r/Android•
jonask84

Made a free Tycoon-style Android game, wondering what you think

For the last half year I've been working on this Lemonade Tycoon style game for Android, and I was looking for some feedback and critisim if you have the time :)

The reason I made it was because I feel a lot of these games that are available for Android today are of a rather low quality, and I think the platform deserves better.

That's why I'm trying to polish this as much as I can and make it really shine, even though it's a rather simple concept. I'm still working on it, so I'd be cool to hear what other fans of the strategy game genre thought!

You can try the game for Free right here in the Android Market

Posted Nov 7, 2011, 12:44 AM UTC

1529
icky_booSGS1/2/3,Nexus7,Nexus5,Pebble,GPad,GPro2,Venue8pro,PadFoneX•

SWEEETTTT THANKS! , Been waiting on a decent Lemonade Tycoon fix for ages and that's the only thing I miss from my Winmo phone. The full version is kind of pricey though. Make it $1 and I'll buy now. Pressing the back button leaves the game, I'd make it go back a menu instead.

5
jonask84OP•

First off, thanks for the kind words! I know how you're feeling cause this is why i made it :)

Second, you're right; let's have a launch sale! 1 buck it is

3
icky_booSGS1/2/3,Nexus7,Nexus5,Pebble,GPad,GPro2,Venue8pro,PadFoneX•

I'm off to buy, btw What does it mean when the people just walk away from your pizza stand, I get the smiley face and the hands down but what's the other symbol? Also is there any rivals you need to contend with like a big multinational (Pizza House or Tri-Ominos could be good in game names for them) comes in and offers to buy you out or you could go and franchise (by borrowing money from bank at set interest then if you don't pay back by end of month they can start to repo items from the shop or even the whole shop) your pizza shop for a % of profits , then you can really be a Pizza Tycoon by buying up their shares/stores (or by making/loosing money on side by having a ingame shares market which could pull some data from real stock sites just to make it more realistic and interesting) . I haven't played the game much as I'm not making too much profit yet so I don't know how the game actually goes further in (Do you get to hire people and sell drinks too?). I have SOME experience with running a shop irl (Parents own a bakery) so I might be able to give you some ideas . Games like Game Dev Story are very good because they follow history DAMN NEAR PERFECTLY so I reckon you should look into the Pizza Wars of the 80's and 90's in the USA (I remember watching a Docu about Pizza Hut and Dominoes) and maybe the expansion of the pizza business worldwide to places like India to give you some more ideas with the game.I'll stop mumbling and play the game now.

2
jonask84OP•

This is really interesting, thanks for the detailed feedback man

My first priority (I've been working on the game for over six months) was to get the quality and gameplay up to a state where it's playable and maybe even enjoyable. Now I'm starting to dig into how to give it more depth, so your feedback is well placed!

It is a tricky thing to balance amount of work something takes to make and the fun it is to play, so I really appreciate hearing other people's ideas

I too am a big fan of the Kairosoft games, I think they're the best strategy games out there for Android, and I really do hope I one day can match them in terms of complexity. It's hard to do with just one guy though :)

Thanks for the feedback, and thanks for testing the game! I'm taking it all down and I'm gonna look at what I can do to add more dimensions to the game

1
icky_booSGS1/2/3,Nexus7,Nexus5,Pebble,GPad,GPro2,Venue8pro,PadFoneX•

Not a problem :) I'll be keeping a eye out on this game. The only thing I can recommend is don't try updating this game forever but go make a new version or something else after a year to help you get a fresh perspective on things instead of being blinded by adding many small steps and fixes. You could always go make a Fast Food tycoon like game where you try to make the best secret recipe (by growing and experimenting) and end game target is to make the company use all organic ingredients by putting more of the game into raising orgainic chickens/cows/veggies and transportation costs all the while maintaining the normal day to day running of the bussiness like it is in Pizza Tycoon (You can recycle the old game's code for this). Eventaually when you become more confident you could combine all of my ideas into one big ass game for the hardcore crowd and sell it in smaller chunks for more causal players . sell each game for $1 and then somehow get all the games to plugin to each other

2
icky_booSGS1/2/3,Nexus7,Nexus5,Pebble,GPad,GPro2,Venue8pro,PadFoneX•

Btw, Is there something I can do in Pizza Tycoon to put money into marketing, Ie, hire some kid to give out flyers/newspaper/radio/tv to get more customers or offer daily / weekly / monthly specials like 2 for ones or free drinks with my pizza? If not, I would recommend you add that into the game asap as that's pretty much standard in bussiness. Don't forget about Dine in pizza resturantes where you have to manage waiters/cooks and cleaners, That would be the first thing I would expland the game into after the marketing. Hell there's games out there all about just managing people in a resturante :)

2
tucci999Galaxy S4, HTC One, LG G2•

I agree with most everyone great little game payed the dollar for it, might like to see my upgrades like a boom box or an umbrella or something.

3
jonask84OP•

That's actually something I've been wanting to do myself. Only skipped it because it will take some time to draw and implement. But it's probably gonna come soon :)

Thanks for testing!

1
danstu•

I keep accidentally hitting the "end the day" button when I go for the "fast forward" one. Think you could move them a little further apart?

Looks good so far. Worth the download at least.

EDIT: Also, in the into screens, the second to last screen spells the character's name differently than all the other ones.

2
jonask84OP•

Thanks, good catch! I will see about moving those a little further apart

Thanks for testing!

1
GoGratsHTC Sensation 4G•

Since you listened to your customer and brought it down to a dollar I couldnt say no to purchasing it. I'll give it a go tomorrow installing now!

2
jonask84OP•

Sure, it's just money :) Hope you like the game

1
citking•

I bought it. I like it! The only things I wanted to add:

-The text on the QuickBake Mega Oven is cut off. The last few words say "...but at the cost of" and then it just cuts off.

-Gotten about 3 or 4 random crashes (HTC Desire CDMA). I sent reports to you so hopefully that'll nail down whatever is causing this.

-A descriptive Help menu option would be nice, especially one that explains the graphic balloons above peoples' heads.

-The Stock Room sliders seem to default to different values after every day. I'm not sure if it is designed to do that or not.

-The sliders for the Recipe and Ingredients screen are very touchy. It is difficult to lock in a price without accidentally getting a dime lower or higher than you intended.

-Rotation doesn't seem to be enabled. That might be something that's harder to do than I think it is though.

-Lastly, upgrading from the Lite to the full app (like I did) loses all of your stuff. It'd be nice to be able to move seamlessly from the lite to the full version without having to start all over.

Those are the only things I have come across thus far. Otherwise I like the game and have just about gotten 100% reputation in all the areas!

Great app!

2
jonask84OP•

Dude, thanks! Best feedback I could have asked for, you helped me sort out a bunch of bugs!

I'm pretty much working on all of the above, and I can't thank you enough for sending in those crash reports. They really do help. (turns out i had a race condition that wasn't showing up on my old crappy dev phone)

1
citking•

Sweet! Glad you got it figured out!

I'll provide more feedback if I come across anything else but so far everything seems good!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dandmcdnubia N5 Mini•

Installing now and will play before I sleep tonight and give you some feedback tomorrow. It looks fun, I enjoy these tycoon style games!

1
docodine•

was this made for hvga devices or something? can barely see what's going on with the bad scaling

1
jonask84OP•

It's supposed to work for all densities and resolutions, but as you probably know that's quite hard :) Especially with pixel art graphics. I'm sorry it doesn't work too good on your device, I simply had no other choice than to redraw the graphics for all the resolutions

Thanks for testing it thought!

1
[deleted]•

Scalable vector graphics?

1
jonask84OP•

Yes, that's a good point, but technically hard to do. All the artwork has to be converted somehow and interpreted by the engine properly. I guess it's something to think of for the next game :)

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
SharkUWNexus 4•

Edit:

Oh wow. Screw what I had here before. Fuck this guy. This isn't even thinly veiled. I realized that the same dev/company has a bunch of other shitty games as well. This guy is the god damn problem with the market.

0
jonask84OP•

You think I am the problem with the Android Market?

Not rampant pirating.

Not spamming of shit apps.

Not the stealing and re-releasing of other people's apps and games

Not the complete disregard for copyrights and trademarks

But ME: The hobby game developer that after working for six months releases his game to you for a BUCK. I preview it here at a 60% discount because i like Reddit and I respect (most) people here's opinion, and YES, if a few people choose to give it a good rating or buy it (I've sold seven copies now) I'll happily that too. Did you know the pirates opens hundreds of fake Google accounts to rate and comment on their own stolen apps?

I will MAYBE make $50 in total on this game. If it's not stolen or pirated the shit out of. Still i keep making Android stuff because i believe in the platform and I enjoy making games in my spare time.

So because you don't like the game, In your eyes; I am the problem.

1
SharkUWNexus 4•

Yep

1
jonask84OP•

Well alright, I totally don't agree but it's not my place to tell you how to feel.

I'll just try and make it better, so I guess if you have any specific things you hated about it I'd like to try and fix it?

1
SharkUWNexus 4•

Wow, you are the problem with the market. Just releasing yet another shitty game. I took a bit of pity on you until I realized that you've also already released other shitty games. Fuck you. Take your shit elsewhere and please don't vote this marketer's post up.

-9
ZellgadissGalaxy Nexus•

If you bothered to check his posts you'd see he's an active poster. Mainly about android and game dev. Give the guy a break. It's not like he's got 20 games out there. It's 3. 2 are lite, free editions of his games.

That being said I do think there should be an app/devtips subreddit.

3
icky_booSGS1/2/3,Nexus7,Nexus5,Pebble,GPad,GPro2,Venue8pro,PadFoneX•

Man, You have gone full retard

2