Japanese authorities discover a new coronavirus variant in traveler from Philippines
https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2021/03/13/national/new-variant-philippines/
Most important piece: "The National Institute of Infectious Diseases is calling for stronger border control measures as part of efforts to curb the spread of the virus and it is keeping an eye on whether the Philippine variant is spreading in Japan."
Hope we all (especially the 2020 group) get to go soon!
Posted Mar 13, 2021, 9:50 PM UTC
I hope that finding new variants of a virus isn't surprising anyone, the news makes it seems like a virus has never evolved before -_-
I think the main concern is mostly over a variant appearing that the vaccines won't work for. Naturally more base variants mean further changed new variants, which means we're just gambling with it. Each one just carries that worry it that it might be the big one to screw us all over, and places like Brazil aren't helping right now.
Edit: Lots of downvotes, if someone thinks that there's a different concern I'd love to hear it. Discussion and other people's opinions are always welcome!
Funnily enough there seems to be some research and speculation coming out that these kinds of overly restrictive measures may have caused more mutations in the wrong direction to actually happen, and that the specific type of vaccines we are using might promote 'immune escape'. You 'gamble' either way. But just notice the words, may, and might; justifying certain and significantly harmful policies on abstract and unknown possibilities, no matter how small that possibility may well be, isn't exactly the pinnacle of reasoning and numerical literacy.
Could you link some research in regards to your first sentence, I'd be interested in reading up on it. The closest thing I could find to immune escape was this paper https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6527/329 which states that the immune escape worry is created from the time period between each of the two needed vaccine shots. From my knowledge, mRNA vaccines could be updated in 2-4 weeks to deal with a new variant though. I'd argue the main concern then is us vaccinating everyone and returning to normal, then having a new one pop up and no one realize it's covid since we're all vaccinated. I may be able to better understand your points if you could hook me up with some sources though, either way thanks for sharing your opinion!
That nitty gritty stuff isn't really the point I was trying to make so I can't link you with oodles of research (most of which I haven't read or actually researched), but the immune escape argument is based on long term damage to our natural immunity leading to an over-reliance on vaccines for all disease. I'm not a virologist and I don't have an opinion on it, nor could I actually have a credible opinion on it; so it's up to you to think about if it piques your interest. What I'm trying to make is a rational argument about overly risk averse thinking, not an empirical one about theoretical virology that neither of us probably understand. I don't believe that the speculation about either of the things I mentioned is justification for doing something drastic like halting vaccination programmes or throwing restrictions away.
What the issue to me is, is that the 'science' starts to quickly become irrelevant when people cherry pick what is often early research and run away with it despite what has often ended up being rapidly mounting research for the opposite, or even previously a fairly strong consensus against it. If all we do is cherry pick our chosen risk or few studies that we read out of confirmation bias, and then apply a risk tolerance of 0 to it, you can make an argument to drastically restrict anything. Which leads us full circle to being worried about the very abstract possibility of one of our actions bringing about the deadly plague of the 'big one to screw us all over'; the idea is so unverifiable, the risk so remote that if that's the standard for having any kind of return to normality, I'm not sure how we'd ever meet that with any disease or risk in this world. If we're being that risk averse, I'm not sure how it makes any sense to go with that risk (which I personally believe is minute) over something like UNICEF's repeated projections (based on COVID related food scarcity that is already happening), that third world starvation due to COVID related restrictions will cause deaths that far outnumber what COVID has currently done and will ever do. There seems to be a potentially infinite number of known and much bigger risks you could just as easily pick from.
Here's a newer article just published yesterday in Science also. This one is saying its definitely something to watch but not to be too concerned, there's more to the immune response than just measuring antibody levels and doing neutralization tests in vitro, plus different studies are using different assays so comparing them isn't too useful anyways.
https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6534/1103.full
I heard also you can update the mRNA vaccines really quickly, Moderna shipped out their updated vaccines to test in South Africa in under a month since they started working on it. The problem is you'd most likely have to give everybody who already got the old "wildtype" vaccine the updated one also and that'd take a while of course.
Good news as far as this thread is concerned should be that the data coming out of Israel seems to indicate that the vaccines stop most of the spread of the virus so a "vaccine passport" could be a viable option.