Japanese authorities discover a new coronavirus variant in traveler from Philippines

https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2021/03/13/national/new-variant-philippines/

Most important piece: "The National Institute of Infectious Diseases is calling for stronger border control measures as part of efforts to curb the spread of the virus and it is keeping an eye on whether the Philippine variant is spreading in Japan."

Hope we all (especially the 2020 group) get to go soon!

Posted Mar 13, 2021, 9:50 PM UTC

4252
flynolo•

I hope that finding new variants of a virus isn't surprising anyone, the news makes it seems like a virus has never evolved before -_-

25
2021JetProgrammeOPUpgraded JET - Current Placement: My House•

I think the main concern is mostly over a variant appearing that the vaccines won't work for. Naturally more base variants mean further changed new variants, which means we're just gambling with it. Each one just carries that worry it that it might be the big one to screw us all over, and places like Brazil aren't helping right now.

Edit: Lots of downvotes, if someone thinks that there's a different concern I'd love to hear it. Discussion and other people's opinions are always welcome!

-4†
ALPHAS-B•

Funnily enough there seems to be some research and speculation coming out that these kinds of overly restrictive measures may have caused more mutations in the wrong direction to actually happen, and that the specific type of vaccines we are using might promote 'immune escape'. You 'gamble' either way. But just notice the words, may, and might; justifying certain and significantly harmful policies on abstract and unknown possibilities, no matter how small that possibility may well be, isn't exactly the pinnacle of reasoning and numerical literacy.

6
2021JetProgrammeOPUpgraded JET - Current Placement: My House•

Could you link some research in regards to your first sentence, I'd be interested in reading up on it. The closest thing I could find to immune escape was this paper https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6527/329 which states that the immune escape worry is created from the time period between each of the two needed vaccine shots. From my knowledge, mRNA vaccines could be updated in 2-4 weeks to deal with a new variant though. I'd argue the main concern then is us vaccinating everyone and returning to normal, then having a new one pop up and no one realize it's covid since we're all vaccinated. I may be able to better understand your points if you could hook me up with some sources though, either way thanks for sharing your opinion!

2
ALPHAS-B•

That nitty gritty stuff isn't really the point I was trying to make so I can't link you with oodles of research (most of which I haven't read or actually researched), but the immune escape argument is based on long term damage to our natural immunity leading to an over-reliance on vaccines for all disease. I'm not a virologist and I don't have an opinion on it, nor could I actually have a credible opinion on it; so it's up to you to think about if it piques your interest. What I'm trying to make is a rational argument about overly risk averse thinking, not an empirical one about theoretical virology that neither of us probably understand. I don't believe that the speculation about either of the things I mentioned is justification for doing something drastic like halting vaccination programmes or throwing restrictions away.

What the issue to me is, is that the 'science' starts to quickly become irrelevant when people cherry pick what is often early research and run away with it despite what has often ended up being rapidly mounting research for the opposite, or even previously a fairly strong consensus against it. If all we do is cherry pick our chosen risk or few studies that we read out of confirmation bias, and then apply a risk tolerance of 0 to it, you can make an argument to drastically restrict anything. Which leads us full circle to being worried about the very abstract possibility of one of our actions bringing about the deadly plague of the 'big one to screw us all over'; the idea is so unverifiable, the risk so remote that if that's the standard for having any kind of return to normality, I'm not sure how we'd ever meet that with any disease or risk in this world. If we're being that risk averse, I'm not sure how it makes any sense to go with that risk (which I personally believe is minute) over something like UNICEF's repeated projections (based on COVID related food scarcity that is already happening), that third world starvation due to COVID related restrictions will cause deaths that far outnumber what COVID has currently done and will ever do. There seems to be a potentially infinite number of known and much bigger risks you could just as easily pick from.

4
edmar10•

Here's a newer article just published yesterday in Science also. This one is saying its definitely something to watch but not to be too concerned, there's more to the immune response than just measuring antibody levels and doing neutralization tests in vitro, plus different studies are using different assays so comparing them isn't too useful anyways.

https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6534/1103.full

Although neutralizing antibody titer against B.1.1.7 was reduced approximately ninefold (from a mean of about 1/500 neutralizing antibody titer against wild-type virus), this did not affect vaccine efficacy because there was no enhanced susceptibility to infection

I heard also you can update the mRNA vaccines really quickly, Moderna shipped out their updated vaccines to test in South Africa in under a month since they started working on it. The problem is you'd most likely have to give everybody who already got the old "wildtype" vaccine the updated one also and that'd take a while of course.

Good news as far as this thread is concerned should be that the data coming out of Israel seems to indicate that the vaccines stop most of the spread of the virus so a "vaccine passport" could be a viable option.

2
emma_bemmCursed 2020 JET•

Wish they'd accept that variants will be part of the process whether the border is open or not, just look around to other countries and their situations. Also, don't they have their own variant?

25
purplefriiday•

I don't think it's really fair to be like "oh well variants are just a thing that happens" given the absolute nightmare that emerged with the UK variant. It's better to be cautious.

8
whatever84826•

Better to be cautious. Close the borders for another 300 years. Better to be safe than sorry. ✌🏻

How many times do we need to move the goal posts for entry? Aren't the new quarantine protocols enough (now THREE negative covid tests required) in addition to a government run facility quarantine for 3 days. Plus many new entrants will be fully vaccinated, providing an additional (strong) layer of protection. But yep, better wrap up those borders, don't want any corona naka naka dashi.

The way I see it, there is no way you can mitigate risk 100%. The virus will be around indefinitely. The virus will continue to mutate, producing a range of new variants. The solution is to either close the borders indefinitely (for years), or you start bringing workers/students into your borders with more effective entry/quarantine requirements, or limit entry to those who have been fully vaccinated, etc. There has to be a solution. Either tell us this entry process will take years so we can finally get rid of our blue balls and abandon our plans to enter, or commence entry with strict protocols in place. No more carrot dangling. The lack of communication has been disgusting.

9
purplefriiday•

There's no way to mitigate risk 100%, but the way I see it is I've been able to live my life almost normally since last summer so Japan is doing something right at the very least. God knows what that 'something' is, but either way we've done far better than many other countries.

I understand you're frustrated with the delays, and it really sucks and I honestly don't envy your position. I'd have dropped out and I would have been devastated. But all the incoming JETs being armchair epidemiologists and thinking they know better because of this frustration is getting old.

I've long given up on moaning about the Japanese government because something is working, life isn't that bad here and we've had no strict lockdowns. I'm in an area that's still under the SoE and the only thing I can't do is go out to a bar or restaurant after 8pm. If the whole country being able to live as normal means keeping the borders closed, so be it.

And you can't really fault the lack of communication because it's the government. The government absolutely do not care about a bunch of foreign ALTs. CLAIR honestly doesn't even care about us either, so I'd get the idea that they're supposed to help us out of your head before you eventually arrive. And your consolate is simply the go-between, so it's unfair if you are blaming them.

I have huge sympathy for all the incoming JETs but seriously, your energy would be spent better elsewhere instead of complaining about reddit because you literally have no control over anything.

-5
whatever84826•

I'm honestly tired of talking with people like you. And what about Taiwan and South Korea that handled the pandemic better than Japan without sacrificing the livelihoods of students and workers in the process? Even New Zealand allows graduate students and postdoctoral researchers into their borders. Not Japan, though.

Frustrated would be an understatement. Imagine waiting a year to enter the next phase of your career development while nearly going bankrupt in the process. I linger around these forums because it's one of the only places I can talk about this with people that understand. I'm not an ALT, but a postdoctoral academic researcher with a government sponsored fellowship. I'm not joining some ho dunk lab, but a leading expert that regularly publishes in Nature and comparably high tier journals with the specific expertise I'm seeking to develop. Why wouldn't I continue to wait?

You don't need to be an epidemiologist to see how retarded Japan has handled entry of foreign workers where other countries with lower numbers, better handling of quarantine, and testing infrastructure have succeeded. Not to mention, Japan's domestic Go-to-get-Corona campaigns that faithfully propagated the virus throughout the country. Sounds like Japan's epidemiologists are really great at their jobs!

Wow, I'm so glad you can enjoy a nice bowl of ramen before 8 pm like normal at the expense of those waiting to enter. Really happy for you. We already have to adhere to strict measures to enter the country (we're up to 3 negative covid tests now with an additional 3-day quarantine at government designated facility). Some of us will be fully vaccinated soon and will effectively be unable to transmit the virus. If I had to venture a guess, the risk of transmitting covid is essentially zero when all of the mitigating factors mentioned above are combined. But full disclosure, I'm not an epidemiologist.

And again, there's already two other East Asian countries (Taiwan and South Korea) that have allowed workers/students into their borders without sacrificing normalcy.

4
the_incense_man•

The something that's working is not testing anyone and pretending there isn't a problem. My state with a population of ~7 million has conducted more tests than Japan with a population of ~130 million since the beginning of the pandemic.

3
Abradolf1948•

Yeah but the problem is that the UK variant has been detected in other countries, even with strict border laws. Many people suspect it didn't originate there, but was simply discovered there because they had better identification methods.

6
[deleted]•

But the variant was already in basically every country by the time they detected it. Acting like you can just slam the door on it is going to waste everyone's time. Just vaccinate and then this shit won't be an issue.

4
emma_bemmCursed 2020 JET•

That's a fair point. They have every right to decide their own approach.

1†
2021JetProgrammeOPUpgraded JET - Current Placement: My House•

Every country has had its own variants, you can check here: https://filogeneti.ca/covizu/

However, only certain variants change enough for us to be worried. The UK, South Africa, and Brazil variants were the most worrisome so far, and obviously this one is different enough for there to be concern. Naturally I agree with you that they should work to safely open the border with haste, but no country should just "accept" it, it should be thoroughly watched and regarded as important.

4
128thMicCurrent JET - Shinjo city, Yamagata•

Every country has had its own variants, you can check here: https://filogeneti.ca/covizu/

I don't know why, but that makes my Pokémon Go instincts tingle.

"Regional variants! Must catch them all wait no don't do that!"

4

and your covidex needs to be filled up with new entries!

1
NoConflict3Current JET - Tokyo•

Typically, viral mutations happen if they move across racial divides because of greater genetic diversity across racial divides.

That's why we have the UK Variant, the SA Variant, and the Brazilian Variant. It, arguably, originated in an Asian population so a variant is rarer to happen. With newer genetic material to learn from an adapt to and replicate in, mutations occur.

1
MariamaticCurrent JET•

What about instead of stronger border controls, actually fucking vaccinate like the rest of the developed world? Apparently basic common sense is too much to ask as usual

24
Seven_Seas_007•

Tell that to Canada. Lmao we're behind just about everyone for vaccinations because Trudeau screwed up on the contract.

6

With what vaccinations? They're still being rolled out/in production. I believe the wider rollout in Japan is expected in September idk when the wider roll out is expected in the Philippines but they had a problem with vaccines causing adverse side effects for dengue fever while back so idk how keen they are on vaccinations. The sensible thing to do while awaiting further roll out is to control the borders.

4†
MariamaticCurrent JET•

They refuse to even approve any additional vaccines and it's not a supply issue, they could do more if they actually cared even slightly. It would be one thing if they were doing everything they can and it was just impossible, but they don't even want to expedite the process. There's no excuse to be this far behind literally every other developed county other than pure incompetence.

8
NoConflict3Current JET - Tokyo•

It's not incompetence it's that the Pharma industry in Japan is one of the most corrupt in the world.

When you have an aging population like Japan that is being kept alive with drugs and medicine, Pharma has all the power. Until the government is willing to fork over the money "required" to vaccinate they simply won't release the product.

2
PHornyOnMain•

At least the pace of the vaccine rollout in Japan has accelerated somewhat in the past few days.

3
2021JetProgrammeOPUpgraded JET - Current Placement: My House•

If I recall correctly, wasn't the population of Japan averse to vaccines after a previous vaccine for something different ended up killing a couple kids? Obviously they should still fully role out the Covid-19 vaccine, but it's not like their skepticism isn't unfounded. Hopefully as they see the rest of the world safely roll out the vaccine, more people in Japan will feel safer taking it!

-2†
MariamaticCurrent JET•

Idk why everyone constantly makes apologetics for Japanese antivaxers as if they actually have a good reason to be willfully ignorant. It's still anti-science nonsense and the evidence is already clear from the tens of millions worldwide who have been safely vaccinated, they deserve the same derision and disregard as western antivaxers.

16
NoConflict3Current JET - Tokyo•

I wouldn't call Japanese people anti-vaxxers.

I think it's apathy, most Japanese people I've talked to simply don't care about getting the vaccine, but they aren't afraid of getting it, nor are they espousing the "dangers of vaccination."

Japan has a long history of being against vaccination. But they know it comes with risk.

1
ALPHAS-B•

I don't think that's fair at all to tar them with the horrible brush of 'antivaxxer'. That's extreme thinking and it's poisoning the well so much that it doesn't really help discussions. I don't know why their rollout is so slow but if it was due to scepticism, it's easy to see how someone can not necessarily be anti science or anti vaccine and still be worried about the mid and long term effects (which we are essentially trialling in real time). It's interesting to see many people be cautious about every possibility around COVID variants and spread, but dogmatic when someone applies that same high level of caution to some of the vaccines. Although I don't personally think thats a great reason, especially in terms of Japan's highly aged society, where many of the first to use it probably won't be living to deal with any of those potential effects anyway; I'm just tired of seeing labels like antivax get thrown around out of righteous dogma and eventually get watered down. It's going to be basically meaningless at this rate just like when people used to call everyone who was even slightly not conservative or to the left a 'commie'

-2†
[deleted]•

it's easy to see how someone can not necessarily be anti science or anti vaccine and still be worried about the mid and long term effects (which we are essentially trialling in real time).

If you're against vaccines based on vague feelings and ignore the fact that it's safe, you ARE antivax. Japan has an antivax issue, regardless of what happened historically.

5
MariamaticCurrent JET•

It's literally accurate though. There's zero legitimate reason to be skeptical of safety when you're like 100 millionth in line other than ignorant fear mongering over a fake news story from a decade ago. I'm sure western antivaxers genuinely believe it will give their kids autism or whatever other bullshit and genuinely think they're just being cautious, but it's still completely unfounded and justly condemned by pretty much everyone. When it happens in Japan giving them a pass for some reason is just implying they aren't capable of the same standards of critical thinking we hold our own countries citizens to. Calling them antivaxers is actually being charitable, my real opinion on the situation is much more inflammatory.

3†
jiminahanaIncoming CIR - 2020•

Since the State of Emergency in Tokyo and neighbouring prefectures is currently set to end on March 21, we're going to see an announcement either extending or ending it next week. Currently, it seems that the latter is more likely.

However, even if SoE would end, it wouldn't necessarily mean that new arrivals would be allowed in again. Having no SoE is just one prerequisite for relaxing border controls.

Either way, it will be interesting to see what changes next week. There have been some slight tweaks in in policy, like arrival limits and adjustments to quarantine procedures during the last few days, so I have a hunch there is going to be at least something changing in the immigration policy.

19

Also, how can the border control measure be any stronger than now?

18
2021JetProgrammeOPUpgraded JET - Current Placement: My House•

Honestly not sure how they could make them "stronger," main concern is further reason to maintain the current border control measures. I don't want the 2021 group to end up like the 2020 group lol.

5†
Cloud7831•

I'm not really sure why you got down voted, but as someone who is a 2020 JET, I too hope you don't have to go through what we went through. It really sucked and I wouldn't wish that on anyone else :p

11
2021JetProgrammeOPUpgraded JET - Current Placement: My House•

Thank you for the kindness and understanding. Hope the best for the 2020 group!

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
the_incense_man•

Your point on Australia, China, and Korea is incorrect. That has been suspended since the beginning of January.

2
[deleted]•

Ah let me delete it then. I apologize. I was also going off the government site. Thanks for letting me know in a respectful manner!

Here is the list I was basing my post off of.

https://www.mofa.go.jp/ca/fna/page4e_001053.html

5
the_incense_man•

No worries just don't wanna get people's hopes up haha

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2†
Xela1102•

Stronger border control would be them closing off the borders completely at this point, which isn’t right. They already don’t allow any new people to come in and the ones they do bring in are quarantined for 2 weeks and tested. Maybe only allow people in who have been vaccinate, which is still a little too much to ask for. Guess we’ll see at the end of March what they’ll do, when the state of emergency is possibly lifted.

18
2021JetProgrammeOPUpgraded JET - Current Placement: My House•

The testing/quarantine should have already been the regarded norm, and should have definitely been offered to foreign workers a long time ago. If your company values you enough then they'd assist in your quarantine and take the responsibility if you did something stupid. This way foreign workers would still have the ability to enter the country, and there's no reason why JET couldn't have backed their applicants in this method. But bureaucracy.

-5†
Xela1102•

Yeah it does suck that stuff like politics can get in the way. Japan does seem to be on track to meet there goals to lift the state of emergency, even with other variants as a factor. Hopefully the travel restrictions will lessen too.

2
2021JetProgrammeOPUpgraded JET - Current Placement: My House•

I surely hope they do, I also hope the Olympics works in our favor by lessening restrictions further and developing a safer and less restrictive travel measures.

-5

I really hope that man from the Philippine was there for absolutely essential reason. Also I hope this means Japan will give up on becoming a hermit kingdom through this pandemic. It doesn't really work. Just open the border and ask travellers to do hotel quarantine for 2-3 weeks and severely penalize them for breaking the quarantine rules. (e.g. UK imposing 10-year jail terms for travellers violating quarantine rule)

10
nightless_hunter•

This will only make Japan become more hermit than before

1†

Damn, way to shit all over our dreams (Again), damn Coronavirus.

7
TrowaBartons•

Its not covid doing it. Its the Japanese government and their policy

3