, i think something to do with audio duration on the sub frame level. but you have to keep an eye on project duration as you do the overwrites.
this might also have happened on the detach audio from clip command too, can't recall.
that's probably not it but it's the only thing that comes to mind, good luck! let us know if you figure it out.
Ooh interesting. It only seems to be shifting 1 frame and some change now that I’ve updated the software. I did do the whole cleanup process but only for one scene for this test so far. Is there a way that I can avoid something like that from happening? This has been a several day thing so far and I’m sure our sound mixer is losing his patience a bit.
i'd need more detail to be able to speculate. you're saying
make AAF from timeline
make export from timeline
aaf is transferring perfectly (meaning it perfectly matches your timeline? how do you know)
export is off by a frame "and change" (this language throws me––the export should be an exact amount of frames)
if you haven't seen it here is the basic workflow i use for turnovers
maybe you have a variable frame rate file somewhere in the timeline?
edit:
rather than testing a scene, my next troubleshooting step would be to take the timeline, split it in half, repeat the process you've been doing, and see if the extra frame is in one or the other half. if it's in one, there's a weird clip somewhere in that half. if it's in both something much weirder is going on
You’re right, I don’t fully know that the AAF is good to go. It appears to match my timeline but I guess that’s all I really have to go off of. Since the export is also off when I put it back into the timeline that’s why have pointed to that as the problem area. 1.04 frames specifically. I’ll try that and see if it’s the kind of thing you’re saying, thank you.
this might be dumb, but i am not understanding how a reference video export can contain fractions of a frame. i’m fairly sure nothing i’ve exported has ever been a fraction of a frame, like, ever, in 10 years of doing this.
i can’t help but notice that 25/24 is ~1.04. any chance the timeline is in 24 but the reference video is in PAL, or vica versa?